Should We Have a Bill of Rights? Essay

Submitted By Brendan163
Words: 806
Pages: 4
Open Document
Good afternoon I am Brendan Jones and would like to thank you firstly for the opportunity to participate in this event. Australia is a modernised western society and is a signatory to all five international treaties that make up the International Bill of Human Rights, but, none of these treaties is legally binding in Australia, and there is not a Bill of Rights in the Australian Constitution. This means that the fundamental rights and freedoms of everyone living in Australia are not protected by law. In recent years the High Court has found that additional rights for individuals may be necessarily implied by the language and structure of the Constitution, but is not in any form of writing in the constitution.
So why should we include it in the Constitution and why is it so important? Bill of rights is a constitutional provision which protects the individual’s right from infringement by the legislature or the executive power. The most famous bill of rights belonging to America, although the Bill of rights for Australia would not take this exact form, for one example thou shall bear arms would conflict with the legislation of assault arms ban Without this right, people of Australia are at the discretionary power of the state and territory governments. University of NSW Faculty of Law senior research fellow Christopher Michaelson compared Queensland’s Anti Bikie Act with that of a dictatorial regime. It is this kind of act that is criminalising innocent people. This law states expand polices powers over innocent people, numerous lawyers have stated that these laws act on and can be used against any group in society. (ABC NEWS By Greg Barns Posted Wed 16 Oct 2013, 3:03pm AEDT ).
To rely on the benevolence or honesty of the Police Commissioner, Attorney-General or Government of the time is naivety in the extreme and fraught with danger. Many states around Australia have jumped on the bandwagon, such as that is the South Australian, Rann Governments SOCCA act and some have or are in the process of approving their own legislation each trying to outdo the other in terms of “toughness”. It is worth noting that only Victoria and the ACT have remained a part from the other states in the push for “anti-bikie” laws, the same two who are the only jurisdictions in Australia that have a locally legislated form of a Bill of Rights.

In regards to the new discriminatory, unconstitutional and tyrannical laws put forth by Campbell Newman in the state of Queensland in Australia that are rightfully being questioned and criticised here please note: "The Australian Constitution, which under Chapter 5, The States, recognises the rights of the individual States. Section 106 deals with the Saving of the States Constitutions, section 107 with saving the power of State Parliaments, section 108 with saving of State Laws, and section 109 with the inconsistency of laws, which says, “When a law of a State is inconsistent with a law of the Commonwealth, the latter shall prevail, and the former shall, to the extent of the inconsistency, be invalid.” - Thus it can be seen that the new discriminatory tyrannical laws put forth by Campbell Newman in the state
Show More

Related Documents: Should We Have a Bill of Rights? Essay

Essay On Bill Of Rights

has won its independence we still have a few minor setbacks and a huge debate of whether we should add a bill of rights or not. I firmly believe we do not need a bill of rights. Bill of Rights would only make people think they have no basic human rights as the bill of rights consist of specific individuals rights and freedom of the people. It’s very to say the least useless. The Constitution itself is good the way it is. The reason I state that the adding a bill of rights is absolutely unneeded for…

Words 510 - Pages 3

Pros And Cons Of Alexander Hamilton

Melissa Gutierrez Hernandez Professor Tomasz Stanek HIST 107 January 18, 2018 Why did Alexander Hamilton oppose adding a bill of rights to the constitution? Amid the late eighteenth century, the Antifederalists contended against the constitution in light of the fact that it didn't contain a bill of rights. They trusted that without a rundown of individual flexibilities, the new national government may mishandle its forces and that the states would be inundated by an all to prevailing and persuasive…

Words 614 - Pages 3

Contrast The Arguments Between The Federalist And Anti-Federalists

in grand favor of including the Bill of Rights in the United States Constitution. The Federalists however strongly opposed this idea stating that there was no need for them whatsoever. But as a Franz Kafka once famously said “Better to have, and not need, than to need, and not have”. I agree with the anti-federalists and their statements ensuring that our rights be protected even if we may not need it but at least we will have it. Although the Federalists may have…

Words 641 - Pages 3

of clay Essays

States wanted to insure everyone’s rights they did so by adding a Bill of Rights. Framers of the Constitution disagreed with the fact of adding the Bill of Rights to the constitution because they felt it was “Invading on people’s personal lives.’’ The causes of the disagreement is over the Bill of Rights is people had different opinions if the Bill of Rights should really be added, the effects would be letting the people choose if there should be a Bill of Rights , and a big political debate. One…

Words 373 - Pages 2

Why We Should Allowe Prayer Be Allowed In Schools

religion and morality. Former president George Washington said that if anyone tried to attack these morals then they shouldn’t consider themselves to be a true, loyal American. The First Amendment of this nation’s Constitution clearly states that we have protection of expressing our religious beliefs from the government trying to control us. But in 1801 a rumor started up that the Congregationalist denomination was about to become the national denomination. Many people went to President Thomas Jefferson…

Words 1150 - Pages 5

Argumentative Essay: Should Gun Background Checks

subject. It is not easy to control gun circulation especially when we can not keep it out of hands of felons or potential felons. This gunman had 10 rifles and, do you know where he got them, not from a gun dealer. There is a bill in process that will help stop this issue but I wonder will it. The official title of this bill is, “Should Gun Sellers Have to Wait for a Completed Background Check to Transfer a Firearm(H.R. 3464)”. This bill will make it a priority for a gun dealer to make gun buyers go…

Words 1243 - Pages 5

Bill Of Rights Impact

The Bill of Rights has impacted American society in many ways, some of these ways are: it helped individual rights and also limited government power. The down side of the Bill of Rights is argued that is gives too much freedom to citizens. However, it has greatly impacted our society by making more individual and has greatly limited the government power. Therefore, the impact that the Bill of Rights has on American society is still in use in today's society. One may argue that the Bill of Rights…

Words 532 - Pages 3

Importance Of The First Amendment

“A Bill of Rights are what the people are entitled to against every government, and what no just government should refuse or rest on interference.” -Thomas Jefferson, third president of the United States of America. As Jefferson says the Bill of rights was created to protect and obtain the rights of American people and prevent our rights from being violated by the government. In present time some of our rights are being bended and molded by the government to seem as though they are not being violated…

Words 1081 - Pages 5

Limited Government: The Most Influential Part Of The Government

government has stopped the government from being too controlling of what people do. Checks and balances is my first piece of evidence and checks and balances is evidence because it has stopped the government from being too powerful and violating people's rights. Checks and balances stops one branch of government from becoming too powerful and…

Words 493 - Pages 2

Violations In The Film 'Miss Evers' Boys

Should a patient be told everything about their diagnosis and treatment? I believe patients should be told everything about their care. We all have the right to know. I would want to know. The film “Miss Evers’ Boys” provides viewers with several examples of legal and ethical violations such as residents bill of rights, patients bill of rights and the privacy act (HIPAA). The first violation I viewed is residents bill of rights. Residents bill of rights says "patient has Free Choice regarding the…

Words 319 - Pages 2