Romeo and Juliet Essay

Submitted By matthewluu1
Words: 849
Pages: 4
Open Document
Romeo and Juliet Comparison Essay
Matthew Luu

Shakespeare's "Romeo and Juliet" is a very popular story. When you have a great story there are many different views on it. Two film directors named Franco Zeffirelli and Baz Luhrmann filmed the story of “Romeo and Juliet” through their eyes, with two completely different movies. Franco Zeffirelli's movie (1968) was very close to what Shakespeare thought of upon writing this story. It was "authentic" and more to the script. On the other hand, Baz Luhrmann's film (1996) gave a completely different feel to an old classic. He made it so that in a way it would appeal to the more younger audiences (teenagers)and more modern. For this essay I will be comparing the two movies from Act 1 Scene 1 "The Opening Brawl".
There are many things that were similar and many that were really different. One example of really different was their choices of costumes. I think that Luhrmann went for a modern look. He made the Capulet’s wear suits giving them a gangster look and the Montague’s in casual shirts giving them a rebelious image. Luhrmann made it very easy to tell the two families apart by the colours of their car: Montague’s had a yellow car, and the Capulet’s had a blue car. However in Zeffirelli's film, the two families were dressed by specific colours. The Montagues wore red and gold and the Capulets wore blue and green. In my opinion, I think the choice of the costumes for Zeffirelli's film was very traditional and more believable. Let's go in thier setting choices, Baz Luhrmann's film has a completely different setting compared to the Franco Zeffirelli movie. With his goal of modernising the play, many things were changed. You could see this by looking at the weapons they used, their method of transportation and their homes. Instead of using swords, they used hand guns in the film. Instead of walking, they traveled by car. The movie took place in a fairly large city ("Verona Beach, California") whereas the play took place in a small old fashioned town ("Verona Italy"). One of the similarities between these two films is the language. In the Zeffirelli film, original Shakespearean dialogue is spoken. In the Luhrmann film, they still use Shakespearean dialogue but it had a different feel to it since it was filmed to be more modern. For Zeffirelli's film, the language used fits in perfectly because it works very well with the set and theme of the movie (it seems more natural to both hear and speak Shakespearean dialogue) . But in the Luhrmann film, it was weird to see the actors dressed in modern day shirts and jeans, riding around in cars speaking in Shakespearean dialogue.
In the Zeffirelli film, the fight scene takes place at a marketplace. But in Luhrmann's film, the scene takes place at a gas station. Watching the third brawl of the two films, I realized the huge range of camera angles used. In Luhrmann’s film, the camera was never in one place, it was as though the camera man kept moving like a person who was actually there. He also used many close ups. They showed both families feelings and facial expressions. This helped
Show More

Related Documents: Romeo and Juliet Essay

Essay on Romeo: Romeo and Juliet and Juliet

title Romeo and Juliet) Start broad, work down to specific → Pointing the way to where your essay is going. William Shakespeare’s (author) Romeo and Juliet (title) is perhaps one of the best known love stories of all time. The play (form) follows the two “star crossed lovers” (quote) from the beginning of their passionate relationship through to their tragic (reference to tragedy) deaths. Shakespeare intends for the audience to sympathise with its central characters, in particular Juliet. Responsibility…

Words 334 - Pages 2

Romeo And Juliet

SAC; On the way back from a Romeo and Juliet play in the car, It was at least midnight. The sky was dark but there were still little beams of light from the moon that lit up the street so they could still find where the car was when the couple exited the theatre. ‘Well that was a load of crap, what a waste of my time’ said Joe angrily. ‘I thought it was lovely it has really opened my eyes about love’ said Jenny with joy. ‘What? As if! It was utter crap, totally fake! No-one could fall in…

Words 821 - Pages 4

Romeo And Juliet

Keayr Griffin My compare and contrast on Romeo and Juliet the new version and the older version. 1-31-13 4 th hour Mrs.K I personally like the newer version of Romeo and Juliet myself because of the more modern themes. The character are not so dull and the setting of the move isn't so medieval time. The action in the movie do not look fake like the first movie. The character who plays Romeo to me is more like us teens nowadays. LIke the way they dress in the old movie you could…

Words 488 - Pages 2

Essay on Romeo: Romeo and Juliet and Romeo

Romeo and Juliet Romantic Love Essay Submitted to: Ms. Saplys Submitted by: Joey McGuire Wednesday, May 22nd, 2013 The play of “Romeo and Juliet” is truly a tragedy that is based by the romantic love these two characters share and how this acts as the compass for all the other events that. Firstly, once Romeo and Juliet meet for the first time their moods completely change surrounding their hatred of each other’s families. Next, when Romeo and Juliet become split up because…

Words 1281 - Pages 6

Essay Romeo and Juliet and Juliet

How important is act 1 scene 5 of Shakespeare Romeo and Juliet the play as whole? Romeo and Juliet were written by William Shakespeare around 1595. This play has been written among many other tragedies by Shakespeare such as, "Macbeth" and "Hamlet". However Romeo and Juliet is one of the most tragic Shakespeareans plays of all time. This play is about hate, tragedy and most importantly Love. It’s about two young lovers, Romeo from the Montague and Juliet from the Capulet’s who both fall in love when…

Words 823 - Pages 4

Romeo: Romeo and Juliet and Romeo Essay

Romeo The play “Romeo and Juliet,” is written by famous British playwright William Shakespeare. It begins with a large fight between the Capulets and Montegues in Verona, Italy. Two individuals, Romeo Montegue and Juliet Capulet go through struggles in order to be together. Romeo is one of the main characters in the play and comes from a rich family by the name of Montegue. Throughout the story Romeo shows a variety of personalities. Romeo is a handsome man who matures to adulthood at a young age…

Words 481 - Pages 2

Romeo and Juliet and Romeo Essay

Wahid Sharifzad Mr. Childs English 1 Honors 29 January 2015 Romeo & Juliet Metaphors William Shakespeare’s The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet includes countless metaphors and similes that are used to describe the relationship between Romeo and Juliet. Act 2, Scene 2 also known as the balcony scene portrays the complex relationship between the “two star crossed lovers”(6). There is no absolute definition of love and everyone finds out his or her interpretation differently. William Shakespeare uses metaphors…

Words 553 - Pages 3

Romeo: Romeo and Juliet Essay

Who is responsible for Romeo and Juliet's death I think many people believe in Fate,but in this condition I don't think Romeo and Juliet's death can be simply explained by fate. We need to take into account everything around them, like their parents,Romeo himself.....and if their love was not a secret would it have ended in tragedy? I am going to declare why Romeo and Juliet's death can not simply explain by fate, and these are my point -Romeo is responsible for his own death. -Friar…

Words 806 - Pages 4

Drama: Romeo and Juliet and Juliet References Romeo Essay

My example of an antagonist is Tybalt compared to Romeo. Tybalt is constantly trying to start fights with Romeo and, eventually, he succeeds. Because of Tybalt, Romeo is banished from the city Verona, where his beloved wife Juliet lives. Another example of an Antagonist is, Paris compared to Juliet. Paris is the main reason that Juliet deems it necessary to take a potion to fake her death. This ultimately leads to the death of both Romeo and Juliet in the end. A foil in a story is a character…

Words 1279 - Pages 6

Romeo And Juliet Flaws

Romeo and Juliet is a well-known play written by William Shakespeare that reveals “genuine love”. True love is being committed to the opposite person by having a compassionate and a sacrificial heart that may require taking risks for that special someone. Romeo’s longing for Juliet is not genuine as Romeo only admired Juliet’s appearance, has a weak heart to women, and replaced Rosaline with Juliet to escape the “real world”. If Romeo and Juliet is an example of fate, then lust and infatuation should…

Words 708 - Pages 3