The Importance Of Background Checks To Higher Education

Submitted By nelliebell26
Words: 7752
Pages: 32
Open Document
CLOSING THE DOORS TO HIGHER EDUCATION: ANOTHER COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCE OF A CRIMINAL CONVICTION

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In recent years, colleges and universities in the United States have increasingly included criminal history background checks in their admissions processes and have started to create exclusionary policies. These polices are being implemented despite the fact that there is virtually no evidence to suggest that the past criminal histories of students are relevant risk factors that affect the rate of crime on college campuses. Although these policies will not make campuses any safer, such policies do carry with them some very significant and dangerous consequences. In their haste to make campuses safer, college admissions officers are adopting policies that threaten to make the community at large less safe and more racially divided. This working paper discusses various aspects of the growing practice of the use of criminal history background checks in the college admission practice. We first consider the data on crime on campus which shows that colleges remain remarkably safe places particularly when compared to the larger community. We review the available, albeit limited data that suggests that crime on campus is more likely to be committed by students without criminal records than students with prior records. The paper reports the results of surveys conducted by the Center for Community Alternatives and the National HIRE Network that show the lack of standards within states, including state university systems, and across states as to whether or not to screen for a criminal history, and how use information gathered through background checks is used. Finally, we raise concerns that because racial disparities figure prominently in our criminal justice system, the practice of excluding college applicants who have criminal histories will inevitably impact prospective students of color more than their white counterparts. Thus, the use of criminal records to screen out prospective students is not race neutral, but rather encroaches on the civil and human rights of people with criminal records. As education is clearly associated with lower recidivism rates, impeding people’s ability to get a college education undermines public safety in the larger society. We conclude the discussion by pointing to several successful model programs that offer examples about ways to help people with records access higher education as well as recommendations for parsimonious use of criminal records in determining admission decisions. There is growing support for returning higher education to correctional facilities. It is ironic then, that as higher educational opportunity doors are reopening in prisons, they are closing in the community. Because of the tragic racial disparities in the U.S. criminal justice system, policies and practices that exclude people with criminal records from institutions of higher learning will set back the gains of the civil rights struggles to open higher education to all people, regardless of race or ethnicity. i

1

CLOSING THE DOORS TO HIGHER EDUCATION: ANOTHER COLLATERAL CONSEQUENCE OF A CRIMINAL CONVICTION1 Introduction In recent years, colleges and universities in the United States have increasingly included criminal history background checks in their admissions processes and have started to create exclusionary policies based on these background checks. Although colleges have a duty to consider a range of factors that would affect the safety of their campus communities - the students, faculty and employees - a cavalier use of criminal records may generate a false sense of security. As discussed in this paper, there is virtually no evidence to suggest that past criminal histories of students are related to crime on college campuses, and thus policies to exclude such students will not make campuses any safer. The unfettered use of criminal records to screen out prospective students will have
Show More

Related Documents: The Importance Of Background Checks To Higher Education

Summary Of David Cash And The Bad Samaritan

the role of the justice system from the courthouse and punish a student with a criminal record? Dawn MacKeen suggested colleges should not disqualify students based on their criminal history or moral history with an example of David Cash, “The Bad Samaritan” in her article, Creeps on Campus. I completely agree with her opinion on this matter. College shouldn't take away the right of the Higher Education because education is not only the solution for those who have troubled history but it is also one…

Words 976 - Pages 4

Is The American Dream A Myth Summary

challenging for immigrants, it is far from impossible. It's all about getting an education and developing good relationships with key people in your field. Also knowing people who are willing to share their knowledge, and having the ability to put that to use. Another key element is keeping a clean record. Achieving the American dream can be nearly impossible as an immigrant. Especially with a lack of a good education. Tracy Elizabeth, the writer of “Is the American Dream a Myth?” states in her…

Words 835 - Pages 4

Record Sealing Law

Reasons To Invest In A Record Sealing Lawyer. In today's fast-paced world, where information is readily accessible with just a few clicks, the consequences of past mistakes can linger long after they've been made. Criminal records, no matter how minor the offense, have the potential to cast a shadow over one's life, hindering opportunities for employment, housing, and more. Fortunately, legal redemption is within reach for those seeking a fresh start. With the assistance of a record-sealing lawyer, individuals…

Words 672 - Pages 3

Poverty Essay

citizens living in prison as of today. According to Rick Mathews, in the article Falling Education Rates Leading to Higher Prison Populations, one of every 150 Americans is cut off from society as an inmate, which amounts to about 2 million people at an approximate annual cost of $55 billion. So many children growing up in the United States have no care for education or are not brought up being taught that education is one of the most important areas to excel in life. These children are more susceptible…

Words 1441 - Pages 6

Paper Assignment

Assaults 1 or More Under 18 50% 50% 18 to 20 63% 37% 21+ 48% 52% 18 to 20 year olds are less likely to commit assaults Table 2: Sociology 2M Paper Assignment, Victim of Theft by Education Self-control Education Never Victim of Theft 1 or more thefts High School Graduate 27% 73% College+ 48% 52% The more Education, the less likely you will be a victim of theft Table 3: Sociology 2M Paper Assignment, Ethnicity and Assault Social Bond Ethnicity Never Assaulted anyone 1 or more Assaults Anglos…

Words 2716 - Pages 11

Pass The Dream Act Essay

to live in the shadows and with the constant fear of being deported but it does not have to be this way. Passing the Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act (Dream Act) will give a chance to the community of minors that is essentially already American to become legal Americans. Through their academic accomplishments and no criminal records, have confirmed themselves able to be true trustworthy, active, intellectual, and beneficial American citizen. Congress should pass the Dream act…

Words 873 - Pages 4

Essay about Literature Review Article For Assignment 1

trust and had difficulty developing healthy relationships outside of his close circle of friends. Hunting also had a criminal record to include charges of grand theft auto, assault, impersonating an officer and resisting arrest. This article discusses the common correlation of adolescents in foster care and juvenile delinquency. These children often experience low levels of education attainment and employment (Jacobs, 2012). Like Hunting, these children leave foster care or the juvenile justice…

Words 3902 - Pages 16

DACA Pros And Cons

rescinded until another solution is developed. DACA provides work permits and an education to illegal immigrants who may not have these opportunities otherwise. In order to be accepted into the program, candidates have to fit a number of requirements, including the following: they had to be thirty or younger when the program was launched, brought to the U.S. before the age of sixteen, and not have a criminal record. Rescinding DACA takes away the chance of a better life for many immigrants, and while…

Words 554 - Pages 3

The DREAM Act

Development, Relief, and Education for Alien Minors Act, also known as the DREAM Act (s.1291), was first introduced in 2001 by Dick Durbin and Orrin Hatch. It meant to create a process that would allow immigrants to apply for conditional residency, which would then lead to permanent residency. This proposition would grant citizenship to young individuals, under the age of sixteen, that have gone through the American education system in good standing, with no criminal record. The DREAM Act failed to…

Words 620 - Pages 3

Ban The Box Campaign Analysis

Obama has issued an executive order that federal jobs will now delay criminal background questioning until further in the application process in order to give ex-convicts a better chance at employment. Within a year of release as many as 60 percent of ex-convicts are unemployed and one in three adults will have been arrested by the age of 23. With these staggering statistics criminal background checks and the questioning of criminal background shouldn’t be placed on initial job application and if there…

Words 1928 - Pages 8