The hazards of drug testing on welfare Essay

Submitted By KatieBreitzke
Words: 736
Pages: 3
Open Document
24 April 2013
The Hazards of Drug Testing for Welfare The establishment of welfare has proven to make a positive influence on thousands of Americans’ lives. The argument that is now surfacing is whether drug testing should or should not be required for welfare recipients. There is cause for pause because both sides to this argument have good view points. Today, each state is given a check by the federal government and is then in charge of distributing the money to each welfare recipient. This is why each state must decide for itself whether or not drug testing will be mandatory; however if each state requires drug testing, it is profiling families based upon their income and seems to be a violation of the fourth amendment. Not to mention the fact that the cost far outweighs the benefit. Studies also show that there are other ways to prevent drug use, rather than disabling families that are down on their luck and in need of some assistance. The first fact that we will discuss is that the cost to each state far outweighs the benefits. Florida has regretted setting up drug testing because of their tremendous out of pocket expenses. The state paid thirty dollars per test, and ended up costing the government over forty-five thousand dollars over what they saved (When Collecting Welfare)! Many other, larger states will pay much more for their drug testing, as well. The next reason that we will look at is the fact that drug testing welfare recipients violates their constitutional rights. According to the fourth amendment, “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searches, and the persons or things to be seized (Lewis, Kenefick).” Rendering this true, if a state requires drug testing to receive welfare, they must have probable cause. This begs the question: Does being destitute make you a drug user? Common sense says no. States that necessitate drug screening profile welfare recipients. To assume that because a person is poor and therefore a drug user uses the same logic as saying that because someone is a minority that they are probably a criminal. In that case it is racial profiling…Is financial profiling any different? Absolutely not! It is not the welfare system’s job to police their recipients. The last point is that there are other ways to discourage drug use, other than crippling families that are just down on their luck and in need of some assistance. This will harm the children of these families more than the parents, even if they are drug users. In impoverished areas, there are clinics that are set up to help drug users face their issues. Many clinics encourage users to go through a six step program. It has helped many addicts overcome their dependency. First, you must admit that one can
Show More

Related Documents: The hazards of drug testing on welfare Essay

Animal Experimentation Essay

combination of grief and anger. What can be said about dog owners can also be said about other kinds of animals’ owners, who are more numerous still. But recently, animals have been used in medical experimentation, research and testing. The use of animals in research, testing, and education is perhaps the most controversial of all animal rights issues. After all, what will the people think when posed with the question, “Whose life is more important? A kid’s or a dog’s? The problem, of course, is with…

Words 3145 - Pages 13

Poverty and Social Work Essay

contributing to the decline in social work credibility Last week we began discussion on poverty and welfare programs Epstein cannot figure out where the 854 billion dollars is going Net deficit in stimulus in 2008 State and local govt cant run deficits Area most germane to us is poverty/ welfare American stratification is being discussed when welfare is discussed Values paramount to justifying welfare is institutionalized in our agencies Very few influence fiscal policy: expression of mass values…

Words 1065 - Pages 5

Persuasive Speech On Animal Testing

boycott animal testing. Everyday 11 or more innocent animals are being tested on and killed. That is 4,015 animals being abused and tested on every year. I have 3 animals at home that I love and I use beauty products everyday and night so it is important to me to use cruelty free products. Vegan products are also usually cruelty free and are a very safe alternative to cruelty…

Words 1299 - Pages 6

Healthy People 2020: Environmental Analysis

homes with hazards, reduce blood lead level in children, reduce air toxic emissions, and increase alternate modes of transportation (Healthy People, 2015). These goals are attainable with the help of evidence-based…

Words 1037 - Pages 5

Essay on Workplace Drug Testing A Boon or Bust

Workplace Drug Testing: A Boon or a Bane? Legal, Ethical, and HR and Concerns Workplace Drug Testing: A Boon or a Bane? Legal, Ethical, and HR and Concerns Both pre-employment and incumbent work place drug testing is a polarizing and controversial subject, a subject which elicits equally vehement sentiments, and lucid, persuasive, and cogent arguments from both those who are fully in favor of the practice and from those who are adamantly opposed to it. The Viet Nam War saw unprecedented use…

Words 4619 - Pages 19

Senior Paper

What wasn’t considered socially acceptable in makeup trends could be acceptable now. What might have been tested on an animal could or could not be tested on them now. Makeup will always be controversial, whether it is the societal impact, animal testing, or what goes in and out of makeup. There is only one way to changing these things, and it starts with changing ourselves. In the 19th century, “Beauty was supposed to be a manifestation of goodness, not artifice” (“People & Events: America's Beauty…

Words 1708 - Pages 7

Employment LAW FINAL Essay

class of individuals The National Labor Relations Act (NLRA): Law enacted by congress in 1935, designed to protect employee and employer rights, encourage collective bargaining and prevent certain management policies that can cause problems for the welfare of businesses, workers, and the US economy. The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (FLSA): Federal legislation that protects workers from unfair labor practices such as unequal pay, excessive work hours, lack of overtime compensation, and unsafe working…

Words 2780 - Pages 12

Animal Abuse Research Paper

looks at or pays attention to. This is due to people not being informed of the kind of abuse that pets, farm animals and wildlife animals go through. Some significant contributors to animal abuse around the world of dog racing and fighting, animal testing, and slaughterhouses. Animal Abuse connected to Dog Fighting and Racing For centuries, humans have deliberately…

Words 989 - Pages 4

Army Safety Essay

Appendix A References Section I Required Publications AR 385–10 The Army Safety Program AR 385–40 Accident Reporting and Records DA PAM 385–10 The Army Safety Program DA PAM 385–40 Army Accident Investigation and DA PAM 385–64 Ammunition and Explosives Safety Standards DA PAM 385–90 Army Aviation Accident Prevention Program FM 5–19 Composite Risk Management Section II Related Publications A related publication is a source of additional information. The user…

Words 3648 - Pages 15

Business and administration Essay

Section 1 Know the employment rights and responsibilities of the employee and employer 1. Identify four main points that would be included in a contract of employment. If possible, use an example contract to support your answer (feel free to obscure any confidential information). • Names of the Parties – The employers name/organisation name and the employers name • Employment Contract Start Date • Employee's Job Title and Description • Place of work 2. a) List three key points…

Words 2770 - Pages 12