Pros And Cons Of Utilitarianism

Words: 1613
Pages: 7
Open Document
Utilitarianism is a moral philosophy created by Jeremy Bentham during the enlightenment. Like his peers during this time, Bentham, attempted understand the world around him through reason and intellect which inspired him to create a moral philosophy that would mirror that sort of thought. Utilitarianism, as an ethical theory, in its simplest form is: seeking decisions that produce pleasure over pain. Bentham writes “Nature has placed mankind under the governance of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure” (Bentham 1.1). Putting this into practice is called hedonic calculus where the ends must justify the means and it is measured in units of hedons. The idea of hedonic calculus and Utilitarianism is that when making a decision a person would …show more content…
But it can also be applied to less important decisions equally as well. Take the United States government for example. There is a massive grid-lock at the moment where almost no legislation is being passed due to party politics. However if Utilitarianism were to be applied to the government, decisions would be quite easy. Maybe take an environment policy or an economic policy, the theory would analyze the pros and cons of the decision without bias to easily come up with a solution that helps the greater good. Because isn’t that what government is for? Helping the majority of people live a happy and productive life. Which is exactly what Utilitarianism would accomplish if applied to society. Another way Utilitarianism can be productive in decision making is when the decision would conflict with other moral philosophies. Henry Sidgwick, a proponent of Utilitarianism, states that “…we require some higher principle to decide the issue…”(Sidgwick 181). The higher principle he was talking about was Utilitarianism because it solves the issue of values and rules. For instance, Deontological ethics states that one cannot do to others that they would not want everyone doing. This is idealistic, because for instance in many cases deontologically immoral acts can produce good consequences for society as a whole. For example, during World War II the British intelligence agency cracked the German encryption code called enigma. However the intelligence agency had to lie to its people and government about discovering cracking the code because word could not get out that they had solved the problem. As a result of this lie the British were able to intercept vital german intelligence which was integral to winning the war. If the intelligence agency had made a decision based on deontological ethics lying would have been declared immoral and therefore the British
Show More

Related Documents: Pros And Cons Of Utilitarianism

The Pros And Cons Of Utilitarianism

bestowed the role model of 21st century. Even from earlier days the professional association and medical licensing bodies held that the trust was high when good leadership was exerted, when leadership failed trust fell.(proquest ) The other point is utilitarianism is used in defense of free market on grounds it theoretically maximizes welfare. It’s the high level precision and sophistication. The critique of Rebecca Chew in Dr Lim vs SMC case transparency in pricing should lessen legal intervention since…

Words 2149 - Pages 9

Pros And Cons Of John Mill's Theory Of Utilitarianism

One of the questions at hand is, what would philosopher John Mill do based off his theory of utilitarianism as well as the Principle of Utility. Utilitarianism refers to, “Happiness of the Greater Good”, the best action is the one that maximizes utility. Based off Mill’s beliefs with rescue 1, I am certain that he will tell the rescuer to save the five lives versus the one. Saving the five lives over…

Words 1338 - Pages 6

Pros And Cons Of Utilitarian Ethics

In this paper I will be discussing two pros and two cons of utilitarian ethics. Such as, benefits, happiness, complications, and difficulty. These four options will allow people to make up their mind on whether it is worth the hassle and the damage that it can cause to be worth it. The first pros of utilitarianism is the benefits it can give the people and how it should be taken into consideration. To sacrifice one thing for the greater good is something that needs to be taken into consideration…

Words 633 - Pages 3

Mandatory Vaccination Policy Analysis

home that requires an annual influenza and COVID-19 vaccination is an example of tension between individual freedom and doing what is best for the common good. Looking at the structure of utilitarianism helps identify the intent and results of enforcement in relation to this policy. The primary goal of utilitarianism is to maximize overall happiness and minimize any suffering. The mandatory vaccination policies in this nursing home are trying to do just that. The intent is to protect the overall health…

Words 437 - Pages 2

Essay on Doctor: Cord Stem Cells

Stem cell research pros and cons have gained a lot of attention lately due to President Obama lifting a ban on stem cell research. Arguments for stem cells The people who favor embryonic stem cell research are mostly scientists, and they have many arguments. The first of these arguments is called utilitarianism, which is about how the benefits of stem cell research outweigh the ethical problem of destroying embryonic life. An example of utilitarianism is that embryonic stem…

Words 348 - Pages 2

Kant: Ethics and Ethical Theory Refuts Essay

When comparing and contrasting kants views too the views of Utilitarianism any person who was knowledged in both areas would easily tell you they are one in the same. In fact that person would not be entirely wrong in making that statement, but at the same time they would certainly not be entirely right either. To make a statemenmt of thios sort you would first have to figure out the pros and cons of each view and then decide from that point where the two views meet and where they differ. As…

Words 774 - Pages 4

Utilitarianism and Williams Essay

In Bernard Williams’ critique of utilitarianism, he focuses on the individual to a great extent. The overarching theme of his essay is that the utilitarian places no emphasis whatsoever on the individual; utilitarianism only pays attention to the consequences or the outcomes of a situation and holds no regard to an individual’s moral feelings or their integrity. In reality, according to Williams, if everyone was living according to utilitarianism, there are an infinite number of scenarios…

Words 1356 - Pages 6

Mandatory Vaccination Research Paper

guidelines further state that you should be concerned about your patient and also your needs as a healthcare provider; This all culminates into a tapestry of utilitarianism. American Nurses Association Provision 3 (2015) states, “The nurse promotes, advocates for, and protects the patient's rights, health, and safety.” In this case, utilitarianism means doing the greatest good for the greatest number of people by getting…

Words 2889 - Pages 12

midterm study guide Essay

standards. Stage 6 - Universal Principles - People follow these internalized principles of justice, even if they conflict with laws and rules. Five Ethical Frames of Reference presented to-date: Utilitarianism, Individual Rights, Distributive Justice, Virtue Ethics, The Duties of Care - Utilitarianism is the moral doctrine that we should always act to produce the greatest good for the greatest number, and that our action should produce the greatest balance of good over bad for everyone affected…

Words 1354 - Pages 6

About Creativity Essay

Undoubtedly, the motivation of students and the multiple intelligence blend are inseparable parts of fostering creativity. Humans are the most creative of all living on Earth, but, ironically, we are discouraging our creative by intellectual utilitarianism and negligence of individualized working. Undeniable, those are the trends of the society, nowadays. Po Bronson and Ashley Merryman revealed the issue that the American kids are overwhelmed with standardized curriculum, rote memorization for…

Words 1169 - Pages 5