The Problem Of Evil and Suffering Essay

Submitted By beessie96
Words: 2212
Pages: 9
Open Document
(i) What is the problem of evil?
‘Physical pain, mental suffering and moral wickedness. The last is one of the causes of the first two, for an enormous amount of human pain arises from people’s inhumanity. This pain includes such major scourges as poverty, oppression and persecution, war and all the injustice, indignity and inequalities that have occurred through history.’ This written by John Hick in Philosophy of Religion and this quote defined what evil and suffering was. The problem of evil and suffering is a major problem for religious believers as it talks about how there is evil and suffering within our world and this evil and suffering means that it’s hard to believe in an all loving god. According to David Hume this problem is the ‘rock of atheism’.

The problem of evil was first brought to our attention by the Greek philosopher Epicurus (341 BC - 270 BC) as he raised the question “If God is an all-good, all powerful creator, where did evil come from and why doesn’t God prevent it?”

There are three types of evil when we are discussing the problem of evil and suffering. One of the evils is natural evil and this the malfunctioning of the natural world for example natural disasters like earthquakes, volcanoes, famines and floods and then these natural disasters may cause use diseases. To define Natural evil John Hick wrote ‘Natural evil is the evil that originates independently of human actions, in disease… in earthquakes, storms, droughts, tornadoes’. The second form of evil is moral evil and this type of evil is the evil that is the result from human actions for example murder, war and cruelty. David Hume wrote in his book Is There A God? ‘Moral evil I understand as including all evil causes deliberately by humans doing what they ought not to do, and also the evil constituted by such deliberate actions or negligent failure’.

Within his paper Evil and Omnipotence J.L. Mackie talked about three things and put them into a triangle this then forms the inconsistent triad. In this triad there are three points and these are God is omnipotence, God is Omnibenevolence and that evil and suffering does exist. It is known as the inconsistent triad as one of these points must be false. So for example if God was to be omnipotence and Omnibenevolence then evil and suffering wouldn’t exist. David Hume argued that these three possibilities within the inconsistent triad are the only ones to exist, and since there is evidence within our world support the fact that there is the existence of evil within our world, we cannot have either an all-powerful God, or an all good God.

One response to the problem of evil is the Augustinian theodicy looks at evil as the privation of goodness exactly like blindness is the privation of sight. This theodicy was developed by St. Augustine (354—430 A.D.) and was a Christian response to the problem of evil. This theodicy says that sing evil is not an entity itself therefore God could not have created this evil and that God had created this universe perfect. Evil is in fact, according to this theodicy, originates from free will which every single human has, and it is said that it’s from angels and humans turning their back against God and settling for a different, lesser form of goodness. This is because we humans are contingent beings and they can be changed as they are made out of nothing and this leaves the possibility of them turning evil. God is perfect however none of his creations are perfect. This theodicy also discusses how natural evil comes into our world and this is because of our human actions which have caused a disruption within the natural order, and then this causes all of the natural evil. Augustinian theodicy argues that evil is a deprivation of good rather than a positive substance created by God has been supported by some modern thinkers. This theory also argues that evil has resulted from the abuse of human free will has also been supported by modern thinkers. It
Show More

Related Documents: The Problem Of Evil and Suffering Essay

The Problem of Evil Essay examples

Phil 300 The Problem of Evil One of the most interesting questions in the world is, “If a God exists, why is there evil in the world?” Most people respond with, “If God created the universe and us, then there should not be evil in the world,” when asked about God or any other powerful being. The problem of evil is also believed to be the cause of Atheism, and I do believe that there is a solution for this. The problem of evil is not a correct argument. The arguments from evil state that if…

Words 1287 - Pages 6

David Hume God And Evil Essay

A Perfect God in a World with Evil? The orthodox theist defines God as an all-good, all-knowing and all-powerful being (Rauhut 186). An all-knowing God would be aware of all the evil and all the suffering taking place in this world. An all-powerful God would have the capacity to do something to prevent this evil and this suffering. Finally, an all-good God would have the want and the will to prevent all that evil and suffering and do something about it("Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy" ).This…

Words 1560 - Pages 7

Summary Of Free Will Defense By J. L. Mackie

The problem of evil is a profound and intricate challenge for theism that questions the possibility of moral and natural evils with the existence of an omnipotent, omniscient, and omnibenevolent God. This essay will explore J. L. Mackie’s logical problem of evil, starting by examining its fundamental characteristics and then addressing potential solutions to the problem. It will then follow a deeper analysis of Alvin Plantinga’s Free Will Defense and finally explain why the Free Will Defense is inadequate…

Words 1354 - Pages 6

Essay on Response to the Idea of Evil

idea of evil is one of the most contended with problems for those who have faith in God. Theists have dealt with the idea and reality of evil for hundreds of years. Famous philosopher David Hume discusses the existence of evil present in the world in Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion. In the later sections of Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Philo presents a contradiction to an argument that Demea has posed. He states how God possesses many good characteristics, and yet evil exists. Philo…

Words 1409 - Pages 6

C. S. Lewis Argument On The Problem Of Evil

spouse Joy Davidman as an agent in biographing Lewis’ story. The filmmakers do so in order to illustrate the ways in which Joy’s presence worked in shaping Lewis’ faith as well as his account on the Problem of Evil throughout his life. This paper will account for Shadowlands main argument on the Problem of Evil, while providing a critical analysis and response to the argument presented. Shadowlands depicts Lewis as an imaginative and an academic writer, as well as a…

Words 503 - Pages 3

Teleological Argument Analysis

I. 1. The problem of evil begins with the idea that there is an all righteous, all powerful, and all knowing God. In this case, the evil and suffering that does exist in the world is heavily questioned. The problem of evil is that if there is an all powerful God, why can he not control the suffering people he loves endures. If there is an all knowing God, why does he not stop the evil and suffering. In David Hume’s Dialogues of Natural Religion, he uses the problem of evil to argue God’s moral…

Words 850 - Pages 4

The Monotheistic God Of Christianity, Judaism, And Islam

The Problem of Evil In the philosophy of religion, the monotheistic God of Christianity, Judaism, and Islam assumes the divine qualities of omnipotence, omniscience, and omnibenevolence. However, the problem of evil provides a challenge to the existence of a loving God in the classic theism of the Abrahamic religions. There are two types of evil that exist in the world, moral evil and natural evil. Moral evil is the result of human immorality, such as crime, cruelty, discrimination, genocide,…

Words 2358 - Pages 10

Irenaean Theodicy Research Paper

made in response to the problem of evil by defending the existence of an omnipotent and omnibenevolent God. It claims that this world created by this God is the best of all possible worlds because it contains what people need to fully develop, and that while evil exists its existence is not because God created it. He is not responsible or guilty for this. Humans are made incomplete just through creation itself and must undergo a life with suffering and experience of evil to become fully complete…

Words 392 - Pages 2

The Existence of God and Evil Essay

The Existence of God and Evil The problem of evil has been around since the beginning. How could God allow such suffering of his “chosen people”? God is supposedly all loving (omni-benevolent) and all powerful (omnipotent) and yet He allows His creations to live in a world of danger and pain. Two philosophers this class has discussed pertaining to this problem is B.C. Johnson and John Hick. Johnson provides the theists’ defense of God and he argues them. These include free will, moral urgency,…

Words 2226 - Pages 9

Doctrine of Evil Final Woodbridge Essay

the Problem of Evil Submitted to Dr. Russell Woodbridge in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the completion of the course Theo 626 – B04 Introduction to Seminary Studies by Simone Atkinson March 9, 2014 Table of Contents Introduction 1 Development of the Doctrine of Evil 3 The Nature of the Problem of Evil 5 Current Solutions Presented on the Problem of Evil 6 Finitism 7 God’s Goodness Modified 8 Denial of the Problem of Evil 10 Themes for Dealing with Evil 11 Evil is Necessary…

Words 4364 - Pages 18