Should All Morals Be Treated the Same? Essays

Submitted By RandiCarter1
Words: 733
Pages: 3
Open Document
Should All Morals be Treated the Same?
Randi Carter
SOC120
Professor Barton
August 2013

In the article written by Lenn E. Goodman called Some Moral Minima, Goodman attempts to point out that we should have a universal feeling about certain morals. He states that there are a few areas where human practices are indisputably wrong and that they are never questioned because they shouldn’t exist. The article goes on to specifically address certain areas like murder, genocide, terrorism, polygamy and rape, to name a few. Goodman does make some valid points, but the practices he chose to discuss, I feel, are too broad. Not everyone’s values and morals are the same. One would think that all morals and values should be the same, but ethics are almost always subjective and relative to their situation and cultural context. I am in agreement with the topics Goodman has chosen, but in some cases, he oversteps his boundaries. Author Goodman claims that “all living beings make claims to life” and that “murder is wrong because it destroys a human subject”. This would generally be considered true. Like everything in the world, it is also subjective to the situation. Do you feel it’s wrong to kill a person in self-defense? There are certain situations where taking a life is considered justifiable. Genocide, which “targets individuals as members of a group, seeking to destroy a race, culture, ethnic class or ethnic identity” (Goodman, 2010) is wrong; the killing of innocent people is part of warfare. You would think ending the war quicker would help protect the innocent people from being hurt; but dragging out the war is in its nature. Goodman also speaks of terrorism. He states “terrorism is willful targeting of non-combatants, aiming to intimidate and attract attention. It is a war crime, since war seeks only to block an enemy’s ability to make war” (Goodman, 2010). This thought is too subjective. If the purpose of terrorism was to defeat an enemy of war as quickly as possible and in addition to prevent further invasion from a recurring enemy, then this is a justifiable means to an end. Next, Goodman’s article focuses on the quality of life that people have a right to live. By associating polygamy with such acts as slavery and human trafficking, Goodman has created an inconsistency in his reasoning. There isn’t any disputing that abuse can and in many cases does take place in polygamous situations. In these cases, it is the actual abuses that should be dealt with rather than the attack on polygamy itself. Child brides and abusive relationships may be part of some polygamous acts; however it is a very generalized statement to say all polygamist families share in these abuses. Goodman also states that polygamy is “not conducive to familial stability or the growth of emotionally fearless
Show More

Related Documents: Should All Morals Be Treated the Same? Essays

To Kill a Mocking Bird Essay

inequality and “moral” education. The author, Harper Lee, is constantly making the audience question the ideas of the text. Since this novel was written in the 1950’s she is saying that inequality is wrong and people’s morals should be more accepting of others. The purpose of this novel is to entertain the audience whilst at the same time persuading them towards Lee’s viewpoint. This novel is trying to get the reader to agree with Lee’s viewpoint that inequality is wrong and people’s morals should be more…

Words 1170 - Pages 5

How Frederick Douglass Treat People

than what Douglass says people should be treated as, which is as ends. Treating people as ends and not means, is really thinking and considering a person’s soul and understanding that they are people too. No matter who you are and no matter what you do, we all deserve to be treated the same and treated with the respect and love that we all need. Being treated as an end, is an intrinsic value, while being treated as means, is an extrinsic value. Human beings have a moral duty to treat themselves and…

Words 961 - Pages 4

Army Value Of Respect

valuable, morally and ethically accepted by the person giving the respect. The Army value of respect means to me that I should treat people the way they should be treated and get the same treatment back, unfortunately this is not a common practice in the Military. The Army value of respect promote treating others with respect and establish guideline for you to be treated the same way, when it comes to leadership, one of the attribute that most leaders are lacking is respect, let’s begin with the facts…

Words 545 - Pages 3

'Countee Cullen And Jean Toomer's Song Of The Son'

choices they made hundreds of years ago. Their decisions and choices many years ago would not be accepted in today’s society. I want to acknowledge that if they were still alive, they would not be accepted into today’s society because of the wrongful moral decisions they made. The main idea is to control past historical figures' decisions about owning slaves and why the decisions they made still have an effect today. In Frederick Douglass’ “What to the Slave is the Fourth of July,” he summarizes slavery…

Words 1111 - Pages 5

Essay on Animal Liberation Front

course of action in a given situation should be the one that provides the greatest happiness overall, and is a form of consequentialism. He argues that the greatest happiness principle of utilitarianism should be extended to include the welfare of animals, not just humans. Singer states that humans have developed what he calls “speciesism,” in that we have a bias toward our own species in the same sense as racism and sexism. Singer also argues that animals should be included in utilitarian decisions…

Words 1394 - Pages 6

Utilitarian And Kantian Philosophical Analysis

Utilitarian and Kantian Moral Theories will be applied in response. To begin one may say that a Utilitarian would not support such an action, because the blacksmith has killed a person and is a detriment to society. Allowing him to live with such actions would cause more disutility to the town. The older…

Words 1664 - Pages 7

Essay about Kant v

Adam Smith and Immanuel Kant I realized how different philosopher’s views are from each other. Understanding both views gave me insight on how I would also want others to comprehend the world. In Adam Smith’s, Theory of Moral Sentiments, he argues that sympathy is the basis of moral virtue. Smith believes that morality is about sympathizing with others with the hopes that they will then, in return, sympathize with us. This sympathy is not only about being there for someone when a relative passes away…

Words 1390 - Pages 6

Civil Disobedience Acceptable Times Essay

Times for Civil Disobedience Most people do not know what civil disobedience is. Civil disobedience is when a person breaks a rule or law because of morals and beliefs (“Civil Disobedience”). Martin Luther King, Junior’s “Letter from Birmingham Jail” is an example of when civil disobedience is acceptable. The Negroes in the piece of text are treated unjustly. Officials are not willing to help the negroes, so some have come to accept the fact that they will have many disadvantages in society. There…

Words 1016 - Pages 5

Case Study Essay

decision a moral one pursuant to Utilitarian ethics? Why or why not? No, because the verdict was not good for everyone as a whole and based on this ethic the verdict benefitted Wal-Mart and Wal-Mart only. These women were in no form or shape compensated for how they were under paid etc. and this brought on more feelings of worthlessness and unfair conditions for the women who already felt things were not fair at their place of employment from the beginning. 3. Is the decision a moral one pursuant…

Words 408 - Pages 2

Essay on Morality and Animal Rights Theory

domestic and wild animals are treated. The research will summarize and critique four theories including anthropocentrism, Animal Liberation, Strong Animal Rights Theory, and Weaker animal rights theory. II. Anthropocentrism A. Definition 1. The belief that human beings are the central. 2. The assessment of reality through an exclusively human perspective. B. How Anthropocentrism theory asserts 1. Animals are not human they do not possess logic. 2. They should not be treated in a manner that is logical…

Words 1000 - Pages 4