the Irish Famine Essay

Submitted By steven0567
Words: 656
Pages: 3
Open Document
History: 20 mark question

Both sources L and M are written by British representatives and both suggest that the British have done what they can or should do to aid the Irish during the famine. Source L is a journalistic report written by the Times newspaper editorial in 1846. The source begins by saying that the Irish people believe that the famine is worse than it is and that they are exaggerating the severity of the situation. The second point made in the source states that the government provided work for the Irish people, regardless of their widespread hatred of Britain, and this in turn fulfilled their duties to Ireland by warding off starvation. The extract goes on to say that any further negative events were sent by god and that it was a test of their indolence. Source L makes another point when it says that the Irish character must be modified and corrected for the conditions in Ireland to get any better. The final point made in the source is that the British view the famine a blessing as it meant that the Irish people must change their main dietary staple from potatoes to meat and that the meat will give them the hunger and lust to work and gain money to buy more meat.
Source L was written during the time of the famine so is therefore a primary source and details, although possibly left out due to the biased nature of the British tabloid paper and the discrimination against the Irish people, were not simply forgotten over time. Source M is an extract from a letter written by Cork magistrate Nicholas Cummins after a visit to Skibbereen, county cork in 1846. The source immediately states the awareness of the scenes of frightful hunger and that the magistrate took with him as much bread as five men could carry to aid the Irish people affected by the famine. Cummins then goes on to say that the scenes he saw were so horrific that they cannot be described in speech or writing and could only be seen to understand the magnitude of the blight. The source continues by detailing the scenes of skeletal people, so thin and sickly that they appeared, at first glance, to be dead.
Source M was also written during the time of the famine and details were therefore not lost or forgotten over time. The source has been extracted from a letter that was written to be informative and unbiased. The letter was
Show More

Related Documents: the Irish Famine Essay

Irish Famine Essay

30 March 2011 The Irish Famine In 1845 the ruined potatoes in Ireland cause death by starvation and disease of over 2 million people and the massive immigration of another 2 million people to the United States and Britain. (Black Potatoes: the Story of the Great Irish Famine). This horrific tragedy marked the start of a revolution because of the effortless attempts from Britain to save the starving people of Ireland. Britain was too concerned with the “unhealthy reliance” that might build between…

Words 646 - Pages 3

The Irish Potato Famine

In the late 1800’s the Irish left Ireland when the potato famine hit Ireland. The potato famine was caused by the potato blight, which made the potatoes rot in the ground. At the time the English were exporting wheat from Ireland, which contributed to the famine. The Irish ate a lot of potatoes and due to the fact that most if not half of the population was Catholic, and only a few generations before the famine, A lot of them at the time were tenant farmers, which means that they had to pay rent…

Words 541 - Pages 3

Irish Potato Famine In America

nothing can harm you.” Irish Blessing. When the Irish’s potatoes began dying in 1845, over a million men, women and children died and thousands were caused to flee the country, many immigrants fled to America. The fortunate people, that were able to pay for safe passage to America on well built and well supplied ships, got to America safely. Some were not so fortunate… Those who survived the journey over, arrived to disappointment and a new life of poverty. In September of 1845, Irish potato crops all…

Words 898 - Pages 4

Irish Potato Famine Research Paper

The Irish Potato Famine began in 1845, lasted for more than six years and; took its toll on the daily lives of millions of people, resulted in the loss of millions of lives, and caused another million people to leave the country for their own well being and the hope of finding a better life. Ireland was very agricultural in the mid 1800s, and 8 million of the poorest people in the Western World lived there. Only about a fourth of the people in Ireland could read or write. The life expectancy was…

Words 3019 - Pages 13

Irish Potato Famine Essay

Alan Hsieh Mr. Gardner Modern Global Conflict 11/01/2013 Poison Gases during WW1 Poison gases are one of the most fearful weapons through out the whole entire World War I. Even though killing rate of machine gun during World War I was compared more than the killing rate of Poison Gases. Poison Gases is more as a slow term affect during the war, since when enemies are not in battle the opponent can still use poison gases to contaminate the living environment that their enemies lived in. And…

Words 422 - Pages 2

Irish Potato Famine Research Paper

was on the brink of disaster due to The Great Potato Famine, also known as the great hunger. The Irish Potato Famine was the worst to occur in Europe in the 19th century from 1845–1849 when the potato crop failed in successive years (Mokyr). One million people died of starvation or the diseases associated with the famine and one million emigrated to North America or parts of England, such as Liverpool, and Scotland, such as Glasgow. The famine was caused by a mysterious disease, the potato blight…

Words 946 - Pages 4

Great Potato Famine Research Paper

Beginning in 1845 and lasting for six years, the Great Irish Potato Famine swept through Ireland causing mass starvation, disease, and emigration. The Great Potato Famine affected not only Irish living in Ireland during this time period, but continues to affect Irish descendants all over the world today. Ireland in the mid 1800s identified herself as an agricultural nation. Eight million people populated Ireland during the Great Potato Famine and these were amongst the poorest people in the Western…

Words 3268 - Pages 14

Irish To Us Essay

Irish to the US AP Human Geography Miyah Davis & Claire Leon Who was involved/who had to migrate - Irish immigrants - famine struck the potato fields in 1840’s - suspicious American Protestants - Anti-Catholic mobs attacked Catholic schools and conveys - were shunned and denied work http://www.eyewitnesstohistory.com/irishfamine.htm Voluntary Migration or Forced Migration? Irish immigration to the United States was considered voluntary and forced. Due to the potato famine Irish people moved the…

Words 485 - Pages 2

Potato Famine Essay

The Ireland Potato famine In 1845, the Irish people depended mostly on potatoes and farming. Inspite of the fact that, the Land used to grow crops was not owned by a certain person. In Ireland during 1845, a plant fungus attacked their potato crops. This fungus was called Phytophthora infestans. The fungus covered the potato crop in black rot. This disaster lasted about 5 years and had a horrible effect on the irish people…

Words 898 - Pages 4

Irish Discrimination In The 19th Century

If the Irish were so lucky, why were they so discriminated? Obviously, they weren’t the shamrock-loving gingers we know when they’re being attacked. They had to leave Ireland to survive due to the potato famine, the Nativists didn’t have to make it any harder for them! Let me take you on a stroll through a story of retaliation, loss, and nativism with the Irish-American immigrants… It’s unfortunate that the Irish were hurt so badly, and the Nativists were unarguably to blame. The Nativists thought…

Words 695 - Pages 3