Is War Ever Justified

Submitted By MarshalThompson1
Words: 822
Pages: 4
Open Document
War is defined as being in a state of hostility or rivalry that usually consists of physical force between opposing parties. With this in mind, we must answer the ethical question of whether or not war can ever be morally justified. Surely there are times in which conflict between states and peoples arise out of necessity, but there are also points in which conflicts arise out of needless ambitions, and it's in these instances that war is never justified. The principles of act utilitarianism can be applied in creating a rational, justifiable cause for war. War is sometimes necessary, this is one of the most heralding facets of human existence that we must come to terms with. Not all wars, however, have been fought out of necessity and remain a tragedy of human history. Hindsight has shown us that certain wars have determined the greatest amount of utility for the greatest amount of people. Act utilitarianism implies that we make a binary choice to go to war to protect the lives of the entire nation, or pacify ourselves against aggressive forces, it is essential to go to war.

When dealing with the ethical question of war, we can use some evidence throughout history that has shown us that certain wars have been waged for the greater good of humanity. Most of these wars were fought either to stop international aggression, or fiercely fought battles of defense against foreign invaders:

• WW2 was a necessary war in which arms had to be taken against the Axis powers who had serious ambitions of enslaving the Slavic states of Eastern Europe and spreading Aryan/Japanese supremacy throughout the world.
• When the Union Army marched into the Confederacy in order to restore the Union could be seen as justifiable because it meant the preservation of the country as well as the abolition of slavery.
• After North Korea was split from South Korea, it was a necessity for North Korea to attempt the reunification of the two Koreas to achieve economic and social success for its people.
• The war that has been waged against Israel by Palestine since Israel's inception has been a justified attempt at reclaiming the homeland for the displaced peoples.
• The Peloponnesian War was waged against the growing Athenian Empire by a collection of Greek city-states (including Athens) in order to thwart growing animosities and aggressions by the Athenians.

These models represent instances where the greatest good and utility was spread amongst the greatest amount of people, because war had been waged. War, like other forms of violence, should only come as a means of defending national sovereignty and/or deterring international aggression such as the Germans in World War II.

Act utilitarianism tells us that we must utilize war only in instances when other resources have been exhausted and there is no other clear choice that will serve the welfare of the entire populace. Often times, war ends up destroying large numbers of people on both sides; however, hindsight has told us that if certain aggressors were not stopped then they surely would have destroyed far more than the cumulative casualties and expenses of war.

Act utilitarianism does not justify wars fought for economic (imperialistic), cultural,
Show More

Related Documents: Is War Ever Justified

How Songs Affect People's Beliefs About War

influence about what people think about war. This is because songs were constantly being made and listened to during war times. Some artists create songs that are portraying the affect about why war is good and how it is right to fight for your country, but other artists create songs to try and influence people that war is not good and that the world needs peace. The main focus I am going to explain is, how songs that don’t encourage war, affect people's opinion about war. First of all the song “Imagine”…

Words 672 - Pages 3

"The Lottery" vs. "The Most Dangerous Game" Essay

Should War be Shown on Television? The first war to be covered on television was the Vietnam War, which lasted roughly around 20 years. Since then, there has been lots of controversy centered on whether war should be televised or not. I firmly say that war shouldn’t be televised. Many things can (and have) been televised, but I think showing war on television would be crossing the line. In the 1940’s, most people didn’t have their own television, so this was never a problem. War scenes are known…

Words 954 - Pages 4

Essay about war on drugs

Drugs 2 The war on drugs is the fight to keep illegal drugs off of the streets. The government is fighting the drug dealers and users single-handedly, and are somewhat successful with catching drug lords. The government then fails with drug treatment programs. If the government would just educate the drugies why the drug is bad instead of saying it is with no reason then we might see some progress in the war on drugs. The war on drugs is ineffective and needs to be changed. The drug…

Words 713 - Pages 3

Ww1 Causes

significant issues that caused WWI to occur. Before the Great War broke out, nations in Europe were prospering, and countries were acquiring new land that helped them grow their economy and spark revolutionary ideas. The need to look strong and powerful by spreading world influence through land consumption was more prevalent than ever and the idea of imperialism skyrocketed. After a while, land dried up, and Germany, a country who was in need of land, was left with only one option. She had to take the…

Words 806 - Pages 4

Vietnam War Research Paper

Matt Mummert Dr. Fahmy POL 155 February 9, 2014 Causes of War One of the ugliest US Conflicts, the Vietnam War, began due to a variety of causes. The earliest of these causes was the failed French imperialist state. France had occupied and managed Vietnam for decades, and they eventually were forced to leave after they continued to lack success in Vietnam. Revolutionary North Vietnamese organizations were growing in power. France lost touch with the national interests of the Vietnamese which…

Words 426 - Pages 2

Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

bodies, bravery, stories extremely prominent in almost every war story. However, what would happen if some of these stories about brave soldiers bearing through bombs and bullets were never true, would they lose their meaning and die in the infinite abyss of obscurity, or would they still be just as impactful as before despite not being completely factual? In Tim O'Brien's novel The Things They Carried, O’Brien argues that war stories don’t need to be fully true to teach a person something because the…

Words 609 - Pages 3

Essay on Women of World War Two

During WW II Women played a very vital role during the World War 2. The 1940’s were built of a decade made of tension and transitions are the only words that sum it all up. While ten million men were at war, and the rest were at work. Women had to take men’s place in the work force. The need for women to work outside of the home was in higher demand. The world realized that the only way to win the war was to hire women to meet the war commands. So women were hired to meet these commands and they…

Words 416 - Pages 2

World War I Changed America Research Paper

massive global conflicts such as World War I, World War II, and the Vietnam War, just to name a few. These conflicts, mixed with a rapid development in technology, led to extreme casualties for all nations that participated in these conflicts, including the United States. World War I boosted the U.S. economy exponentially because of the need for mass production and government intervention in the economy, which changed Americans’ everyday lives. Moreover, World War II expanded the United States’ economy…

Words 1055 - Pages 5

What Would I Get Rid Of In The 21st Cen Essay

What would I get rid of in the 21st century Wars http://creativewritingdisorganization.blogspot.co.uk/2007/02/thoughts-from-war.html http://makewordsnotwar.wordpress.com/tag/creative-writing/ http://www.debate.org/opinions/is-war-a-necessary-evil Eleanor Roosevelt We have to face the fact that either all of us are going to die together or we are going to learn to live together and if we are to live together we have to talk. In war, as it is waged now, with the enormous losses on both sides, both…

Words 667 - Pages 3

My Creative Essay

Zuriel Salvador Pre- ap English 1/4B Ms. Starnes 10/17/12 War doesn't just affect the warzone, war affect the world War affects the populace by damaging the economy, effects the jobs, and effects the families. One effect that affects the populace is that war damages the economy. In the article "Iraq, Afghanistan, and the U.S. economy", "CBO now estimates the costs of the Iraq war, projected out through 2017, might top $1 trillion..." (Teslik). This shows how much debt problems the U.S. have…

Words 454 - Pages 2