Negotiations In Combat Areas: The Effects Of Role Clarity And Concern For Members Of The Local Population

Submitted By balooandmowgli
Words: 1367
Pages: 6
Open Document
Soldier's Negotiations in Combat Areas: The Effects of Role Clarity and Concern For Members of the Local Population
Orly Ben-Yoav Nobel, Donald Campbell, Sean T. Hannah and Brian Wortinger
International Journal of Conflict Management, 2010
DOI: 10.1108/10444061011037413
Summarized By
This scholarly, peer-reviewed article was authored by current and former staff members of the United States Military Academy at WestPoint, New York. The article focuses on the level of importance related to both "role clarity" and needs of opposing parties during the negotiations process, with specific attention given to application during military operations.
Literature Review
The authors cited several social science journals and other publications during their authoring of this journal article. The authors discuss the evolution of United States military operations over the past few decades and how the inclusion of negotiations has become increasingly important. The use of negotiations during military operations can be found during operations related to intelligence gathering, civil administration, and peacekeeping in hostile regions throughout the world (p. 202). The authors discuss the current need for the modern soldier to utilize negotiation tactics (in addition to traditional war fighting, as some conflicts cannot be handled with words alone) to successfully build relationships and agreements between the United States and local groups (p. 203). In addition, United States military personnel are increasingly finding themselves to be the mediators between rivaling groups within a region (i.e. tribes in Afghanistan). Ineffective understanding and use of the negotiations process can literally mean the difference between life and death in wartime situations. For example, a soldier attempting to mediate an agreement between two rival tribes will ultimately fail (and possibly be killed) if they fail to differentiate between values and preferences when trying to figure out settlement ranges (i.e. Schatzki's L.A.R and M.S.P concepts) for each of the parties involved. Negotiations between parties with inflexible religious viewpoints can become emotionally charged quickly, leading to (in a warzone) a rapid escalation to violence.
The authors provide an explanation of two types of negotiation models: Distributive Bargaining and Integrative Bargaining. The authors describe the two methods as follows:
Distributive Bargaining: The idea that negotiations are an adversarial, win-lose situation. This type of bargaining is better suited for aggressive situations where no future negotiations are likely to take place (i.e. one-time deals)(p. 203). Integrative Bargaining: The idea that negotiations should be a win-win, and both sides assist each other to look for ways to fulfill mutual interests. This type of bargaining is better suited for close, continuing relationships where trust is important (p. 203).
The authors discuss their belief that Integrative Bargaining is the more useful of the two in situations where building ongoing relationships between the United States military and local tribes, as well as in proctoring deals (mediating) between rival factions (pp. 203-204). This is in contrast to what most people probably view as the role of the United States military as (aggressive fighters using superior power and strength to dominate). By utilizing carefully crafted negotiations strategies that aim for mutual gain, conflicts can be avoided and both sides can come close to reaching their maximum supportable position.
The authors point out that the Dual Concerns Model is one tool that can be utilized in examining the effectiveness of negotiations in relation to the level of clarity that is present in the process (p. 204). To summarize, the authors propose that the more clarity provided by each side, the better the outcomes will be in regards to developing and implementing agreements that are beneficial
Show More

Related Documents: Negotiations In Combat Areas: The Effects Of Role Clarity And Concern For Members Of The Local Population

Article Summaries Essay

Article Summaries Anne Jinner PSYCH600 June 30, 2014 Vineeta Kapoor Article Summaries Adolescent to emerging adulthood smoking trajectories: When do smoking trajectories diverge, and do they predict early adulthood nicotine dependence? Tobacco use is responsible for more deaths in the world than most other accidents and medical incidents combined (Riggs, Chih-Ping, Chaoyang, & Pentz, 2007). The reviews in this article show the results of a longitudinal research design conducted for studies from…

Words 875 - Pages 4

Article Summary Essay

Article Summary – Group 3 (National) Govt to create longer wait to become Canadian, strip citizenship from terrorists The Government of Canada is deciding to improve on its Citizenship Act. On Thursday, February 06, 2014, the government had voted for the rules and procedures of obtaining a Canadian Citizenship to be tightened so that there is a way to filter out all the criminals and those who engage in terrorism. Also, Canada found that by tightening the rules and procedures, there would be a…

Words 339 - Pages 2

Article Summary Essay

Article Summary The P90X system has become a popular workout to test your physical and mental stamina. This program has received great praise and criticism from the health community. WebMD contributor Dr. Michael Esco reviews the P90X program by outlining what it is, how it works, the pro, the cons, and the(50) bottom line. The article begins with an explanation of what the P90X system is. The system is described as an intense home DVD exercise program that boasts complete physical transformation…

Words 988 - Pages 4

Summary Article Essay

Questions: 1. What is crew integrity? 2. How does crew integrity play an important part in the fire ground operations? Summary: This article begins with reviewing two case studies that lead to a tragic loss of life, due to a breakdown in the crew integrity. The author gives his personal definition of crew integrity with putting together the dictionary definition of “crew and “integrity”, is “a group of people working together in a perfect condition. However, he states that for some reason “we continue…

Words 492 - Pages 2

Grossberg's Article Summary

In the article, Grossberg discusses the ever-changing view of people with disabilities, as well as, the changing policies that were enforced upon them. People in the mid 20th century feared anyone with a disability and “warned that feeble-minded children and adults undermined the social by spawning prostitution, delinquency, poverty, alcoholism, and countless other social pathologies” (Grossberg 730). Every new policy put into place was based on what amount of fear the common people felt towards…

Words 642 - Pages 3

Article summary Essay

Social Media. Most of us know social media is a tool used to help people communicate with one another; this type of technology seems to be changing the way we as humans interact with each other. There are many social networks that are supposed to encourage us to express ourselves. Facebook, Myspace, Twitter, and Instagram are all networks with the same purpose, for us to stay in touch with friends and family and to give us the freedom to express ourselves. Usually on some of these networking sites…

Words 323 - Pages 2

Strayhorn Article Summary

This article was written by Dr. Terrell Lamont Strayhorn—Director of the Center for Higher Education Enterprise. He is also Professor of Higher Education in the Department of Educational Studies within the College of Education and Human Ecology at The Ohio State University. Interestingly, in this article, Strayhorn began his introduction by showing research data from US Department of Education (p.90). It described a demographic distribution of college students—undergraduate, graduate and doctoral—that…

Words 636 - Pages 3

Article Summary I Essay

Article Summary I SUMMARY In “NextEra Buys Hawaii’s Biggest Utility in Green Energy Test” by Mark Chediak and Ehren Goossens explains a huge change will occur in the US electric power industry in the near future. Hawaii has a highest penetration using wind and solar power in the United States. NextEra Energy Inc. (NEE), North America as the largest generator of wind and solar power in the nation also know the situation in Hawaii and agreed to buy Hawaiian Electric Industries Inc. (HE) in order to…

Words 485 - Pages 2

Essay about Summary of Articles

Article One: Glaspell’s Trifles The first article that I viewed was called “Glaspell’s Trifles.” This article was summarizing what the short story by Glaspell wrote. They explained basically in detail what the short story was about. They used descriptive words to describe the feelings and what each character was surrounded by. It starts out by introducing the two main characters. Although neither of them are present in the legitimate short story they play a huge role in the story and without…

Words 2076 - Pages 9

Current Article Summary Essay

Current Article Summary HCS 325 September 21, 2014 Steven Fowler Healthcare is one of the most talked about issues, not only with social and economic reasons, but also for the rising cost that comes along with implementing new technology in the healthcare field. While more Americans are being covered by the new healthcare reform, other Americans are forced to face the reality of paying higher insurance cost. Most professional organizations are liable to pay for at least half of…

Words 397 - Pages 2