Race And Representations Essay

Submitted By uzoamkao
Words: 851
Pages: 4
Open Document
Uzoamaka Onyekwere
Freshman Comp 003
Dr. Jones
5 February 2015
Why White Critics Shouldn’t Critique
The representation of race in the late 1950’s to the 60’s was quite similar to what it is today. During the Black Arts Movement, black writers everywhere developed their own black aesthetic, which is described to be the principle black writers use to express the ideas of all black people. It was a way for the black people to have a sense of self­determination and nationhood.
Today in society, black literature is still used to express ideas, but also other verbal means of expression is used such as protesting for rights. The similarities in this large time span show how things haven't changed at all in terms of how people of color are represented. It is seen in the way black writers write and only black critics understand the importance of why things are expressed the way they are. This is where the argument comes in. The belief that white people shouldn’t critique black literature is still relevant today due to the lack of experience, lack of interest and understanding, and the negative stereotypes of black people that encompass their minds. The Black Aesthetic is a term used by Hoyt Fuller in “Towards A Black Aesthetic”. It is used to portray a platform, set to guide black writers in writing what needs to be heard and to who. Those that were well­known writers had to make it their obligation to push the ideas of black people out there to have some sort of expression present to white people. In his article,
Fuller pointed out that white people lack the experience blacks have and with that reason alone

they are inadequate to give a valid critique. “Black critics have the responsibility of approaching the works of black writers assuming these qualities to be present, and with the knowledge that white readers—and white critics—cannot be expected to recognize and to empathize with the subtleties and significance of black style and technique.” White people never knew what it was like to feel inferior or feel unworthy to society therefore they don't have the right to say whether a black writers opinion is right or wrong.
Another reason why white critics should not critique Black Art is because Black Art isn't made for them. Its geared towards black people so they they feel that they have something to relate to. In Zora Neale Hurston’s “What White Publishers Won't Print” she talks about how publishers won't print what they know won't sell. They know that African American literature won't sell because of the fixed stereotype they have on black people.”I have been amazed by the
Anglo­Saxon’s lack of curiosity about the internal lives and emotions of the Negroes,...” White people arent interested in the deeper emotions and behaviors of black people. They wouldn't understand the reason why writers feel to write like this. They would rather read about racial matters, which just add to the stereotype that black people already have, bringing me to my next point. During the Black Arts Movement, it was a time where black people wanted a say for themselves and didn't want to follow the white mans English standards because of the negative stereotypes surrounding them. Black people wanted to break free of those stereotypes and create something better. Many novels and books in this era reject the
Show More

Related Documents: Race And Representations Essay

Zora Hurston

In Zora Hurston’s essay, “How It Feels to Be Colored Me,” she discusses numerous ways of how she perceives her own race. During the Harlem Renaissance, 1920s, many artists expressed their difference through their work individually and Hurston was no different. Of the many different theorists, two emerged and became extremely prominent in the new black representation movement. The two theorists were Langston Hughes and W.E.B. Du Bois. In this essay Hurston communicates to the reader that she is herself…

Words 813 - Pages 4

Columbus Forgotten And Spending Culture Summary

13) This theme can be observed in both Columbus: Gone but not Forgotten and Spending Culture: Marketing the Black Underclass through the way in which she challenges oppressive structures and advocates for a more inclusive and just society. In her essay about Columbus, Bell Hooks delves into a deconstruction of the prevalent historical narrative of how America was “discovered”. She challenges the traditional perspective of Christopher Columbus as a heroic figure who brought civilization to the indigenous…

Words 1446 - Pages 6

Zora Neale Hurston The Gilded Six-Bits Summary

Zora Neale Hurston wrote “The Gilded Six-Bits” 17 years prior to the publication her essay “What White Publisher's Won't Print,” and is a direct response to the lack of literature focused on the “internal lives and emotions of the Negroes” discussed in her later essay. Hurston said that stories of the “'exceptional'” and of the “'quaint'” Negro had “been exploited all out of context already,” however, “realistic” stories centered on the “average, struggling, non-morbid Negro” were almost nonexistent…

Words 226 - Pages 1

Richard Deloria Indians

late centuries, the origins of certain expectations for Indians, and their attempts to redefine their place in society through five essays: violence, representation, athletics, technology, and music. From the very first interaction between Americans and natives, Indians were always viewed as an obstacle or a race to be conquered and forced to adapt. In Deloria’s essay on violence, it’s revealed that there was a common fear of outbreaks, uprisings, and rebellions from Indians (Deloria,…

Words 1059 - Pages 5

Comm: Sociology and New Media Technology Essay

COMM121 2012/10/9 Overview * Ideological criticism in media studies * Hegemony * Dominant ideologies present in media contents * The case of news media, rap music, popular TV * Advertising and consumer culture Ideological analysis in media * Ideology * A system of meaning that helps define and explain the world and that makes value judgments about that world. * They don’t know it, but they are doing it. Ideology as normalization * Ideology defines what…

Words 1710 - Pages 7

Oscar Micheaux Body And Soul Analysis

imposters. Pearl Browser and Louise Spence, writers for the University of Texas Press, talk about Micheaux’s film and how he dealt “the burden of representation”. In the essay Browser and Spence believe Body and Soul “provided images of victimization and poverty too reminiscent of racist portrayals that were supposedly defining characteristics of the race”. I understand why they think this way but I disagree with this argument because the images are a necessary evil that need to be shown to everyone…

Words 785 - Pages 4

Examples Of Racism In Canada

It is no secret that racism has run Canadian society, and most other countries, in its legislative, justice and policing functions. Racism has evolved from outright slavery, to a race based social hierarchy, to racist policing practices and finally, to codified forms of racism that run the fundamental functions of Canada. The aforementioned example demonstrates how, even in a progressive and educated society, racism can re-establish itself in an aggressive, and yet accepted, form. This is because…

Words 1579 - Pages 7

Love: Amiri Baraka and Close Reading Essay

FIRST ESSAY ASSIGNMENT English 285: American Ethnic Literature Prof. Cameron Leader-Picone In this essay, you will closely analyze one of the literary sources that we have read so far in order to argue what the author represents as the meaning and structure of racial identity, race as a concept and racism. This essay builds off of the techniques practiced in our first close reading assignment. Your essay must make a clear and explicit argument, contained in a thesis, about what the text you…

Words 1121 - Pages 5

Wonder Woman By Gloria Steinem Summary

In the essay "Wonder Woman", by Gloria Steinem, she begins her essay with her childhood discovery of the first women super hero. Before, comic books depicted women as vulnerable beings that cannot help themselves, and always rely on a man to save them. This was acceptable role for women both in comic books and in reality. Wonder Women broke the stereotype that society had placed on women at the time. She represented independence to the author, as well as equality for all genders and races of people…

Words 633 - Pages 3

Dichotomy: The American Dream

the right to equal opportunity and representation. This outlook is idealistic in that it assures, regardless of gender or race, a hard worker has the opportunity to obtain whatever they are working toward. Media portrayal has an implicit yet direct impact on social interactions among races. Many minority males still struggle with racial profiling today, despite the great transformation on race relations. Minority males suffer from their persistent representation as criminals across media and, as a…

Words 1233 - Pages 5