Restorative Criminal Justice Essay

Words: 476

Pages: 2

Open Document

NO
Restorative justice has no place in the American Criminal Justice system. There are several offenses where it is impossible to remedy the loss of the victim. An assault victim for example, could be subjected secondary-victimization by this process even tough the victim may have chosen this route to resolve the pending criminal offense. The offender his/her family may have ways to coerce the victim to choose restorative justice program in the worst case. In these cases no justice can be served and no damage can be remedied. In serious offenses against persons, there cannot be reason to build communication and understanding between the victim and the offender.

The Restorative justice system is a threat to the offender’s civil rights. The right to confront the accuser, due process and right to council are examples of these rights potentially getting bypassed by this unconventional method. The offender may feel pressured to comply with the …show more content…
Minor offenses such as criminal mischief and theft cases could potentially bypass the court system and save a lot of valuable resources and allow to use necessary resources efficiently.

Any minor property offenses would be ideal cases to have to be engaged in a Restorative Justice program. The offender could work for the victim or in other ways make the victim whole i.e. help recover for the loss caused by the offense. The offender could repair or replace what was destroyed, damaged or stolen.

Restorative justice system would be an ideal method to treat first offenders. This would allow them to get a comprehensive understanding of the extent of their actions including the cost, inconvenience, and pain it may have caused to the victim. It would give the offender a chance to relate to the victim and also an opportunity to understand more humane values instead of having to go through the conventional route to pay back his/her debt to the

Justice In Criminal Justice

committed and an individual is caught in the act, there is a set process that one follows to adhere to the rules of the criminal justice system. This method can be simplified by looking at the common flow of events: (1) an individual is arrested, (2) individual is brought to court, (3) individual receives a punishment. Though it may appear that the way in which the criminal justice system functions is sufficient, many voice the concern that there are certain key players affected by crimes that are…

Words 706 - Pages 3

take home exam JST Essays

Part A- Short Answer Questions 2. 'Diversionary measures in the juvenile justice system are a cost-cutting measure that reduces the burden on the court system and provides less formal options of dealing with young offenders. It is a win-win'. Critique this statement by providing 5 key points regarding the advantages and disadvantages of diversionary measures. 1. Financial- Court based methods of dealing with youth justice are amongst the most costly means of dealing with juvenile crime due to high…

Words 3063 - Pages 13

Juvenile Justice System Research Paper

The juvenile justice system is a complex and multifaceted system that aims to rehabilitate and punish young people who have committed crimes. However, the juvenile justice system has been criticized for its reliance on the school-to-prison pipeline and the failure to adequately protect juvenile offenders' rights. One of the most controversial aspects of the juvenile justice system is the use of school resource officers (SROs). SROs are police officers who are assigned to work in schools. While SROs…

Words 1468 - Pages 6

Carceral Feminist Analysis

Carceral feminists have the right ends, the wrong means. Have they. Criminal feminism aims to tackle gender-based violence and inequality through the criminal justice system. This essay will examine whether the means of carceral feminism are effective in delivering justice and resolving gendered violence. There has been growing criticism of the punitive policies advocated due to their role in contributing to mass incarceration and their adverse effects on promoting equality. This alliance between…

Words 1993 - Pages 8

Essay about The Ride

murder. Within this essay I will demonstrate from The Ride the relationship between reporting and suffering that may have been brought on for the crime victims of this case, the relationship between the victim profiles and the victim family profiles, the role in which the family may have played in the…

Words 1423 - Pages 6

Social Constructionism, Positivism and Classicism Essay

* positivism * social constructionism The role of theory in contemporary youth justice practice is crucial in shaping and conceptualising relationships between youth and crime. It provides a structure for how youth justice is practiced and helps make sense of today’s issues surrounding the topic. Approaches to youth justice have evolved throughout the centuries and it is important for youth justice practitioners to be aware of the evolution of theory in order to be up to date with their…

Words 1817 - Pages 8

Gabriella Mahaffey Restorative Justice Cases

Gabriella Mahaffey Restorative Justice Spring 2024 Written Assignment Part 2. For this essay, I decided to continue with the case study involving my father's childhood best friend. I talked about 2 different crimes Freddie committed, but in this essay, I will be focusing on the first crime. However, I still keep the second crime and its effects on the stakeholders in the back of my mind when deciding which restorative practice would be most effective. After taking a lot of time to reflect on this…

Words 1144 - Pages 5

Compare Beccaria and Lombroso Essay

Key Thinkers and Their Competing Ideologies. Criminology is a study of crime, criminals and criminal justice. Ideas about criminal justice and crime arose in the 18th century during the enlightenment, but criminology as we know it today developed in the late 19th century. Criminology has been shaped by many different academic disciplines and has many different approaches. It explores the implications of criminal laws; how they emerge and work, then how they are violated and what happens to those…

Words 2300 - Pages 10

Law And White Collar Crime

there is no assurance of either. Law during the feudal period was designed to maintain the social order, such is the essence of law, but the nature of the social order was quite different. Reciprocity was the norm even in the workings of the criminal justice system. Much of law was based on tradition, enforced by community members as a whole, and judged by local nobility. It is during the decline of these relations and the rise of the powerful merchant class that a significant law for white-collar…

Words 1848 - Pages 8

Narrative And Resistance Essay

the backbone of this paper’s position: OD professionals, as well as their methods of diagnosis significantly participate in creating the resistance to change that OD professionals find problematic. Narrative, defined for the purpose of this essay as any spoken or written account of connected events, is a central factor to the externalization process described by Berger and Luckmann, both explicitly and implicitly. It is key to how individuals construct knowledge, how knowledge is transmitted…

Words 4596 - Pages 19