The Pros And Cons Of Aid

Submitted By kmvette
Words: 1380
Pages: 6
Open Document
Katie Vette w1474607 Prosperity Aid is a multibillion-dollar a year industry created to help countries in need yet, it is the leading cause of debates across the world. At the focus of this debate lies the question everyone wants the answer to, is aid working? Scholars from both sides of this debate think they have all the answers and proof to why or why not aid is working so, who is right? I believe that certain types of aid are helping countries under certain circumstances however, it is not working under others and my factors contribute to why this is. I will discuss the main factors that come into play for why aid is not working including; what type of aid is being used and how unsuccessful the dispensation and implementation of the aid by institutions is. I will also go on to explain how humanitarian aid can be helpful to countries. Leading into how in some countries aid is not the solution to the problem discussing the hopelessness of aid that is not domestically driven. William Easterly, author of The White Man’s Burden: Why the West’s Efforts to Aid the Rest Have Done So Much Ill and So Little Good, sums up why aid isn’t working in one short yet affective sentence, "Poor people die not only because of the world's indifference to their poverty, but also because of ineffective efforts by those who do care." (Easterly, 2006, p7). Firstly, there are many different types of aid and depending upon what type of aid a country is receiving can be a leading cause to why aid isn’t working. Developmental aid takes place within the worlds poorest countries by promoting development and aiming to reduce poverty. Bilateral and multilateral aid donors are dominating the development aid services today. These donors are leading within aid services because these donors are made up of multiple companies thus, having the access to more money. However, with more money comes more power and that is how some of these donors become corrupt. In the article Governance, Representation and International Aid, published in the Third World Quarterly, professor Shelia Nair argues, “Development and poverty reduction approaches crafted principally by bilateral and multilateral aid agencies, and by policy and academic elites, are accompanied by hegemonic representations about aid.” (Nair, 2013, p648). Nair suggests that leading bilateral and multilateral donors intentions are not a clean and sweet as they might like people to think. Instead, within these donors policies are prescriptions for how to govern the poor which enhances the asymmetry of power between the donor and recipient relationship. The asymmetry of power factors into why aid doesn’t work, if there is an imbalance of power between donor and recipient corruption becomes a threat within the flow of aid. Another, type of aid is humanitarian the only aid of which I believe has the ability to be completely good for a country. This corruption can be avoided by implanting the values of good governance within these donor corporations. Good governance Humanitarian aid is used to respond to emergencies such as natural disasters. This type of aid is vital to countries when tragedies strike and organizations such as the Red Cross have dedicated volunteers ready to give their personal assistance. Also, within humanitarian aid come the branches of organizations that have people who dedicate themselves to teaching people in developing countries the skills they need so that their environment becomes livable. In a perfect world this would be the only aid given to developing countries but these organizations are very expensive to start and maintain. Individual donors celebs
The prestigious idea of how the implementation and distribution of aid occurs is another contributing factor to people’s impression of aid efficiency. William Easterly, an economist who specializes in economic growth and foreign aid, points out in his book The White Man’s Burden “The West spent $2.3 trillion on
Show More

Related Documents: The Pros And Cons Of Aid

Race and 40 th Tallahassee Marathon Essay examples

recovering well from the race! If you happen to be a local runner, the clothes left at the FSU track (from the start area, 1st & 2nd aid stations) have been washed, folded and are on our front porch. Contact us if you have something and I will give you the address, but do so quickly. The clothes will be given to charity next Friday if not picked up. The final results are on line at http://gulfwinds.org/raceresults/2014/Marathon%202014.asp The link to view pictures is http://www2.backprint…

Words 4069 - Pages 17

Stigmatization in Society Essay

Andre Flores 4/13/12 Section B2 Stigmatization in Society We live in a society where, regardless of what race, age, ethnicity, physical make-up, etc., you will get judged. People living with HIV/AIDS are a prime example of stigmatization. There are three major groups of people with HIV/AIDS that are stigmatized. Those groups are homosexuals, drug users, and those who live in 3rd world countries. The government, and others with similar powers have seemed to do a lot to help get rid of stigmatizations…

Words 1186 - Pages 5

Essay about Medical Marijuana

Running Head: FINAL RESEARCH PAPER 1 Final Research Paper Medical Marijuana FINAL RESEARCH PAPER 2 Alternative medicine has become a rather popular method of relieving everything from a headache to depression. Some common forms of alternative medic include aromatherapy, acupuncture, and crystal therapy. Among them is the healing power of medical cannabis. It has been praised for its soothing and hallucinogenic qualities. Medical marijuana has been on the forefront of public debate…

Words 856 - Pages 4

Person: Poverty and Countries Essay

International aid In this day and age, it is standard practice for some advanced countries to provide some help to poor countries. But when it comes to the topic about the international aid, people hold divergent views. Some argue it is a good thing. Others contend that international aid has brought about some negative effects. Personally, I believe both of these two views have some merit. There are definitely numerous benefits associated with international aid. Firstly…

Words 562 - Pages 3

Essay on Aids: Aids and Safe Sex

AIDS also known as Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome is caused by the Human Immunodeficiency Virus (HIV). This virus was discovered in the United States in 1984. As the illness progresses around the US, it interferes more and more with the immune system, making the person much more likely to get infections.HIV is transmitted primarily unprotected sexual intercourse contaminated transfusions, hypodermic, and from mother to child during pregnancy, delivery, or breastfeeding. Some bodily fluids, such…

Words 383 - Pages 2

List Some Common Neurotransmitters And Describe Their Effect On Behavior?

have a specific effect on the nerve circuit which may either aid or hinder communications. Neurotransmitters which are helpful to the process of communication are known as excitatory. In contrast, the neurotransmitters hindering proper communications are referred to as inhibitory (Live! Psych, 2002). Some of the common neurotransmitters include endorphins, serotonin, and dopamine. Endorphins are small chains of amino acids which aid in the reduction of pain. These neurotransmitters are regularly…

Words 1329 - Pages 6

How To Write An Informative Speech

of the message. The speaker must select and incorporate a visual aid that to visually enhances and supports their presentation (25 points). Pay careful attention to see that the topic is adapted to the audience and the occasion. The topic should be well researched as evidenced by strong supporting materials. Remember to choose a topic that you can present in 4 to 6 minutes. At the time of delivery, you will turn in a typed final outline with a bibliography or reference section, worth 25 points…

Words 1582 - Pages 7

Instructional Plan Worksheet

Instructional Plan Worksheet Directions: 1. Review the Merrill (2002) article, the “instructional plan” handout and template for the course, and Merrill’s First Principles Job Aid. Also, review the work you’ve already completed – particularly the objectives and performance assessment. 2. Use this worksheet to paint the broad strokes of how you see your training unfolding. This will be a balancing act. On the one hand, your team will need to make (and document) decisions about time allocations and…

Words 1169 - Pages 5

Police Officer Essay

CALCULATION Schools use the report provided by SSS to begin a review of your finances before making the final determination of how much your family should contribute toward education. In this review schools use their professional judgment to consider the additional information you entered on the PFS to better understand your family’s financial picture. Each school may determine a different final family contribution governed by its policies on: 16 Home-Present Market Value $100,743 17…

Words 680 - Pages 3

being a writer Essay

IVY TECH COMMUNITY COLLEGE Financial Aid Office 2012‐2013 Federal Direct Loan Request Fall 2012 and Spring 2013 Semesters ONLY Student Name ________________________________________________ Student ID # C________________________ Address ___________________________________________________ Telephone (_____)_____‐_______________ City ________________________________________________ State ______________ Zip Code __________________ You do not need to complete this form to apply for grants…

Words 920 - Pages 4