The Elements of Criminal Liability Essay

Words: 2392
Pages: 10
Open Document
The Elements of Criminal Liability

ACTUS REUS & MENS REA

"Actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea", or "an act does not make a man guilty unless his mind be also guilty (Burgess, 2004, p.8)." In criminal law, for an individual to commit a crime, there must be present two elements. They are:
• Actus Reus (meaning guilty act – or omission); and
• Mens Rea (meaning guilty mind).

Actus Reus is the guilty act or omission in the commissioning of a crime. In short, it is what the offender does or doesn't do which results in a crime taking place. Mens Rea is the guilty mind behind the crime. It is what tells the offender that what they are doing or not doing is wrong but they do it regardless. An act can be described as an action carried …show more content…
• Provocation: the accused may claim provocation or a loss of self-control. While this is not a full defence to most crimes, provocation is said to affect an individuals' mens rea. With out full mens rea, the severity or seriousness of an offence is reduced. For example, if a person accused of murder claims to have been provoked into committing murder, their charge may be lessened to manslaughter. In 1998, Barbara Denny was found non guilty for the murder of her husband, but guilty of manslaughter. Her not guilty plea was based on provocation related to her husband's behaviour during their marriage. She received a three year suspended sentence (R v. Denny [1998] VLR 938). In Mrs. Denny's case, the prosecution was unable to establish full mens rea and therefore could not have her convicted of murder.

• Battered Woman Syndrome: while generally not a widely accepted defence in most cases, when used it does affect the element of mens rea and therefore whether the accused can be found guilty of the offence. The defence of battered woman syndrome is more often than not used to support the defence of self-defence. When using the two together, it is necessary to prove that force was necessary to protect the offender or others against death or serious bodily harm (Beazer, 2002, p. 103). For example: Annie and Stephen have been married for 30 years and for 30 years, Stephen has beaten, abused and humiliated Annie on a daily basis. One day Annie made
Show More

Related Documents: The Elements of Criminal Liability Essay

Explain the Arguments for and Against Strict Liability Offences Essay

Explain the arguments for and against strict liability offences A strict liability offence is one where it is not necessary for the prosecution to prove any mens rea. In most cases of strict liability even if one did not have the intent to commit a crime, however reasonable, in relation to a particular element of the actus reus of an offence, they can still be convicted. This can be shown in reference to Prince and Hibbert. Prince (1875) the girl was taken by Prince even though he knew she was…

Words 1387 - Pages 6

Assignment: Criminal Law and Reasonable Belief Essay

Assignment: LS160 Criminal Law and Procedure (Assignment 1) VOLUNTARINESS The fundamental principle for the prosecution to prove and convict Logan is to prove that the act was voluntary. Therefore, there is a requirement of proof of a voluntary act causing the forbidden result and a fault element. 1 A voluntary act is a willed act that is only concerned with its performance not its consequences,2 compared to an intentional act comprised performing the act for the purpose of achieving its consequence…

Words 3016 - Pages 13

Cooperate Crime Analysis

contemporary society. Corporate crime has become one of the major concerns, and, therefore, requires each state to respond accordingly and address the problem promptly. Corporate Liability Providing control over corporations, the government has determined corporate liability, regulated by civil and criminal laws. Corporate liability defines the extent of accountability for corporation and its representatives operating within corporation.…

Words 1316 - Pages 6

LAW ESSAY

Criminal defences operate in a variety of ways. Explain the categories in broad terms, before comparing and contrasting the nature and characteristics of two specific defences Introduction In the field of Criminal Law, there are a variety of conditions that will tend to negate elements of a crime, known as defences. In civil proceedings and criminal prosecutions under common law, a defendant may raise a defence in an attempt to avoid criminal or civil liability. There are two kinds of defences;…

Words 846 - Pages 4

Homework: Criminal Law and Structural-functional Analysis Deviance Essay

Stigma- a powerfully negative label that greatly changes a person’s self-concept and social identity. Mens Rea Mens Rea- is the mental part, the state of mind required to be criminally liable. It is often defined as “a guilty mind” or possessing a criminal intent. What exactly is intent? Do any of the following terms define intent in your mind. Mischievous Malicious Unlawful Purposeful Intentional Knowingly Willingly Reckless Negligent Careless Fraudulent With and evil purpose General, Specific…

Words 470 - Pages 2

Business: Law and Common Law Doctrines Essay

1. What two essential elements comprise traditional criminal liability? What are 3 primary differences between civil and criminal court? - 3 primary differences between civil and criminal court are PURPOSE, WHO CAN FILE, AND BURDEN OF PROOF. - Two essential elements that comprise traditional criminal liability are committing a bad act and intent to do a bad act. Certain acts don’t require intent, such as manslaughter and criminal negligence. 2. List 6 categories of crime and give examples…

Words 796 - Pages 4

Legal Studies Essay

by a recognised criminal sanction upon proof of guilt in a criminal proceeding initiated and presented by officers of the crown or its agencies. A crime can be defined as any act or omission of duty that results in harm to society as a whole and which is punishable by the state. For the reason that a crime is against society as a whole, crimes are prosecuted by the state, i.e. it is not the role of the victim to prosecute the person(s) committing the crime. Accordingly, criminal cases in Australia…

Words 6128 - Pages 25

The Elements Of Criminal Law Essay

THE ELEMENTS OF CRIMINAL LAW By: Rachel Di Lena The Criminal Code The Criminal Code:  Is a federal statute that contains the majority of the criminal laws passed by Parliament.  It lists offences and sentences that are being imposed as well as the procedures to follow when trying those accused of crimes.  The code is meant to reflect the social values of the majority of Canadians. Summary Conviction Offences Summary Conviction Offence: A crime that is considered less serious and carries a…

Words 1038 - Pages 5

What Are The Major Types Of Crime

year. 8. Corporate Criminal Liability a corppration is a legal entity created under the laws of the state. It can enter into contracts, purchase land etc. Corporations CAN commit crimes and suffer penalties of such as denial of certain legal privilegs( such as licenses) and they can be fined. Hard to put a company in prision 9. crime a wrong against society that is labeled as such by those in authority, is prohibited by law, and is punishable by the government 10. Criminal Act Most crimes an…

Words 2068 - Pages 9

Governance: Tort and Self Regulation Essay

REGULATION OF BUSINESS Week 6 Recap  • • • Control and monitoring of business activities: Governance Concept of governance meaning, elements and what amounts to good governance Corporate governance – internal organisation and management of a company – – – – • Key aspects of accountability, transparency Main theories – principle/agent approach Stakeholder theory Corporate governance in UK Cadbury 1992 to UK Combined Code 2010 Key factor – primarily internal control…

Words 729 - Pages 3