Implications Of The 14th Amendment Essay

Words: 949
Pages: 4
Open Document
The concept of animus was first given recognition by Justice Kennedy in the Romer v Evans case back in 1996 (Epstein and Walker). Animus can be generally understood as prejudiced, spiteful, and malevolent ill will, and when it comes to laws and policies, the supreme court has generally conceded that when animus is involved in the creation of laws, the law in question does not serve a valid government interest. Since Donald Trump signed the executive order enacting the Travel Ban, also coined the Muslim-Ban by laypersons, several people have been concerned about the constitutionality of the matter. Based off of what I have learned throughout the course of this class, I would argue that the ban is a violation of the equal protection clause established …show more content…
Technically speaking, the 14th amendment was specifically designed to apply to states; however, one could make the argument that state and local governments would eventually become implicit in the discriminatory federal statute through enforcement once Muslims are detained at airports solely because they are Muslim. Further, the 14th amendment put forth several clauses that work to protect and ensure fair treatment, but this travel ban specifically violates the equal protection clause of the amendment. Ratified in 1868, the 14th amendment, composed of two sections, is the foundation of the general constitutional protection we have against discrimination (Epstein and Walker). The equal protection clause states that “no state shall… deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws” (Epstein and Walker). Now, in order for someone to establish a legitimate claim of discrimination under the equal protection clause, the person is required to show how the proposed law creates unfair treatment between groups of people, and state action must be involved (Epstein and Walker). Both requirements would easily be met given someone is detained at an airport specifically because of their faith or nationality. Furthermore, as established by the court’s decision in Yick Wo v. Hopkins (1886), the fourteenth amendment definitely applies to non-citizens as well; therefore, peoples entering the country should arguably have some of the same protections citizens in this country have by
Show More

Related Documents: Implications Of The 14th Amendment Essay

14th Amendment Research Paper

The 14th amendment to the United States Constitution, ratified in 1868, stands as an important moment in American legal history. Its far reaching implications have significantly shaped the landscape of rights and liberties, ushering in a new era of constitutional development. This essay explores the monumental impact of the 14th amendment on the evolution of rights and liberties in the United States. The key to understanding the 14th amendment is the historical context in which it started. Ratified…

Words 556 - Pages 3

Questions On American History

questions 5 short identifications 1 essay Identifications: Briefly identify the term and explain its significance in 2-3 sentences. All the terms will come from the list of key terms below. Sample ID: Compromise of 1877: Political compromise that allowed Rutherford B. Hayes to win the presidential election. This was significant because Hayes was forced to accept several key concessions, including ending Reconstruction. Essay: 2 of the following essays will appear on the exam. You will pick…

Words 461 - Pages 2

Significance of Doha Para 6 Decision Essay

evaluate the solution that has been offered (i.e. ‘Decision of 6 August 2005’ to amend the TRIPS Agreement’) The Declaration of the TRIPS Agreement and Public Health (the ‘Doha Declaration’) was adopted by the WTO Ministerial Conference 2001 in Doha on 14th, November 2001. This marks the first attempt of an inclusion of international health and development as an interest at the World Trade Organization (WTO). The declaration illumined the problem of pharmaceutical access in many developing countries and…

Words 3131 - Pages 13

Legal and Ethical Implications for Classroom Management Essay

Legal and Ethical Implications for Classroom Management Grand Canyon University: EDU 536 April 24, 2013 Today’s classrooms are more dynamic than ever before. Educational needs of students are changing at breakneck speeds, along with the demands being placed on their teachers. There are associated legal and ethical implications that are evolving as rapidly as the technology that is driving a lot of the change. In order to have a chance to meet the needs of students and…

Words 1538 - Pages 7

Essay on PS 110 Notes

Chapter 1 Politics: Who Gets What, and How? Resources: assets that can be be drawn on by a person or organization in order to function effectively Power: ability to get others to do what you want them to do Politics: “who gets what, when, and how?” Government: a system for exercising control over a body of people Institutions: structures of mechanisms of social order that govern the behavior of a specific set of individuals Ex. schools, hospitals, prisons, religion, marriages Rules: set…

Words 2561 - Pages 11

Essay on Concepts for midterm

The behavior of homo sapiens -- human beings tend to pursue their own interests. They behave in ways that promote individual interests, and are motivated by incentives (both positive and negative). This is one of the reasons proposed for the development of governments: groups of individuals all acting in their own interests leads to collective action problems, and governments exist as a solution to those problems. Collective action problem -- this occurs when a group of individuals, each acting…

Words 5510 - Pages 23

Examples Of Legal, Political, Ethical Dimension

Legal, Political, Ethical Dimension - Week 5 Midterm 1. Question : TCO B. After the 2010 fall election, the Democratic National Committee (DNC) decides to take matters into its own hands. During the lame duck session, they pass a new "Elections Are Free Act" that requires single people who make more than $75,000/year or married couples who make more than $150,000/year to provide a copy of their tax return to their local county officials before being allowed to register to vote. The return must…

Words 3933 - Pages 16

Hy Study Guide Essay

B. the Progressive search for the ordered society 1. anti-lynching laws or segregation laws? C. The legal framework 1. the 14th and 15th amendments in the way 2. avoiding the 14th: Separate but Equal 3. avoiding the 15th: race-neutral racism D. Response from the African-American community 1. Social and cultural implications 2. Booker Washington and economic uplift 3. W.E.B. Du Bois and political action 641 Henry Grady “New South” “Pitchfork” Ben…

Words 3031 - Pages 13

United States and Essential Questions Essay

extensive primary and secondary sources and to the interpretations of various historians. Class participation through seminar reports, discussions, debates, and role-playing activities is required; special emphasis is placed on critical reading and essay writing to help students prepare for the AP examination. The course is structured chronologically, divided into 21 units. Each unit includes one or more of the nine periods and/or key concepts outlined in the AP U.S. History curriculum framework.…

Words 7288 - Pages 30