The Giver A Dystopian Society

Words: 1113
Pages: 5
Open Document
Is it possible to achieve true happiness without experiencing deep despair? The Giver, by Lois Lowry, presents a society that in some respects is a utopia, but also contains elements that make it a dystopia. Ultimately, the book addresses the larger question whether one really can exist without the other. The Giver describes a society with strict rules that are deemed necessary to maintain a utopian culture. Jonas, the main character, is selected by the Chief Elder at the Ceremony of Twelves to inherit the position as the next Receiver of Memory. That job entails him meeting with The Giver every day until The Giver has transferred all of humanity’s memories. This experience makes Jonas both value and doubt the structure of his society. In …show more content…
In Jonas’s reality, everyone possesses the same skin color. The Giver reveals, “‘there was a time - you’ll see this in the memories later - when flesh was many different colors. That was before we went to Sameness. Today, flesh is all the same…’” (94). In our society, the fact that people have different skin colors leads to racism. Some people feel that they are superior to others based solely on the color of their skin. This is avoided in The Giver because everyone possesses the same color skin. The people also retain emotional Sameness because they have similar opinions and depth of emotion. They avoid an immense amount of strife in a society caused by differences of opinions. Everyone in Jonas’s world bears similar emotional responses, and they do not feel deep sadness or deep happiness. One of the numerous benefits of not being able to experience deep emotions is that it spares people from feeling sorrow or pain. One gives up joy and pride to avoid utter darkness and despair. But the serenity that comes from Sameness makes it a …show more content…
They cannot experience love because they think that it is a danger to their predictable lifestyle. Even Jonas admits, “‘I liked the feeling of love… I do understand that it wouldn’t work very well. And that it’s much better to be organized the way we are now. I can see that it was a dangerous way to live’” (126). They have no memories of love, Birthmothers are unable to have a loving relationship with their children, and romantic love is not allowed. They even give the citizens medication to prevent them from developing romantic feelings. The inability to love may take away emotional risk of disappointment or heartbreak, yet it restricts them from feeling depth of emotions. Although the people of the society in The Giver are content, they never experience joy. Joy is such an intoxicating emotion that when Jonas experiences it, he is willing to sacrifice his life for a chance to live in a world with love. Any society in which the people cannot experience deep love is a
Show More

Related Documents: The Giver A Dystopian Society

The Giver: A Dystopian Society

In the book The Giver, Jonas states that the game of war is a cruel game and kids should not be playing it. The child he told (Asher) apologised as the rules have told him to do. This novel is about a dystopian society where everyone is unknowing of things like snow, love, color, and music. They may think they are happy but they haven't ever been truly happy or sad like the mother mentions. These people have nothing to live for beside their assignment which they may or may not like. If you don't…

Words 531 - Pages 3

Dystopian Society In The Giver

that your perfect society can be destined to fail? In The Giver, a boy named Jonas lives in a society of Sameness, but he and another man named the Giver, has the knowledge of the past and how it was before Sameness. They decided that their job is done once they change the community as well as show everyone the past and that there is more to life, such as emotions and qualities like color. In order to change the community, the society won’t stay a utopian. The book called The Giver by Lois Lowry is…

Words 489 - Pages 2

The Giver Dystopian Society Essay

The Giver Dystopian Society Essay Ever since Lois Lowry’s award winning children’s book, The Giver, there have been several different claims over it being a dystopian or utopian novel. In order to make a conclusion, the definition of the words “dystopian” and “utopian” need to be comprehended. A civilization without war, famine, illness, or hatred or any other society flaws, is considered a utopia. The members of this social order are nice and are in a state of perpetual bliss…

Words 675 - Pages 3

Mrs Hutchinson A Dystopian Society In The Giver

In the book The Giver is based upon an utopian/dystopian setting where a young boy named jonas learns that the utopian that he once lived in is actually a dystopian society and when he uses his beliefs towards this society to change others, The leaders of his community find out and want to “release him from the community”. In The Hutchinson Trial, Mrs.Hutchinson tries to share her own religious beliefs within her community but ended up getting banished from her colony. Before the trial in 1638, Anne…

Words 794 - Pages 4

Dystopian Society Essay

it happened after i pasted it into Yahoo. The Giver Essay Reading/Literacy Ever since the inception of Lois Lowry’s award winning children’s book, The Giver, there has been several controversial claims over it being a Dystopian or Utopian novel. In order to formulate a conclusion, the definition of the words “Dystopian” and “Utopian” need to be comprehended. A civilization without war, famine, illness, or hatred or any other society flaws, is considered a Utopia. The members of…

Words 765 - Pages 4

Dystopian Film Analysis

stories and novels that all seem to have a common theme of “sameness” throughout a society. This concept is something that is portrayed often in dystopian literature. It involves a future society in which technology is used by the “government,” or the people in charge, to improve the everyday lives of human beings by making them equal. The Giver, a dystopian film based off of the novel by Lois Lowry, illustrates a society in which their “government” provides a sense of utopia by eliminating memories…

Words 569 - Pages 3

The Giver Research Paper

The Giver is a classic dystopian novel that fits in the category because of many distinct characteristics. Some of which include fear of the outside world, constant surveillance, nature being distrusted or banished, sameness is idolised and any sense of individuality is diminished. These all contribute to a sense of a utopia, or a perfect society, usually in the beginning of most dystopian novels. Although the setting of the story may seem like a perfect world at first, later the reader may realise…

Words 587 - Pages 3

Comparison Between 'The Giver And Anthem'

Dystopian Books There are many reasons why teens like dystopian novella. In these stories there are rebellious people who don’t obey the law. Teenagers relate to these books because they don’t want to follow strict rules teenagers do what they want to do. One last reason why they realate is because they don’t want to be around all the adults. So teens can relate to Anthem because the system is broken. The Giver and Anthem are relate to the teenagers in many ways but not in all ways. In the book…

Words 530 - Pages 3

Impact Of Dystopian Literature

Dystopian Literature Impact “The future ain’t what it used to be”(Yogi Berra). Back in the 1960’s the future is full of promise and excitement. Looking at The Jetsons, flying cars, robot maids, and happy, healthy living is far and wide. The outcome of the far future is positive, and people are eager to live in the time to come. In contrast, the present has a grim outlook of what the future has in store. Unlike The Jetsons, the future is perceived as scary and almost inevitable. Dystopian literature…

Words 969 - Pages 4

Ayn Rand's 'Anthem': Teenagers In Dystopian Worlds

Teenagers in Dystopian Worlds Dystopian World’s are very interesting to many teenagers now and days. In some ways, the dystopian stories intrigue us because sometimes teens can relate to the stories. The background on Anthem is there was a guy who was done being the same person with everyone else. As for The Giver, it is about a boy who wanted to bring back the emotions to everyone. Dystopian stories and film are very intriguing to teens today. The novel Anthem shows that people aren't their person…

Words 757 - Pages 4