Elie states that he "never shall forget the nocturnal silence" (34). The first part of the statement is being repeated to make this an Anaphoras. There was an occurring silence from the Jews that allowed the Nazis to push them around. The silence that surrounded Elie "deprived [him] for all eternity of the desire to live" (34). There was no rebellion, therefore, the Nazis knew they had the Jews under their belts. The Nazis took there lack of rebellion and used it to their advantage by making them do work, give up their valuables, and move all over the country. Their muteness may have even made things worse because the Nazis knew they could make the Jews do anything they wanted them to