The Grand Inquisitor

Words: 684

Pages: 3

Open Document

The Grand Inquisitor
Fyodor Dostoyevsky's The Grand Inquisitor shows many examples of evil throughout the story. These include Gnosticism, political orders built on violence, and the issue of free will. All of these occur during the Spanish Inquisition, a time where religious intolerance ran rampant, and people were abusing power left and right, especially within the church. This story shows that a good organization can be corrupted by evil, as well as power. It also paints a great metaphor for the hypocrisy of some religious people, as it shows Jesus Christ himself in the hands of the in- quisition.
Gnosticism is the evil of arrogance and self-satisfaction regarding someone's social stand- ing and knowledge. The Grand Inquisitor character himself displays this on a personal level. As a Cardinal of the Church, the Grand Inquisitor thinks of himself as all powerful and knowledgable, as he has the power to condemn people to be burned at the stake. He shows his arrogance by ar- resting the Lord and Savior of his religion for committing miracles. He tells Christ, who he has imprisoned in a jail cell, that his work cannot be done because it undermines the Church. Is this how Christ would be expected to be treated by a Cardinal, and ordained member of his church …show more content…
The inquisition used terror tactics like intimidation and burning people at the stake in order to get their goal across. In the story it says "for the greater glory of God, stakes were flaming all over the country." Even when Jesus returns, there are bones of heretics crackling in the flames. It is clear that when there is such a group or event like the Inquisition which puts fear into people and uses violence, that the moral character of that community is reduced. People are more willing to turn on each other and turn away from God. That is seen with the Cardinal, who rejects Christ for the Devil because of his loyalty to the

The Grand Inquisitor Essay

In Ivan Kamarazov’s poem “The Grand Inquisitor,” the titular character arrests Christ during his Second Coming and argues, almost in a religious ecstasy, against his teachings. You should have, the Inquisitor tells Christ while they encounter each other in a cell, taken the temptations offered by the Devil. In performing miracles, Christ would have definitively proven the truth of Christianity, and would have established a unified Christian world. Christ’s failure to do so has doomed humanity to…

Words 1900 - Pages 8

The Grand Inquisitor Analysis

In this lesson’s story, The Grand Inquisitor imprisons Jesus to prevent him from accomplishing his work on the town’s people as well as to avoid conflict with the work of the Church. While discussing this disagreement, the Grand Inquisitor mentions the time when Satan had given Jesus three temptations, that of which he rejected. These three temptations that Christ was presented with were bread, a miracle, and power. Firstly, with bread, Satan told Jesus that if he were the son of God that he shall…

Words 565 - Pages 3

Essay about The Grand Inquisitor Dostoyevesky

The Grand Inquisitor JACKIE BARRIERE stc The Grand Inquisitor The Grand Inquisitor is a chapter in Dostoyevsky’s classic novel “The Brothers Karamazov.” The Greater novel itself is a philosophical debate on God, free will, human nature and morality written by Dostoevsky over 2 years and published in 1880. As with all of Dostoyevsky’s novels it is set in a modernizing Russia and it is a deep psychological study of faith and reason as well as the doubt, psychology, moral decisions and thought…

Words 542 - Pages 3

Freedom And Happiness

er people because of existential circumstances in their lives such as mental illnesses or unhealthy upbringing. Therefore, I was shocked during the reading of Dostoevsky’s “The Grand Inquisitor,” that serious consideration was given to characters who doubted the capacity of goodness in most people. Despite the Grand Inquisitor’s love for humanity, he does not consider them able to handle the burden of freedom. In my mind, the expression “knowledge is power” always rang true. The further people…

Words 656 - Pages 3

The Inquisitor's Analysis

The Inquisitor twists the meaning of Christ's three temptations in the wilderness. Speaking as if he (the Inquisitor) was Satan incarnate, using misled logic with a hint of the truth to turn Jesus’s faith and trust in God around. He did this to prove to people that Jesus did not do what we believed he came to do and was actually following Satan. How the story is told in Mathew 4: 1-11 in the bible that so many believe to be true is strongly misinterpreted by the Inquisitor in order to manipulate…

Words 274 - Pages 2

Austin Heath english 2 Essay

towards religion, the government, and humanity. Much corruption was shown through religion. There were few good examples as to how corruption was shown through religion, such as, the time the Grand Inquisitor wanted to buy Cunegonde from Don Issachar. Don refused and was threatened by the Grand Inquisitor with auto-de-fe (Voltaire 42). Girls back then were treated with no respect. It’s a good thing they now have the same rights then men do. The church in certainly not a place where corruption…

Words 496 - Pages 2

History: The Inquisitors And The Spanish Inquisition

This, also, is an exaggerated view. Ciappara states that “In most instances the inquisitors’ duty was simply to gather information for the holy congregation to decide…they were to take no decisions on their own, but only after they had informed the cardinals of the case and waiter for their directives” (451). Ciappara also stated that most of the times inquisitors were condemned by cardinals for being too harsh with them, and historians like Christopher Black are quick…

Words 1093 - Pages 5

Voltaire's Candide: The Age Of Reason

remain celibate around Cunégonde, the romantic interest of the eponymous hero, Candide. As Cunégonde says, “[...] the Grand Inquisitor noticed me one day at Mass, he ogled me throughout the service, and then sent word that he had to speak with me on private business [...] a proposition was made on his behalf [...] the Jew would have Mondays, Wednesdays, and the Sabbath, the Inquisitor would have the other days of the week [...]” (Voltaire 20). This is one of several ways religious officials are shown…

Words 859 - Pages 4

Dostoevsky's Rebellion

Believing that life is ultimately not worth living is the root and complete and utter lack of happiness, realizing that nothing you do, even the things that could bring you joy mean anything beyond what they immediately are is a difficult life to lead. The only way to enjoy happiness is to live under some sort of illusion, one being a leap of faith and the other, absurdity, where lack of meaning does not necessarily mean lack of reason to live “A man defines himself by his make-believe as well…

Words 1624 - Pages 7

Book Candide Essay

a beaten during a Spanish Inquisition ceremony. After this, an old woman reunites Candide with Cunégonde, who survived the Bulgarian raid, the rape, and partial disembowelment. Cunégonde has now become involved with both Don Issachar and the Grand Inquisitor of Lisbon. After hearing this, Candide murders both of them, then runs away to Cadiz with Cunégonde and the old woman. When he gets there he volunteers to fight the Jesuits in Paraguay. Then they sail to Buenos Aires, however, shortly after they…

Words 613 - Pages 3