Socrates Arguments Against Euthyphro's Definition

Words: 322

Pages: 2

The Greek philosopher Socrates gives a strong reason for the objectivist position, and this is that the Gods love an act or action because they detect the piety in them. Therefore, the definition given by Euthyphro cannot be the right definition. Yes, these are compelling because if we take an example of morality, we can experience that some people call a particular action executed by a person moral and some, call the same action immoral. There is some universal condition or rule attached to morality. In the absence of this universal condition, a particular action becomes immoral for the same people.
Socrates argument against Euthyphro’s second definition of piety works wonderfully because if there is disagreement among Gods as stated by Euthyphro,

Show More

Euthyphro and Piety Essay

and the definition of holiness/piety. The dialogue Euthyphro was written by Socrates' protege Plato during the weeks leading up Socrates' trial in which he was accused of corrupting the youth in Athens. It features Socrates and religious expert Euthyphro engaged in a discussion attempting to define holiness. Euthyphro displays the methods Socrates used to try to gain wisdom and his and Plato's views on holiness. The concept of holiness emerges in the dialogue Euthyphro because Socrates is facing…

Words 1057 - Pages 5

Euthyphro's Response To Socrates

learning, as drawn out of Euthyphro by Socrates, is that unlike his counterpart [Euthyphro], Socrates was enforcing his own manner of wisdom, if not skepticism, and that he was preparing both his own defense as well as empowering Euthyphro with a logical basis by which to either proceed with, or rescind in full, the charges against his father based on the logic presented by Plato thus far. (Jowett, 2008) When pressed by Socrates regarding Euthyphro’s self-alleged or perceived sacred duty to…

Words 849 - Pages 4

Interlocutor's Argument Analysis

knowledge are inconsistent with the argument. One implication of Plato’s claims was demonstrated by Socrates against Euthyphro, in regards to Euthyphro’s knowledge claim stating that piety is what is loved…

Words 1696 - Pages 7

Euthyphro And Confucius's Argument Analysis

Good and Bad Citizens: Euthyphro’s logic vs Analects’ moral choices Both Plato’s Euthyphro and Confucius’s Analects coincide in interpreting good citizenship through the knowledge of piousness. Confucius’s Analects at first may appear as a stronger ideological discipline of good citizenship because all actions committed by humanity are based on moral and ethical choices. However, Plato’s Euthyphro accentuates that good citizens should follow reason and knowledge to based their choices and consequences…

Words 1392 - Pages 6

Euthyphro's The Trial And Death Of Socrates

Euthyphro’s part on “The Trial and Death of Socrates” starts when Euthyphro talks to Socrates. Euthyphro asks Socrates why he left the Lyceum (the Lyceum was an outdoor gymnasium outside of the walls of Athens) and why he is spending time in one of the nine principal magistrates of Athens also known as “King-Archon”. Before Socrates answers, Euthyphro adds that he probably is not there for the same reason as him. Socrates starts telling about Athenian’s thoughts and how they didn’t call the reason…

Words 922 - Pages 4

Rhetorical Analysis On Euthyphro

Euthyphro focuses on what is pious and impious for this section, describing pious as “what all gods love” and impious as “what all gods hate”. Socrates states, "I give you that all the Gods hate what your father did; I waive the point about one God's hating what another God loves; if you like, say that the pious is what all the Gods love and the impious is what all the Gods hate, so as to be sure that the same act is not both pious and impious. Even so, will your account of piety and impiety stand…

Words 303 - Pages 2

The Case Of The Blind Man

The intention of this paper is to examine the case methodologically to determine what Socrates' opinion would likely be. This will be accomplished by examining Socrates' writings for similar logic and/or rebuttals of others' arguments that would support an assertion of what Socrates would say of this case. Specifically, The Republic “Euthyphro” and ”Phaedrus” are pieces from Plato that we can use to examine Socrates' ideas. The first statement of the case is that “A blind man shall receive a thousand…

Words 958 - Pages 4

Chapter 14 Refutation 1 Essay examples

the conclusion must necessarily follows from the premises. That is, the argument must be formally valid—have a valid form—and therefore avoid formal fallacies such as those discussed earlier in this book. However, sound reasoning requires more than just that the conclusion follow from the premises. The premises themselves must also be rational or justified. As you have already seen, the conclusions of valid deductive arguments can turn out false unless the premises are also true. The importance of…

Words 3676 - Pages 15

Euthyphro essay

relationship between Piety and Justice, we must first define Piety. In The Euthyphro, several definitions are put forth for Piety, but the most compelling one to me is this. “Speaking freely, however, I can tell you that if a man knows how to say and do things acceptable to the gods in prayer and sacrifice, those things are holy.”(Plato, 17).Euthyphro’s definition works, however I would add a few things to make this definition clearer and more conclusive. Pious things are any prayer and/or action that is pleasing…

Words 917 - Pages 4