The Third Dumpster

Submitted By leshemrae
Words: 1093
Pages: 5
Open Document
January 29th, 2015
Leshem Rae

ENGL 220 H: Close Reading Assignment
“The Third Dumpster” by Gish Jen

The Third Dumpster is approximately a seven page short story written by Gish Jen. In this story, the author does not seem to have any relation to the characters other than simply being the storyteller; a third person point of view. The tone of the writing can be seen as funny, farce and somewhat confusing. The stories tone is considered funny because in many parts of the story Jen uses slight humour through the characters rolls. It is almost as if the characters lives themselves are a joke, something to be mocked. The two brothers, Morehouse and Goodwin cannot seem to get their lives together; Goodwin’s wife divorced him, both men are unemployed contractors as well as pressure their parents put on them to conform to Chinese culture/values even though they are live in America (a completely different culture that allows people to have a sense of freedom). The boys feel trapped between their parent’s approval and the desire to be who they want in the society they live in; the natural instinct to please their parents is holding both of them back. Therefore the entire story revolves around this mockery of the two bother lives not being what they want, and their desire to please their parents keeps them stuck in one place. The story can also be confusing to a reader because of a few writing choices that create some misguidance, but ultimately is resolved by the end.
The plot of this story is interesting; the author gives us pieces of the “bigger picture” or entire plot as we continue to read. At first the reader is given minimal information about the two brothers buying a house for very cheap at an auction, and as the story progresses the reader discovers the reason for their purchase and continually more information on who the brothers are. The plot can create some confusion to the reader (like stated previously) however it does begins to grow clearer as we continue to read.
There are a few stylistic choices within this story that not only add significance, but also are found to be untraditional and rather fascinating. Perhaps the most interesting of them all would be the most obvious; throughout the story Jen never once uses quotations to indicate when a character is speaking. Even without the use of quotation in this story, it is very easy to indicate whether a character or the author speaking. When I pondered why she would choose to eliminate the use of quotations, a few idea came to mind; the vacant quotations – although Jen flawlessly does it- can look a little messy, cluttered and blurred, just like the way the two brothers feel about who they are. The brothers feel rather lost in the twister of their own desires to fit more in American society and confusion of wanting to please their parents by conforming to traditional Chinese values. I also thought that the nonexistent quotations may represent the house their renovating for their parents. Just like they way the chaotic form of writing with no quotations, the house is initially very messy.
Another stylistic choice that I found to be interesting was Jen’s use of italics. Italics we only ever used by their parents when they were either talking about American culture (in disapproval, of course) or when they were putting emphasis on Chinese culture. The italics are putting greater attention on the thoughts shown in the specific text; therefore if only thoughts in italics have to do with American and Chinese culture, we can once again assume that this intentionally adds more tension to the brother’s thoughts on their beliefs. The italics add extra pressure to this tug-of-war between the two cultures.
Irony also seems be reoccurring throughout this story. Possibly the most ironic would be the name of the two brothers, Morehouse and Goodwin, both names sound very American when we already know as readers that their parents are very supportive of Chinese culture. This is ironic
Show More

Related Documents: The Third Dumpster

Essay week2RDG 534lessonplan

Lesson Title The Giver: Close Reading Chapters 1 & 2 Topic Novel study of The Giver by Lois Lowry Objectives Students will be able to identify ask informative questions about the text read while being mindful of the theme and how if affects each of the characters and the overall plot of the story. Standards CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.8.1Cite the textual evidence that most strongly supports an analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text. CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.8…

Words 591 - Pages 3

Litrary Luminary1 Essay

Literary Luminary Name: Rushil Mistry Period: 3rd Meeting Date: 12/9/2014 Reading Assignment: 20-22 Novel: Frankenstein Job Assignment: Your job is to locate a special passage in this week’s reading to close read. The passage selected must be anywhere from a page to two pages. You should do three different things with the passage: First—You should photocopy the page(s) you plan to close read. Then you must proceed to close read the passage, making annotations and comments while highlighting important…

Words 587 - Pages 3

The Crucible Character Based Assessment Essay

knowledge about the book we read, the “Crucible” by Arthur Miller. We had close reading we did almost everyday to help us really understand the characters. Why did Ms.Thayer ask me to participate in a CBA? First things first the CBA was very fun, I really thought it was fascinating. It’s different because from a regular assignment you would have to just write your point of view without disscussing about it. Regular assignments are long and boring and independent. When we did the CBA, the whole class…

Words 613 - Pages 3

My Writing Experience

is my primary language, it became difficult to read in English during elementary school. I realized that going to your teachers for extra support during lunch has a positive influence in your life. My interest in reading and writing has increased to a great extent. This interest in reading and writing improved when I made a point that if I enjoy the context, I am able to maintain focused and entertained. I have improved exponentially as a writer since my 9th grade year, after getting my work back from…

Words 876 - Pages 4

Love: Amiri Baraka and Close Reading Essay

FIRST ESSAY ASSIGNMENT English 285: American Ethnic Literature Prof. Cameron Leader-Picone In this essay, you will closely analyze one of the literary sources that we have read so far in order to argue what the author represents as the meaning and structure of racial identity, race as a concept and racism. This essay builds off of the techniques practiced in our first close reading assignment. Your essay must make a clear and explicit argument, contained in a thesis, about what the text you…

Words 1121 - Pages 5

A Guide To Writing Proposals Essay

feasible solution: solar and wind power in residential areas, or, via business buildings. Problems / questions/ outcries: expensive, placement, etc. In your introduction, you will use an argumentative thesis statement—this will differ from our close reading assignments because you will not introduce an author and an essay. Rather, you will introduce a topic and make a claim. Your overview should explain the issue briefly, and explain that there are solutions to the existing problem or issue. Don’t forget…

Words 441 - Pages 2

Academic Dishonesty and Designated Rescue Area Essay

texts will emphasize both close reading and historical (cultural, political, and literary) contexts. Required Textbooks: 30/30: Thirty American Stories from the Last Thirty Years (Editors: Shreve and Ngyun) Publisher: Longman (2005) ISBN: 978-0321338983 Wolf Whistle (Author: Lewis Nordan) Publisher: Algonquin Books (2003) ISBN: 978-1565121102 Assignments The schedule of daily reading assignments and due dates is available on Moodle. Assignments on the schedule are subject…

Words 1058 - Pages 5

Literacy Reflection

being placed in the special table during reading time. Additionally, I did not know how to write until the second grade, and even then it was essential for me to spend one on one time with the teacher. It was difficult for me to seek from help from my parents because they were still learning English, hence them coming to the United States from Argentina where Spanish is the national language. Although their English was conversational, their writing and reading was not proficient. Yet, I received disappointed…

Words 628 - Pages 3

Syllabi And Forecasting For January Calendar For MR 208

March, April Note: Reading the announcement section, the syllabi and reviewing the course calendar will help you know exactly what to expect and when to expect it. Familiarize yourself with these tools to help keep you on track. . February Calendar MR 208 ◄ January ~ February 2015 ~ March ► Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat 1 2 3 4 Week one assignment due 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Week two assignment due 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 Week 3 assignment du 19 20 21 22…

Words 474 - Pages 2

Textual Analysis

of nations." "lt almost looks _sigmund Freud 5 to 6 pages The primary goal of this assignment is to help the reader of your paper understand "Late Victorians." To accomplish this, you are going to be asked to draw upon almost every tool and every approach that we have covered thus far in this class, as well as acquaint yourself with a few new techniques. We will be talking at length about this assignment over the next couple of classes, but be aware that at a minimum your analysis should attempt…

Words 459 - Pages 2