Refugees and Morality Essay

Submitted By wiggins9012
Words: 1020
Pages: 5
Open Document
Greater Good
Many nations have much more resources than others. In todays world many capable countries aid needy countries with food, money, medical attention etc. There are many people who feel these countries do not give enough and many other people who feel these countries give too much. There is no definite answer to the question because it is all based on personal views. Pete Singer and Garrett Hardin views on the topic greatly differ from one another. In “Insiders/Outsiders”, Singer states it is a nations moral duty to do all it can to help those in need, while in contrast Harden states it is a nations duty to not help the countries in need in his article “Lifeboat Ethics.”
Pete Singer’s main argument is that these affluent nations need to do all it can to help these poor nations. That help can range from anywhere to food, money, medical supplies, taking them in as refugees and much more. Singer uses the analogy of how the world is facing massive radiations levels and a certain group of people have prepared for this situation and over the course of many years have built an under ground sanctuary for then to stay away from the deadly gases. The people who have prepared for the worst have found out they have room to take in up to 10,000 people who are at danger of being exposed to the radiation. To take in 10,000 people the sanctuary would have to remove of all the leisure space they have. Singer is comparing this sanctuary to these affluent states that should take in high numbers of needy immigrants because it is their moral duty to help out others.
One of Singer’s arguments is to let these refugees resettle in different countries. He states that these people cannot return home due to the reasons they left in the first place. Whether it is political unrest, scarce food supply, or horrid living conditions. Most of these problems do not get resolved in these third world countries. Another resolution could be local settlement, which would mean these refugees settle in neighboring countries. However, in most cases these neighboring countries do not have the means to take in refugees as they are in the same state as the surrounding countries. With both of these resolutions not being reasonable Singer says it is best for these immigrants to resettle in another affluent country far away as they have the means to take in refugees.
Singer goes on to talk about how the citizens of the affluent country will be affected by the influx of refugees. Taking in a great number of refugees will have an effect on the economy. It may have many negative effects as more jobs will be needed, more public welfare being needed, business competition will boost. However, Singer says not to look at the bad but the good than can arise from the situation such as new business, new ethnic diversity within the community, and having new loyal citizens who are reading to contribute to the country.
Garrett Hardin’s views greatly contrast Singers views. He states it is in the best interest of affluent countries to not help these people in need. He says by helping these people you are only putting a bandage on the problem. By putting a bandage on the problem the problem will only increase and multiply. Allowing these countries to go through their struggle with no foreign aid will help them exceed in the long run.
One of Hardins question at issue with helping these people is their population will continue to grow. When their population continues to grow the problem will only get bigger as it will be harder to take care of more people. He says poor countries populations grow 2.5 percent per year while affluent nations only rise 0.8 percent per year. The number of people in need is only getting higher and
Show More

Related Documents: Refugees and Morality Essay

Essay On Refugee Refugees

situation. There are several ongoing efforts to help refugees and IDPs. One example is a project called “Improving the Coping Status of Urban Refugees,” enacted by CRAT with the US Embassy in Cameroon. It aimed to support refugees regain economic independence through their own jobs. The project aided refugee women to gain skills to manage a small business and save assets thorough CRAT. Even though it could only apply to a small portion of refugees, the result was successful and many of them were encouraged…

Words 1145 - Pages 5

The Pros And Cons Of Alexander Hamilton

displays the power of the federal government taking control of the terrorist issue on a small scale first, and experimenting to see the results of this temporary ban. In addition, other Muslim-majority countries that house hundreds of thousands of refugees are not part of this seven country list because the citizens do not pose as large a threat to the US, so the proposition Muslims are not allowed in the country is disproven. In the Executive Order, President Trump expressed that the Executive Order…

Words 785 - Pages 4

Peter Singer's Argument Analysis

Peter Singer’s argument on international aid requires the use of several premises and a single conclusion. Premise 1 states “that suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, and medical care are bad” (“Famine, Affluence, and Morality” 231). The negative effects of starvation (e.g., suffering and death) are major evils which could be reduced, if not averted in its entirety. Singer is largely unconcerned with defending the validity of this premise as he believes most people will accept the notion…

Words 1505 - Pages 7

The Perils Of Indifference Analysis

times of crisis. Allowing human abuses to occur is a blight against the morality of all people. To stop is a duty laid out in the world to prevent occurrences such as the Holocaust from…

Words 804 - Pages 4

Persuasive Essay On Hillary Clinton

biased. But amidst all the criticism, nobody tends to look at the actual policies of either candidate, and nobody tends to see their redeeming qualities either. So today I will be looking at the superior choice for America, on policy, character, and morality Hillary Clinton. So let's look at Hillarys federal income tax plan. Its relatively simple, Hillary wants to keep everything the same, except add an additional tax bracket for those who make over $5,000,000. This will generate more income for the…

Words 504 - Pages 3

PHI 208 Week 2 assignment Essay

Famine, Affluence, and Morality PHI 208 Ethics and Moral Reasoning Famine, Affluence, and Morality In Peter Singer’s 1972 post titled “Famine, Affluence and Morality”, he conveys that wealthy nations, for example the United States, has an ethical duty to contribute much a lot more than we do with regards to worldwide assistance for famine relief and/or other disasters or calamities which may happen. In this document, I will describe Singers objective in his work and…

Words 1306 - Pages 6

Holocaust Paper

numerous press reports in the 1930s about the persecution of Jews. More than a decade later in 1942 the governments of the U.S and Great Britain received confirmed reports that stated Germany’s intent was to kill all Jews. In fear of massive influx of refugees, neither country modified their refugee policies. No specific attempts to stop or slow the genocide were made until mounting pressure forced the U.S to undertake limited rescue efforts in 1949. Another example of how the world let this happen:…

Words 642 - Pages 3

Implications Of The 14th Amendment Essay

The concept of animus was first given recognition by Justice Kennedy in the Romer v Evans case back in 1996 (Epstein and Walker). Animus can be generally understood as prejudiced, spiteful, and malevolent ill will, and when it comes to laws and policies, the supreme court has generally conceded that when animus is involved in the creation of laws, the law in question does not serve a valid government interest. Since Donald Trump signed the executive order enacting the Travel Ban, also coined the…

Words 949 - Pages 4

post 1945 Essay

Post 1945 World War 11- refugees and resettlement schemes 1975- immigration Restriction act removed Vietnam war- refugees (Buddhist, catholic) 2000- middle east Christians High- birth and migrant rates- baptized but not practicing Christianity instituationalised- law, system of gov, holidays, schools+colleges, charities 2006 64% christians Contemporary Aboriginal Spiritualties Discuss how Aboriginal spirituality is determined by the Dreaming The dreaming is a fundamental, underlying aspect of…

Words 2813 - Pages 12

1 AFF Lay AC Essay

I affirm the resolution, “Just governments ought to ensure food security for their citizens.” To clarify the debate, I provide the following definitions: Ought implies an http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/ought used to express obligation. Jane Straus defines ensure as (Straus, Jane [author of the Blue Book of Grammar and Punctuation]. Grammar Book.) Ensure is to do or have what is necessary for success. The United Nations defines food security as (United Nations. 1975. Report of the World…

Words 3955 - Pages 16