Essay about Presumption Of Innocence 3

Words: 3579
Pages: 15
Open Document
To what extent has the 'presumption of innocence' enunciated in the case Woolmington v DPP [1935] AC 462 vis-a-vis criminal cases changed in light of the Human Rights Act 1998? Discuss.
History
The sixth century Digest of Justinian (22.3.2) provides, as a general rule of evidence: Ei incumbit probatio qui dicit, non qui negat - Proof lies on him who asserts, not on him who denies”. It is there attributed to the second and third century jurist Paul. Similar to its Romanic predecessor, Islamic law also holds the principle that the onus of proof is on the claimant, based on a hadith documented by Imam Nawawi. The collapse of Western Modern Empire gave way to the rise of feudalistic justice system. Within it, there was no concept of …show more content…
With the result that s.28 must be read as if it imposed only an evidential burden on the accused, the word ‘proves’ as used in s.28 must be construed to mean ‘give sufficient evidence’, by employing s.3 of the HRA 1998.
Test of proportionality – how could a reverse onus to be justified? As a result of Lambert, it is submitted that the imposition of reverse legal burdens of its prima facie incompatible with Art6 of the ECHR, and must be scrutinized with great care in light of the principle of proportionality.
However, House of Lords also made it clear that not all legal burdens were placed on a defendant in criminal trial violated the ECHR or Art6(2) in particular. The court held, it was not an absolute right in all the circumstances. In Salabiaku v France, the ECtHR stated that some reverse burdens of proof are ‘convention compliant.
Hence the courts must ensure every reverse onus clause in English law must be measured for convention compliance. Although it is apparent that the onus on those seeking to persuade the courts that a reverse burden is necessary is heavy, the courts continue to uphold such provisions. In Sheldrake their Lordships also concluded that when conducting an assessment of proportionality, it was necessary to balance society’s interest in the effective suppression of a social
Show More

Related Documents: Essay about Presumption Of Innocence 3

Justice in America Essay

The forensic evidence suggested faulty electrical wiring or some building defect as the likely cause, not arson, but scientific facts could not derail a hardwired determination that because Taylor was black, he had to be at fault. His youth, his innocence, and even his dramatic work to save and comfort the victims were imperceptible and irrelevant. Outraged citizens wanted the death penalty. A profiler was brought in who swore under oath that the likely perpetrator was “a black teenager.” Taylor…

Words 1137 - Pages 5

Legal Essay

Legal essay – David Hicks and Bikes The legal system has responded to the challenges created by contemporary issues we have studied in class recently such as David Hicks and Bikies in multiple ways and areas. There are 3 categories legal responses to organised motorcycle gangs fall into, these are; passing laws to prosecute individuals for the specific crime that they have committed, such as assault, drug offences or money laundering. The second being creating police task forces or police powers…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Legal Studies Essay

acceptance of the increased terrorist threat has created increased infringements on an individual’s right to freedoms. One of the most basic rights of an individual has been undermined by the Bail Amendment Act 2014. The accused’s presumption of innocence as defined under Section 3 of the Bail Act 2013 has been completely removed. This has clearly undermined an individual’s basic right to be treated fairly. In turn, a major public backlash occurred as evident in the Sydney Morning Herald Article, Law reform…

Words 669 - Pages 3

Essay on Courts: Jury and United States

The Judicial Process Courts The Judicial Process There are many components that make up the judicial process. If someone wanted to know the key parts of the judicial process I would start by telling them the types of laws and what they mean. When it comes to laws there is common law and there is statutory laws are the types of laws that are applied here in our judicial system. The next component of our judicial process is the staffing of the…

Words 3416 - Pages 14

Legal studies exam revision Essay

evidence to support a conviction in a higher court. If yes it will be sent to country or supreme and a committal mention date will be set ii) Strict Liability Crime: Crimes where mens rea is not required by the prosecution. E.g. parking fines iii) 3 differences between criminal and civil law Civil Criminal Concerned with Rights and responsibilities of individuals Offences against society Resolution Remedies such as compensation/providing a service Defendant receives punishment Standard…

Words 2208 - Pages 9

nothing ishere Essay

Standard of proof: United States[edit] Burden of proof refers most generally to the obligation of a party to prove its allegations at trial. In a civil case the plaintiff sets forth its allegations in a complaint, petition or other pleading. The defendant is then required to file a responsive pleading denying some or all of the allegations and setting forth any affirmative facts in defense affirmative defenses. Each party has the burden of proof of their allegations. Legal standards[edit] Reasonable…

Words 3228 - Pages 13

Dna Profile Research Paper

INTRODUCTION The purpose of this investigation is to investigate if everyone’s DNA profile should be stored on a DNA database. Three intended student leanings will be addressed, including M16.1, M17.1 and M17.2. This will take place by investigating the question Should everyone's DNA profile be registered with a database? This will be achieved by investigating the possible individual, social and global negative and positive effects of this idea. A DNA database, is a database containing DNA profiles…

Words 1426 - Pages 6

Death Penalty Research Paper

Schwindt 1 accepted as his condemnation of physical retaliation ( though most scholars agree that the latter passage was "certainly not part of the original text of St John's Gospel) More militant Christians consider Romans 13:3–4 to support the death penalty”(Wikipedia), but is it right to do such a thing? Is there a reason for having the death penalty? In some cases “Death Penalty support becomes a minority opinion when the public is presented with a variety of alternative sentences”…

Words 1246 - Pages 5

Criminal Justice Essay

chastise her and state that I do not agree with her derogatory remarks and would report her to Internal Affairs and the Mayor and City Council’s office. She would be subject to legal scrutiny and possible dismissal from her duties. Ethical Dilemmas 3: Accepting Favors I would start my investigation of the gun advocacy group with agreeing with the next county’s Chief of Police about his officer’s unethical behavior. This may be acceptable habits and “good old boy” policy in his county but I would…

Words 1204 - Pages 5

Brief Cupp V Murphy Case Brief

Criminal Justice I. Brief Cupp v. Murphy 412 U.S. 291, 93 S.Ct. 2000, 36 L.Ed.2d 900 (1973) Merits: The respondent, Daniel Murphy, was convicted by a jury in an Oregon court of the second-degree murder of his wife. The victim died by strangulation in her home in the city of Portland, and abrasions and lacerations were found on her throat. There was no sign of a break-in or robbery. Word of the murder was sent to the estranged husband…

Words 1177 - Pages 5