Supreme Court of the United States and Amendment Essay

Submitted By jairperez123
Words: 1077
Pages: 5
Open Document
New Jersey v. T.L.O:
Question:Did the search violate the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments?
Decision: The decision of this case was a 5 to 3 vote for the State of New Jersey..
Majority:The decision was a majority decision because they agreed that students don't have privacy for the item they taking into school grounds. The reason for this decision is because the student made the decision to bring inapropriate items into school grounds. A teacher obtaining a warrant before ssearching a suspicious child is an infraction to school rules and would dely the need to improve schools.
Concurring: Justice Blackmun has agreed with the judgment. He believes that the court has left of a crucial step in whether a school search should be based upon a probable cause or not. Eduction is the most important concern of the government, and government have the highest rights to protect students from things that would distract them from learning. The response to the threat of the learning environment was the correct decision because students education should be the number one importance to a school district.
Dissenting: The decision of searching without a warrant was considered against the fourth amendment because there wasn't any “probable cause”. Justice Brennan find that the principal had no right to keep on searching through T.L.O's purse because he found the pack of cigerrettes right when he opend the purse. At the poin t the search should've ended due to the fact that he only needed prove that she was smoking in the bathroom.
How was the Constitution interpreted?
Fourth Amendment: The constitution was not interpreted. The court abandoned the cause of the search of “probable cause” to accuse the student of violating the law. They decided to use a less strict standard of evidence to come to a final decision that the search was not violating the constitution. The court believed that the finding of rolling paper made the principal believe that T.L.O was carrying drugs in her purse. This gave the right for the principal to search the purse thoroughly.

Hazelwood School District v. Kuhlmeir:
Question
Did the principal's deletion of the articles violate the students' rights under the First Amendment?

Decision: 5 votes for Hazelwood and 3 votes against the district.
Majority: The Justices have recognized that the First Amendment right of the student in school settings is not compatible with the rights of adults. They believe that a school should not tolerate such foul language because it doesn't coexist with the eductional believes. They havecome to a conclusion that Principal Reynolds acted correctly by deleting the newspaper that Spectrum wrote about pregancy.
Dissenting: When students decided to take Journalism 2, they wanted civil duties too. Spectrum and others want to express their views while gaining an understanding of their right and duties under the First Amendment in the U.S. Constitution.These Justice believe that the speech did not distrub or potentially harm the learning environment in any way.

How was the constitution interpreted?
First Amendment: Speech, Press, and Assembly
The amendment was not violated because the court did not see that the First Amendment require achools to promote unusual types of student speech. The Court believed that school have the right to disregard any student speech as long as its against the shared values of a civilzed social group. Educators did not violate the First Amendments as long their decsions were reasonable and related or an actual concern.

Bethel School v. Fraser

Question
Does the First Amendment prevent a school district from disciplining a high school student for giving a lewd speech at a high school assembly?
Decision: The scored was 7 votes for Bethel School District No. 403 and 2 votes against

Majority: They believed that Fraser had no right to speak with such foul language in front of his peers just to promote his friend for elective office.
Show More

Related Documents: Supreme Court of the United States and Amendment Essay

Essay on First Amendment to the United States Constitution and u . s . Supreme Court

Significant historical events, court cases, and ideas that have shaped our current system of constitutional First Amendment jurisprudence: 1215 Abuses by England’s King John cause a revolt by nobles, who compel him to recognize rights for both noblemen and ordinary Englishmen. This document, known as the Magna Carta, establishes the principle that no one, including the king or a lawmaker, is above the law, and establishes a framework for future documents such as the Declaration of Independence…

Words 7937 - Pages 32

Supreme Court Cases: Freedom Of Speech In The First Amendment

The Supreme Court is the highest federal court. Each year thousands of people try to have the Supreme Court look at their case because for these people it is the last resort for justice, however most of the time the Supreme Court cannot view these cases. Approximately eighty cases or one percent of the cases are accepted each year. Once accepted they have a briefing and an oral argument. Soon after the justices of the Supreme Court make a precedent. Whenever the Supreme Court sets a precedent they…

Words 738 - Pages 3

Arguments Against The 4th Amendment

The Fourth Amendment of the United States Constitution states that is a natural right of man to be protected random searches and seizures, programmed by the government. It also implements the idea of the right to privacy, and involves the uses of warrants, a method used by the British known as “writs of assistance. Although the Fourth Amendment protects persons’ rights against unreasonable searches and seizures, it also protects their undisclosed right to privacy. The right to privacy is sprinkled…

Words 936 - Pages 4

Case Study: Korematsu V. United States

Kansas, is a United States Supreme Court case that experienced a unanimous decision that ended state segregation. The case brought the beginning of the American civil rights movement. BvBoE had a 9-0 vote to end federal tolerance of segregation and “separate but equal” ways, the case declared that “separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.” BvBoE came back to the Fourteenth Amendment which states that there is equal protection under law to all citizens. The Supreme Court ruled the case…

Words 881 - Pages 4

Pros And Cons Of The 8th Amendment

cruel and unusual punishments inflicted” The 8th amendment is a very important inclusion to the 10 bill of rights. This guaranties the right that you will be punished fairly on the crime you’ve broken. You won’t be hung because you were speeding. The 8th amendment makes it unconstitutional for the jury to give you an unreasonable bail. The bail must meet the crime as well as the fine. These are all stated in the different clauses of the 8th amendment. 2.) This Idea was part of British law for centuries…

Words 1071 - Pages 5

POL330 Midterm#1 Essay

POL330 Exam1 2. Minor v. Happerset [Holding: The Fourteenth Amendment does not guarantee women the right to vote.] [overruled by Amendment 19th, 1920] [summary: Minor v. Happersett, 88 U.S. 1Si (1875), is a United States Supreme Court case in which the Court held that the Constitution did not grant women the right to vote. The Supreme Court upheld state court decisions in Missouri, which had refused to register a woman as a lawful voter because that state's laws allowed only men to vote.…

Words 3008 - Pages 13

Argumentative Essay On Brown Vs. Board Of Education

This statement, written by the United States Supreme Court in the court decision of Brown vs. Board of Education, helped to end the segregation of schools in America. In Brown vs. Board of Education, Linda Brown believed that her 14th amendment right was being violated when she was forced to walk through a dangerous railroad switchyard to get to her bus stop that was segregated from the closer, all white bus stop. In this controversial case, the United States Supreme Court unanimously decided that the…

Words 668 - Pages 3

Government Final Study Guide Essay

10 amendments to the constitution. Ensured certain rights & liberties to the people Civil Liberties- areas of personal freedom with which governments are constrained from interfering Selective incorporation- The process by which certain of the guarantees expressed in the Bill of Rights become applicable to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment Double Jeopardy- the prosecution of a defendant for a criminal offense for which he has already been tried; prohibited in the fifth amendment to the…

Words 866 - Pages 4

Balance Of Power In The United States

are state and local governments that have similar power in making laws and enforcing laws.…

Words 1832 - Pages 8

8th Amendment Against Cruel And Unusual Punishment

Throughout the United States history, the death penalty has continued to serve as the final form of penalty for serious crimes. Since its creation, capital punishment has been ongoing debate with lawmakers, citizens, and leaders alike. Treason, murder, and arson are some examples of serious crimes that could result in death penalty. The United States Supreme Court has decided that the death penalty is not a violation of the Eighth Amendment’s ban on cruel and unusual punishment; however, the Eighth…

Words 551 - Pages 3