Response To Moral Relativism

Words: 630

Pages: 3

Open Document

Critics assert that relativists typically exaggerate the degree of diversity among cultures since superficial differences often mask underlying shared agreements. In fact, some say that there is a core set of universal values that any human culture must endorse if it is to flourish. Moral relativists are also accused of inconsistently claiming that there are no universal moral norms while appealing to a principle of tolerance as a universal norm. In the eyes of many critics, though, the most serious objection to moral relativism is that it implies the pernicious consequence that “anything goes”: slavery is just according to the norms of a slave society; sexist practices are right according to the values of a sexist culture. Without some sort of non-relative standard to appeal to, the critics argue, we have no basis for critical moral appraisals of our own culture’s conventions, or for judging one society to be better than another. Naturally, most moral relativists typically reject the assumption that such judgments require a non-relativistic foundation.

In the view of most people …show more content…
The objection is that if we say beliefs and actions are right or wrong only relative to a specific moral standpoint, it then becomes possible to justify almost anything. We are forced to abandon the idea that some actions are just plain wrong. Nor can we justify the idea that some forms of life are obviously and uncontroversially better than others, even though almost everyone believes this. According to the relativists, say the critics, the beliefs of slave-owners and Nazis should be deemed true and their practices right relative to their conceptual-moral frameworks; and it is not possible for anyone to prove that their views are false or morally misguided, or that there are better points of view. To many, this is a reductio ad absurdum of moral

Cultural Relativism And Morality

Carlise Richmond World View Assignment #2 American History March 10, 2015 Cultural Relativism and Morality Cultural relativism was coined by Franz Boas, a anthropological researcher, who was fascinated by other cultures and languages of indigenous cultures of the Baffin Isle Inuit. Franz said that a "...civilization is not something absolute, but ... is relative, and ... our ideas and conceptions are true only so far as our civilization goes…

Words 630 - Pages 3

Ethical Absolutism, Relativism, And Pluralism

resolution when confronted by a moral dilemma can be a very difficult task. In societies today, ethics are developed by one’s religious belief, government, and through experience. Social ethics serve as the premise for morality when dealing with moral conflicts such as the preservation of indigenous ways of life compared to the modernization world we now live in. According to Hinman, there are three common systems of thought regarding ethics, which are, absolutism, relativism, and pluralism. Ethical absolutists…

Words 2525 - Pages 11

Essay Ethics: Ethics and Ethical Relativism

Ethical Relativism has many definitions and has meaning different meanings when stated in theory in general by the following definition “In ethics, the belief that nothing is objectively right or wrong and that the definition of right or wrong depends on the prevailing view of a particular individual, culture, or historical period..”(The American Heritage® New Dictionary of Cultural Literacy, 2005) Also can be viewed in three points of interest as well what is right for one person is not always…

Words 1453 - Pages 6

Plaisance Response Paper

Name: Jiashuo Qin Date: 14/9/2014 PROFESSOR: Dr. Bernhard Debatin Response Paper for J8130-Ethics, Internet, and society—Fall 2014-2015 Topic: Media ethics (Plaisance) Ethics comes into our minds when we are finding rational justification for our actions. Aiming at giving his readers applicable key principles to moral philosophy and to responsible media practice, Plaisance introduces a broad collection of classical and contemporary philosophers. For example, in defining ethics, Aristotle…

Words 633 - Pages 3

Morality Essay

and class discussion. Cultural Relativism Essay 1. Cultural ethical relativism holds that ethical values vary from society to society and that the basis for moral judgments lies in these social or cultural views. For instance, it is considered ethical to eat certain foods or consume alcohol in some cultures, but unethical in others and some cultural societies have different forms of punishment for violations such as theft or adultery. Does the diversity of moral outlooks in cultures show that right…

Words 1027 - Pages 5

Schools of Thought Worksheet Essay

University of Phoenix Material Schools of Thought Worksheet Write brief descriptions for each of the terms in the table below. If you use an outside source to define them, include an APA citation for the source. General Terms Ecology A science that deals with the relationships between groups of living things and their environments ("Merriam-Webster", 2014). Environmental justice A recognition that access to a clean, healthy environment is a fundamental right of all human beings (McGraw-Hill…

Words 1198 - Pages 5

Iwc1 Literature, Arts and Humanities Essay

IWC1 Test 1.02 Module Pre-Test Question 1: Multiple Choice The historical revival of Classical culture began during the: a) Middle Ages b) Renaissance c) Baroque Era d) Romantic Era Feedback: The correct answer is b. The historical revival of Classical culture began during the Renaissance. Question 2: Multiple Choice Which of the following was a key feature of ancient Chinese humanism? a) An emphasis on theoretical philosophy. b) A subordination of intellectual life to religious…

Words 10011 - Pages 41

Essay on Stocks For The Long Run

Westermarck (1862-1939), “The Sources of Moral Ideas: Society, Custom, and Sympathy” Question: Are there any objective moral judgments? Are moral judgments about some reality, and so true/false insofar as they correspond with that reality? Are moral judgments one’s that all persons with intellect/reason concur in making? I. Deﬁnition of objectivity Objectivity in judgment requires that: (a) The judgment can be seen to be true by everyone who has all the information relevant to the truth…

Words 1116 - Pages 5

midterm study guide Essay

actually are acting Requires: Arranging values to guide decisions, Understanding the facts, Constructing arguments. Kohlberg’s Stages of Ethical Development: he responses were then classified into various stages of reasoning in his theory of moral development: Level 1: Stage 1 - Obedience and Punishment - The earliest stages of moral development, rules are seen as as fixed and absolute. Obeying the rules is important because it is a means to avoid punishment. Stage 2 - Individualism and Exchange…

Words 1354 - Pages 6

Essay on katie s midterm for philosophy

Virtue, Principle of the Mean, Moral Virtue, Teleology Immanuel Kant- Categorical Imparative/ Goodwill Epicurus- Ataraxia, Happiness, Epistemology John Rawls -The Two Principles of Justice Concepts Moral Philosophy (Also known as ETHICS)- is the study of morality using the methods of philosophy, and morality concerns beliefs about right and wrong actions and good and bad persons or character. Normative Ethics- Philosophical exploration and evaluation of moral norms (principals, virtues, values…

Words 2696 - Pages 11