Search and Seizure in Public Schools Essay

Words: 1913
Pages: 8
Open Document
Purpose The purpose of this paper is to discuss public school districts' limits on "hate" speech and reconcile those limits with the decision in Tinker v. Des Moines.

Importance to Education

To avoid disturbance and disruption and to create and maintain a safe learning environment, public schools often adopt policies that forbid certain acts on the part of students. Included in many of these policies are prohibitions on hate speech. The opinion of the court in Tinker v. Des Moines (1969) broadly stated that students retain their first amendment rights when they enter the school, but the breadth of that statement is not without limit. Schools may narrowly curtail free speech rights to the extent necessary to maintain good …show more content…
Tyler Harper wore a t-shirt to school that carried several messages: "I will not accept what God has condemned." "Homosexuality is shameful ‘Romans 1:27'" The next day, Harper wore the same shirt and added to the front, "Be ashamed, our school embraced what God has condemned." Harper refused to take the shirt off when told it was inflammatory and in violation of the school's dress code, and spent the day in the principal's office. He was not suspended. Harper filed suit in federal court, claiming his rights to free speech and free exercise of religion, equal protection and due process had been violated and sought an injunction to enjoin the school from continuing to violate his constitutional rights. After several motions, the trial court denied Harper's motion for preliminary injunction. Harper appealed the denial of injunctive relief. (Harper, 2006, p. 1173) In an opinion that apparently shrinks the scope of Tinker, the court of appeals for the ninth federal circuit affirmed the trial court. The court's ruling was based upon a finding that some speech is so psychologically damaging to vulnerable students that it can be banned completely. The Harper court characterized student speech that demeans other students' core characteristics, such as race, religion or sexual orientation, more akin to assault than constitutionally protected speech. (Harper v. Poway, 2006, p. 1178) Another recent
Show More

Related Documents: Search and Seizure in Public Schools Essay

Essay about Point of Law

Point of Law—Search and Seizure in the Classroom Eric Zorn ELS 657: Public School Law Dr. Mark Lineburg 11/28/12 Abstract Students in today’s schools are often concerned that their constitutional rights are being violated by teachers and administrators. Specifically, they are concerned that their privacy is being violated when there are random classroom searches. Upon reviewing relevant court cases and judicial documents it is clear that what students perceive as violation of their rights…

Words 1898 - Pages 8

Arguments Against The 4th Amendment

of the United States Constitution states that is a natural right of man to be protected random searches and seizures, programmed by the government. It also implements the idea of the right to privacy, and involves the uses of warrants, a method used by the British known as “writs of assistance. Although the Fourth Amendment protects persons’ rights against unreasonable searches and seizures, it also protects their undisclosed right to privacy. The right to privacy is sprinkled throughout the Bill…

Words 936 - Pages 4

Case TLO V. New Jersey

Civics Essay If Katz had the right to privacy in a public phone booth, then why do we give up that right in a public school? TLO should be not guilty her 4th amendment rights were violated and she should have been innocent. In the case Katz v. United States, Katz was suspected of involvement of illegal gambling activities, and he was relaying gambling information across the phone in a public telephone booth. It was ruled unconstitutional because the FBI needed a warrant to listen in to Katz's…

Words 673 - Pages 3

T. L. O. Case Study

Tracy Lois Odem (also known as T.L.O.) was a 14-year-old girl attending Piscataway Township High School. One day she was smoking with a friend in the bathroom. One of the teachers walked in and confronted them. T.L.O. and her friend were taken to the Principal's office. Where an Administrator asked them if they were smoking. One of the girls confessed and said she had smoked. The other girl known as T.L.O denied it. The administrator wasn’t buying it and asked to see her purse. Once T.L.O refused…

Words 1944 - Pages 8

Legal Memorandum Essay

file No.: 12095 Public school searches Date: June 6, 2013 I. Issues 1. The issue is whether public school officials have the authority to perform strip searches of students in suspicion of hiding illegal drugs. 2. The issue is whether public school districts can perform random drug screening of students who participate in school athletic programs under state or federal law. II. Brief Answers 1. No. Strip searches of students in public schools of students are…

Words 2791 - Pages 12

Facts of the case TLO Essays

Facts of the case: A teacher at a local high school witnessed two girls smoking at the lavatory and one of the girls was T.L.O. The teacher sent the girls to the principal’s office where the girls talked to the vice principal Theodore Choplick because it is a violation of the schools policy. One of the girls admitted to smoking in the lavatory while T.L.O. denied that she was smoking in the lavatory. Mr. Choplick escorted T.L.O to his privet office and demanded to see her purse and found a pack of…

Words 745 - Pages 3

Search and Siezure Essay

abuse concerns, confidentiality, search and seizure, parental custody, and First Amendment interpretation are some of the main legal and ethical issues facing our school according to my principal and assistant principal. My principal’s previous experiences were as a business owner, college leader, school counselor and church member. He has over thirty years of experience. He highlighted issues of parental custody and student discipline as those that affect our school the most. Reflecting on a recent…

Words 2633 - Pages 11

The Fourth Amendment Analysis

several years the Government of the United States has been caught red-handed collecting citizens’ public and private information through web traffic and other web-based mediums. The Government has employed the use of secret court orders as well as surveillance programs such as PRISM in which they work closely with private organizations to obtain this information. The issue was widely brought to the public eye by the confidential files that Edward J. Snowden released in 2013 through 2014. The revelation…

Words 798 - Pages 4

Argumentative Essay

Student Name Instructor Course Date of Submission On Preventing the Use of Drugs in School Between one in five and one in three high school students in America have used drugs or alcohol.1 Many of these children see drugs for the first time while they are at school. The ever-increasing problem of teenage drug use can hardly be understated. That is why teachers should have the right to search students for drugs on school grounds. The Fourth Amendment states that “The right of the people to be secure…

Words 1310 - Pages 6

4th Amendment Case Study

persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures and that no warrant can be issued without probable cause (Constitution Center). Selective incorporations gives the courts the rights to make universal rules about the 4th amendment defining what search and seizure mean. The court case Smith v. Maryland identified when a search warrant is needed and that there has been an understanding of when a search warrant is justified. In 1967, the idea of an expectation of privacy…

Words 510 - Pages 3