The Effect of Compensation in Management Essay

Submitted By mkzero
Words: 3116
Pages: 13
Open Document
The effect of monetary compensation in managers’ behavior

Introduction

Behavioral Economics is the combination of Psychology and Economics that investigates what happen in the markets in which participants display human limitations (Mullainthan, 2000, p. 1) through the assessment of the intrinsic motivation of those people. This perspective can be considered to understand how socialization, networks and identity shape individual behaviour in organizations.

The objective of this paper is to analyze the effects of monetary compensation in the behavior of managers by using the Behavioral Economics’ approach to organizations, and then, to demonstrate that current schemes of compensation sometimes causes “irrational” decisions (from an economic perspective) that sabotage the performance of the firm.
.
This work is divided in three parts: in the first part I explain the nature behind the behavior of managers, by describing the fact that corporations are compounded by individuals (including managers) with different goals and by developing the concept of principal-agency relationship; in the second part, some compensation schemes have been developed as well as their justification; in the third part, I analyze how the economic packages sometimes fail in their intent to drive the behavior of managers towards the performance of the firm; and in the last part, I comment some complementary alternatives to fix problems related to compensation, that are actually ineffective.

1. The nature of managers behind the behavior

2.1. The goals in organizations

When academics talk about the main organization’s goal, the first idea that comes to their heads is “increasing profits”, as if a company was a person with its own motivations. In spite of the legal fiction to attribute to the corporation the characteristics of a single entity, the reality is further complex. Actually, a corporation is composed by a variety of individuals (managers, employees, shareholders) with different interests than that of the organization; moreover, according to Williamson, there are also immediate determinants of individual behaviour within a firm: salary, security, prestige, power, professional excellence, social service, etcetera (Baxter, 1993, p. 160). If we recognize that different sub-goals of a firm (production, sales, inventories, market share, profit) are concerns of different people, the nature of a firm become even more difficult to define.

Even though organizational goals are distinct from the goals of individuals, they are not divorced: conflict of interests is a characteristic of the firms (Baxter, 1993, pp. 156-157). So, when we are dealing with organizations, we must explain organizational behaviour in terms of the goals of the individual in order to fit them in the organizational goals (Baxter, 1993, pp. 158-159).

In this context, companies should consider personal motivation of managers when develop its owns: (i) psychologically , manager don’t see firm as mere apparatus for satisfying their own desires, they go deeper and see the prosperity and success of the firm as an actual proxy for their desires; (ii) from a sociological perspective, managers want not only “narrow” economic gain but also achievement, power and status; (iii) from a economic point of view, managers ask for basic compensation, bonuses, stock options and other ways of compensation (Baxter, 1993, p. 161). Considering these ideas, managers’ primary goal is the maximization of the rate of growth of their firms, subject to the constraint imposed by a security factor (keep their jobs in the same or better conditions).

2.2. Principal-agency theory applied to firms

An agency relationship is defined as an exchange relation between a person (the principal) who delegates in another person (the agent) certain task to be perform in the interest of the first. The reason for the existence of this kind of relationship is due the lack of resources,
Show More

Related Documents: The Effect of Compensation in Management Essay

Labor Unions Pros And Cons

head of the unions who represent the employees before management for the purpose of negotiating benefits, and some benefits can include dental, health insurance, payed vacation, and average salary. Instead of having each individual talk to management and try and negotiate benefits, employees come together and form a union to try and give the employees some power for a safe and fair work environment. If individuals were to try and talk to management and bargain terms of theirs working situation, most…

Words 866 - Pages 4

Agency Conflicts, Managerial Compensation and Firm Variance Essay

Fall 1996 AGENCY CONFLICTS, MANAGERIAL COMPENSATION, AND FIRM VARIANCE Robert L. Lippert* Abstract This paper presents a theoretical model of the agency conflict between managers and shareholders. The problem is examined in an expected-utility-maximization scenario in which the explicit cost of the agency conflict that arises between the manager and shareholders is derived. The model determines the effect of changes in firm variance on various compensation components. Development of this model depends…

Words 5165 - Pages 21

Reporting Practices And Ethics

care staff to make the extra dollar. On the other hand there are health care providers who follow the right proto-call to stay honest with his or her patients and practice. As the health care system enters to the new century, there is a tidal wave effect within the system. Studymode (2013),"With so many changes, such as the older generation are working and living longer the health care system has to change. Reorganizing the health care system over the past 10 years has changed completely the procedure…

Words 749 - Pages 3

The Pros And Cons Of Performance Motivation And Employee Performance

Introduction Compensation is a systematic method that formulated by the employers to offer financial value to employees to exchange for their working performance. Employee’s satisfaction of job, performance of job and the employer’s organizational recruitment are direct affected by the compensation that the organization offered. Compensation is the implement that provided by employers for various objectives to further the development and existence of the organization. Compensation is flexible that…

Words 1664 - Pages 7

What Is Executive Compensation Plan

XXX Ltd. Executive Compensation Plan Prepared by: Remuneration Committee Introduction Executive compensation plan is referred to the contract between a company and its management executives that aims to encourage and motivate the executives for the achievement of the company’s visions and objectives (Hassen, 2014). The existence of executive compensation plan arises from the conflict of interests between principal and agent. Principal who is aka as shareholders do not involve in the…

Words 1081 - Pages 5

Industrial Hygienist Compliance Report

the University of California and mitigation of workers compensation claims. The University of California workers compensations claims were costing the university over 90 million dollars per year. The University’s Chief Risk Officer decided that she needed to move from a mere compliance adherence attitude, to a more prevention type of program. Two initiatives were introduced to help with prevention, and reduce the cost of workers compensation claims against the university. Said cost cutting measures…

Words 954 - Pages 4

Essay about The Harnischfeger Case

ACC 613 Chapter 3: Harnischfeger Case 1. Identify all the accounting policy changes and accounting estimates that Harnischfeger made during 1984. Estimate, as accurately as possible, the effect of these on the company's 1984 reported profits. Harnischfeger made the following accounting policy changes and accounting estimates during the year 1984. • There was a change in the recognition of some types of sales. This resulted in a change in sales calculation. Harnischfeger incorporated…

Words 903 - Pages 4

Linkedin Case Essay

Braddock Industries Inc. Long-Term Incentive Compensation System Evaluation Darren Bahadur Barima Peprah Daniel Niedra Hubery Zhao Historical Plans Plan 1 (1998-2002) Although Braddock was a privately held company during this time, the long-term incentive plan involved a stock-based component (case Exhibit 4) and as well as an annual performance bonus based on the matrix illustrated in case Exhibit 6. The good * Since management compensation is tied to firm performance, managers are…

Words 4069 - Pages 17

Employee Compensation Essay

Employee Compensation Laura Navarro HRM531 January 3, 2013 Antonia Vianna Employee Compensation Introduction As an employee for a medical health billing company, I’m currently a new employee and making sure that I understand all forms of the financial tangible services, returns and employee benefits received. My relationship with EA Health is a good start with my employer and employees. I’ve been able to see our employee composition…

Words 1232 - Pages 5

Essay on Understand The Compensation

Understanding the Compensation of Nonprofit Executive Directors Examining the Influence of Performance and Organizational Characteristics Nathan Grasse,1 Trenton Davis,2 Douglas Ihrke3 1 Central Michigan University, 2Georgia Southern University, 3 University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee In this study we aimed to provide a better understanding of executive compensation in nonprofit organizations. We examined factors including organizational size, market, subsector, organizational type, staffing level…

Words 7699 - Pages 31