Note: The sample assignment below deals with Question 1 in Week 5 tutorial program – Directors’ Duties (1). The student was only asked to discuss whether Popper and Brown had breached their duties owed to Electrics Ltd.
Introduction
Directors are usually conferred with extensive express and implied powers that may be used in managing a company. As these powers leave the fate of the company largely in the directors’ hands, the common law and Corporations Act 2001 impose certain duties on these directors.1 Directors are considered to stand in a fiduciary relationship with their company, as a consequence of this fiduciary relationship, equity imposes duties on directors.2
On the facts available, there are two issues of directors’ duties to be discussed. The first issue is whether Popper has breached any fiduciary duties and s 181, s 182 and s 184 of the Corporations Act (the Act) by proposing the Electrics Ltd acquiring the land from his daughter. The second issue is whether Brown has breached the common Law duty and s 180 by rarely attending board meeting and saying he’s happy to endorse what the others have decided. Potential liabilities of Popper and Brown are discussed.
Issue One: Whether Popper Has Breached Any Fiduciary Duties, Statutory duties s 181, s 182 and s 184
1. Fiduciary Duty to Act Honestly and in the Best Interest of the Company & s 181(1)(a) and s 184(1)(c)
Directors are under a fiduciary duty to act in good faith and in the best interests of the company and for a proper purpose. The equivalent statutory duty is contained in s 181(1)(a) which states that a director or other officer of a corporation must exercise their powers and discharger their duties in good faith in the best interests of the corporation and for a proper purpose.3 The duty has both subjective and objective elements as explained by Owen J in The Bell Group Ltd v Westpac Banking Corporation.4 The duty is breached if a director acts in a way that no rational director would have considered to be in the best interests of the company: ASIC v Adler.5
Section 184(1)(c) similarly provides that it is an offence if directors are reckless or intentionally dishonest and fail to exercise their powers and discharge their duties in good faith in corporation’s best interests.6
In our case, Popper proposed the Electrics Ltd acquiring the land from his daughter for $1 million and later the contract was approved. The company’s property portfolio manager said the land “may be useful when things pick up”. The information provided indicates that it is not necessary for Electrics Ltd to acquire the land at moment. It is Popper’s daughter needs cash urgently so that Popper proposed that Electrics to acquire the land. Ms Shareholder later learned that Popper has known for some time that proposed zoning changes would reduce the land value well below $1 million. If this is true then Popper’s action involves intentionally dishonest. The objective standard for duty to act in good faith and proper purpose under s 181 was adopted by Santow J in ASIC v Adler:7
In particular, I consider that the standard of behaviour required by s 181(1) is not complied with by subjective good faith or by a mere subjective belief by a director that his purpose was proper, certainly if no reasonable director could have reached that conclusion. This is made clear by the new provisions in s 184(1) which by contrast imposes the additional elements of being “intentionally dishonest” or “reckless” for the purpose of criminal sanctions.8
In my view, Popper has breached the fiduciary duty of acting honestly and in the best interest of the company, he has also breach the statutory duty of s 181(1)(a) and s 184(1)(c).
2. Fiduciary Duty to Avoid Conflict of Interest & s 182(1) and s 184(2)
Directors are under both fiduciary and statutory duties to avoid undisclosed conflicts between their personal interests and the interests of the company. The duty is strictly applied as in Aberdeen
General Business:
Group had a potluck at Christin’s apartment to discuss group proposal. Long Hoang, Faith Mbella, Christin Padgett, Wan Dong showed up.
Project ideas, what each member should do on their own and discuss when to meet next.
Email Alejandro Ugarte about his part.
What work has been done:
General ideas about the projects.
Discuss what we should include and divide by parts for members.
What work is being done:
Members figure out what content they should have to finish…
Business Law & Bankruptcy
Assignment #5
When Josh was asked, during a bankruptcy proceeding, whether he had ever been sued, he responded that he had not. In fact, he had once been sued for intentional infliction of emotional distress. That suit had been settled many years earlier and had no financial impact on Josh today. Josh’s debts were discharged in bankruptcy. Creditors want the discharge revoked because of Josh’s lie.
Should a discharge be revoked because of a lie made in court by the…
1.Negligence
A. Negligence involves the ability to foresee the consequences of acts and fault for failing to take appropriate actions to avoid the harmful consequences. In this case, there is reasonable foresee ability, which implies that Zonar is responsible for any consequences that they could have reasonably foreseen had they been reasonable. Furthermore, there was actual foreseeability as well, which is that they are responsible for consequences they actually foresaw occurring. First of all,…
The general impression is that this paper could be much better written because the results are important and novel to science and, as such, may have a significant application in the orcharding. In addition, English is hardly satisfying and there are serious objections which must be corrected if the paper are likely to be accepted.
Starting from the beginning, the title of the paper is adequately selected because it completely matches the theme. The abstract is a very informative and concise but,…
Training and Development
Nowadays how to motivate the employees has become one of the most crucial
challenges companies have to face. It is essential for an organization to choice proper
human resource practices as several researches have proved that a company’s
human resources plays a critical role on a company’s success (Ferris et al., 1999).
Among all the functions of human resource practices, the most important one is
employee training and development. Recent study suggests that human resource…
1. How do the objectives assist a student in completing the assignment?
The objectives listed with the project help assist students by allowing them to understand what the end goal of their papers should be. This allows students to write their assignments according to these objectives, resulting in a quality paper and thus better grades.
2. Describe what needs to be done for the assignment found in the sample syllabus?
The paper must talk about how components create a worldview in 500-750 words…
Understanding a GCU Assignment Worksheet
Assignment Background:
It is important to read through all components of an assignment in the GCU classroom so that you are aware of its requirements and the expectations of your instructor. Look for the following cues:
• What is the objective of the assignment?
• What are the elements of the assignment?
• How will the assignment be graded?
• What are other considerations for completing the assignment well?
The purpose of…
students will be exposed to topics of current interest in Professional Issues in Accounting (B AD 63022).
Assessment Measure: Students will be required to prepare team papers and presentations on selected current topics in B AD 63022. A random sample of the resulting submissions will be evaluated. Success will be indicated by a minimum score of 80%.
Learning Objective 2: Students will develop basic networking and interpersonal skills necessary for success in obtaining an initial position in…
methods covered in Psychology/Sociology 205
5. Learn good data management techniques to support data integrity
Methods of Instruction: Lecture, lab demonstration, one-on-one student-teacher interaction, students work collaboratively to complete assignments
Content:
1. Computer Basics
2. Inputting Data Directly Into SPSS and Defining Data
3. Transforming and Manipulating SPSS Data
4. Frequencies, Descriptives, Identifying Outliers
5. Graphic Displays of Data…
