School Vouchers Essay

Submitted By Elizabeth-Sanchez
Words: 2245
Pages: 9
Open Document
School vouchers: Are they effective or damaging? During the 1950s, Noble Prize winning libertarian economist, Milton Friedman, made the first proposal for American education to include a voucher system. However, it was not until the 1980’s when the nation’s first school choice voucher program came into effect, which was passed by the legislature of Wisconsin, and provided parents the opportunity to choose the school where they felt was appropriate for their child. The Friedman Foundation defined the notion of school choice in two parts:
(1)…a common sense idea that gives all parents the power and freedom to choose their child’s education, while encouraging healthy competition among schools and other institutions to better serve students’ needs and priorities, [and] (2) a public policy that allows a parent/guardian or student to choose a district, charter, or private school, regardless of residence and location (www.edchoice.org).
While the idea of school choice seems fitting and beneficial, especially to students who come from low-income families, there are many lies, dangers and threats seamed within the idea. School vouchers not only pose a serious danger to students and to the system of public education, but they also violate the separation between church and state. Beneficial…to an extent On its website, The Friedman Foundation provides an explanation to the significance and objective of school vouchers:
Vouchers give parents the freedom to choose a private school for their children, using all or part of the public funding set aside for their children’s education. Under such a program, funds typically expended by a school district would be allocated to a participating family in the form of a voucher to pay partial or full tuition for their child’s private school, including both religious and non-religious options (www.edchoice.org).
In a nutshell, vouchers are monies given to students in order to attend a school of their choice. The first sentence of the foundation’s explanation lays out the first benefit gained from the voucher program. What incites people to the idea of the voucher system is the opportunity that is given to low-income families to send their children off to an elite private school. While many are blinded by this aspiring opportunity, others, like Barbara Miner, look beyond the sugarcoated promises made by voucher programs. In her article, “Why I Don’t Vouch For Vouchers,” Miner makes a very interesting point by saying, “Private schools can control whom they accept and the terms upon which students stay enrolled. […] The schools are to select on a random basis, […] one problem, however, is enforcement. Who ensures that the rules are followed?” (1998). Parents do not realize that, although they are promised to be provided a better education for their children, they are never guaranteed that the child will be accepted to the school they choose, or whether they will succeed in a private school rather than in a public school. Yet again, Miner makes another thought-provoking point in questioning the furthering of segregation in schools through the voucher system. To provide an answer to this question she points out some statistics from a school in Milwaukee:
In Milwaukee, the public schools are approximately 60 percent African American. At Divine Savior/Holy Angels and Pius XIth High Schools, only 3 percent of the students are African American. At Milwaukee’s most elite religious high school, Marquette University High School, 5 percent of the students are African American. Some religious elementary schools in Milwaukee do not have any African American students (Miner, 1998).
Whether these numbers may just be sheer coincidence or intentional, the idea of providing vouchers to parents as a means of reserving the best possible education for their children do not come with a guarantee that the school they choose will be a safe haven and far better than public schooling. Another benefit gained
Show More

Related Documents: School Vouchers Essay

Charter Schools Vs School Vouchers

traditional public education, the public school system offers a one-size-fits-all method of education of children in the decades. Enter the 21st century, more and more children began to fall behind in a rapidly changing environment marked by the introduction of personal computers. Many people began to push for a new educational model which can keep up with the times. Both charter schools and school voucher programs are collectively referred to as “school choice” initiatives, because they allow parents…

Words 733 - Pages 3

School Vouchers Essay example

government today is the issue of school vouchers. Many people are sided over this educational issue. Some wonder about the practicality of using the vouchers, while others wonder if it is defeating the purpose of the educational system. Educational vouchers can be very beneficial for both the student and even the school districts involved in the program. Many people do not realize the benefits of this program. Educational vouchers are something that many school districts need to implement due…

Words 1799 - Pages 8

Lifters: School Voucher and Dad. Happy Fathers Essay

or role model that I will ever have. Imagine going to school and finding half of your friends are moving to different schools because they have qualified for a school voucher. It’s difficult to see them go because you have known them all your life. It’s also difficult to watch them attend the school which everyone knows in your community is known to better than the one you are currently attending. Questions are also brought up to your mind with school vouchers. Students who don’t qualify may ask themselves…

Words 399 - Pages 2

Against Vouchers Research Paper

ensure all students - regardless of race, color, national origin, disability, or zip code- have equal access to education resources that includes academic and extracurricular programs, strong teaching, technology and instructional materials, and a safe school environment. The argument surrounding student success has been historically concentrated on the No Child Left Behind (NCLB) Act of 2001, which is an Act of Congress that is the flagship program for disadvantaged students. The NCLB focus shuts out…

Words 775 - Pages 4

Week 3 School Funding Issues Essay

School Funding Issues 1 Shanice Johnson School Funding Issues AED/200 January 25, 2015 School Funding Issues 2 Some people say that having school options such as private, magnet, charter, or home schooling does affect school funding for the public school system. They say that the fewer students in the public schools, the less funding the school will receive. Other people say that having school options does not affect school funding for public schools…

Words 443 - Pages 2

Zelman vs. Simon Harris Essay

about vouchers being provided to children for alternative education in Ohio. This was a pilot program set up to give equal educational opportunities to families who resided in the Cleveland City School District. This program was designed for families who needed financial aid for their children’s education and whose public school system had failed to provide them with a basic education. Through this scholarship program, the parents could send their children to either a school or a private school (religious…

Words 839 - Pages 4

school choice Essay examples

School Choice in Ward Eight School choice is a wide array of programs aimed at giving families the opportunity to choose the school their children will attend. As a matter of form, school choice does not give preference to one form of schooling or another, rather manifests itself whenever a student attends school outside of the one they would have been assigned to by geographic default. The most common options offered by school choice programs are open enrollment laws that allow students to attend…

Words 927 - Pages 4

What Is The Future Of Educational Finance

will impact school funding. Rulings such as the Lemon Test and separation of church and state will impact decisions that can potentially result in litigation and court rulings dictating educational decisions. In his work…

Words 4080 - Pages 17

Families and School Choice Essay

obligation. All families should have a school choice for their children with programs such as magnet or charter schools, or voucher programs. In fact, they should be available to students regardless of income or zip code. Public schools serve the vast majority of students and are critical to the educational success of our nation. Educational choice doesn't diminish the role public schools play in preparing students for post-academic life. However, if a school, public or private, is not meeting a…

Words 1354 - Pages 6

Cuts In Federal Rent Aid Are Squeezing Minnesota's Poor

grueling days scouring the North Mankato area, by public transit and taxi, for an affordable apartment and a landlord willing to accept her rental voucher, which would cover two-thirds of her rent. General Mills scores a win in Greek yogurt ad fight against rival… But her search ended quite unexpectedly two weeks before Christmas, when her unused voucher was revoked because of budget cuts enacted by Congress last year. “I felt like my ticket out of poverty had been stolen from me,” said Stevenson…

Words 1763 - Pages 8