Scientific Method and Critical Reflection Essay

Submitted By davidmpenn
Words: 723
Pages: 3
Open Document
Critical Reflections of Theory and Research
David M. Penn
Walden University

The Role of Theory
Theory refers to a particular kind of illumination. It is a structured body of principles and concepts with intent to provide insight or explanation pertaining to a particular phenomenon. Consequently, theories attempt to explain why and how something operates the way it does and postulates what kind of implications or impacts it may have (Browne & Keeley, 2007, pp. 4-6). In essence, theoretical perspectives provide an opportunity for critical reflection by the global community. The aim is to shape how scholar-practitioners identify a defined research dilemma, how to frame the research and methodological parameters with which to address it. The connection between theory and research is reciprocal. Without critical evaluation of research, academics are condemned to merely regurgitate espoused thought or practice. Through theorization and research, Ph.D. students generate interconnected ideas that are systematically formulated and organized, illuminate issues and confirm or disprove assertions using various research methods (Brookfield, 1995, pp. 185-206).
The Influence of Theory
As asserted by Brookfield (1995) the study of theoretical canon is fundamental to the Ph.D. student’s development (p. 189). Essential to this process of study, one must consistently ask the right type of questions throughout critical reading (Browne & Keeley, 2007). In Brookfield’s (1995) view, the questions should be epistemological, experiential, communicative, and political in nature (p. 189). Having a historical perspective of ideas presented in theory is essential through the epistemological lens. It asks for traditions that are intellectually significant to be evaluated not only by the scrutiny of the actual evidence provided but also research methods and empirical data (Brookfield, 1995, p. 2). Wright (2008) supports this line of questioning contending that the ability to speak knowledgeably about theory is the capacity to interpret and understand the analysis and data and how it relates to the theory (p. 2). The responsibility is on the student to be well-read and analyze accordingly. Experiential questions lead pupils to examine the autobiographical nature of the written work. There may be biases, culturally based distortions or ethical conundrums that may influence the author that the reader must take into account (p. 193). A form of communicative inquiry affords the reader insight into how the author attempts to facilitate understanding of the theory through language. The careful selection and arrangement of terminology and general wording are needed in order to reach the broad spectrum of readers and actively engage the audience (p. 198). Politically motivated questions are necessary so the reader may deduce whose interest does this work benefit and what actions could be inspired or impeded (p. 200). Ph.D. students asking these types of questions may be able to filter intense amounts of literary stimuli, make sense of information presented and apply or dismiss it appropriately (Brookfield, 1995, pp. 185-206).
Primary Strategy of Theoretical and Critical Reflection
Lastly, Brookfield
Show More

Related Documents: Scientific Method and Critical Reflection Essay

Introduction To Psychology

Intro to Psychology: Chapter 1 1. Critical thinking in psychology can be described as a method as mentioned in the book to evaluate, compare, analyze, critique, and synthesize information. Critical thinking is a type of reflection. Critical thinkers often are open minded and more willingly to question and challenge specific ideas and beliefs with scientific explanation and observation. (2013) “Critical thinkers evaluate ideas by probing for weaknesses in their reasoning and analyzing the evidence…

Words 397 - Pages 2

Film Analysis Of The Film Reflection Of 'Contact'

Film reflection of “Contact” T.W The film focuses on a female scientists Ellie who believed in science pursuing scientific answers, in the story she firmly believed that there is life on other planets. She broke through many difficulties and eventually visited “other planets.” In a short visit, she passed many time-spaces, saw the beautiful and vast space world, and saw her father. But when she tried to prove herself what she saw and heard after she woke up, she could not find…

Words 735 - Pages 3

Essay about HLC122 LEO Lectures Wk1 Concepts Of Clinical Reasoning Critical Thinking And EBP

18/02/2015 HLSC122 Inquiry in Health care Mini Lecture 1 Concepts of clinical reasoning, critical thinking, and evidence‐based‐ practice part 1 Presented by: Dr Joe Perry(LIC) Introduction What will be covered: • Making meaning • What is critical thinking? • What is critical reasoning? • Why are these important? • Critical reflection • This mini‐lecture serves as an introduction and guide to the contents of Modules 1 & 2 2 Making meaning • Unit description: “This inter‐professional unit provides…

Words 1080 - Pages 5

The Importance Of Science In Science

facts and information and problem solving skills with means that foster students’ curiosity and investigate in the socio-scientific world of science (Albe, 2008). In science, our current knowledge is limited and there are a lot of problems to be solved. This sets the platform for students to participate in searching and generating new knowledge. The first step in such scientific journey is being curious. So science teachers have huge responsibilities in instigating student curiosity by careful planning…

Words 1877 - Pages 8

Historiography From Ranke's Perspective

His method of scientific history, combining historical and scientific research methods, have transformed how history is written. In the American Scholar, a scholarly journal an article entitled, Historiography: What Ranke Meant, discusses Ranke’s method of historical investigations, “One claim is that history is a science, that it is primarily concerned with facts and their casual connection – how they acted upon each other. Like any other science, therefore, history has its own method, the critical…

Words 634 - Pages 3

Scientific Underpinning Reflection

My Reflection on Scientific Underpinnings The Nursing profession of today and in preparation for nursing in the next generation has called for upgrading in advanced practice nursing education to a higher degree (Cronenwett, Dracup, Grey, McCauley, Meleis, & Salmon, 2011). In 2004, American Association of Colleges of Nursing (AACN) gave approval for the preparation of all Advanced Practice Registered Nurses (APRN) in Doctor of Nursing Practice (DNP) program (Potempa, 2011). The scientific…

Words 545 - Pages 3

Essay on Clinical Reasoning: Combining Research and Knowledge to Enhance Client Care

Making sound and client-centered clinical decisions in an area that demands accountability and evidence-based practice requires not only scientific knowledge, but also a deep knowledge of the practice of one’s profession and of what it means to be human in the world of combined strength and vulnerability that is health care. Every clinician must understand the importance of applying best research evidence to client care, the essence of evidence–based practice, to improve the overall quality…

Words 2463 - Pages 10

Scientific Method and Operational Definition Essay

Team Week One Reflection Paper RES 351 Team Week One Reflection Paper In week one, we discussed the need for operational definition. Operational definition is critical when collecting all data. Operational definition identifies one or more specifics, observable events or conditions such that any other researcher can independently measure and or test them. We learned when using operational definition, it will allow you to decipher though the data to determine if the research is valid or…

Words 921 - Pages 4

Psych 100 Paper Guideline F2014

theoretical proposition? c. How was the study/studies conducted? d. What was the result and how was it interpreted? 2). Your critical reflection: a. Evaluate the importance of the research (contribution to the field, significance of the finding, etc..) b. How do you evaluate the method the researchers chose? (If you like it, why? If you don't like it, do you think an alternative method might have been adopted?) c. How might the findings enlighten future research in psychology or in other disciplines?…

Words 1426 - Pages 6

The Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution: Essay

The Enlightenment and the Scientific Revolution: Men of Ideas Creating Change Nicole Hill The eighteenth century is often referred to as the Enlightenment. The ideas of many individuals combined to create a movement that would not only sweep across Europe, but reach as far as the America's. The idea of a world without caste, class or institutionalized crudity was what many were striving to achieve. Coinciding with the Enlightenment was the Scientific Revolution. Advancements in astronomy, technology…

Words 1840 - Pages 8