The Turner Thesis

Words: 588

Pages: 3

Open Document

The American Frontier contains the geography, history, folklore, and cultural expression of life in the forward influx of American development that started with English colonial settlements in the early 1800s. The American Frontier focuses mainly on the westward expansion in the 19th century. The American Frontier was effective in producing economic and technologic growth; on the other hand, the American Frontier was detrimental due to the fact that Native Americans and European immigrants were forced to adapt to the American lifestyle. As shown in these sources, discrimination of European and Native Americans during this period were detrimental to society as a whole. The Americans took over Native American land, persuaded them to sign treaties, and used violence to take over tribes. Most commonly, the …show more content…
The moral of The Turner Thesis is to depict how the American Frontier caused the assimilation of Europeans. Turner had a positive outlook on the assimilation of the Europeans, in which it lead to American individualism. On the other hand, The Ghost Dance Ballad depicts how the American Frontier caused violence and assimilation of the Native Americans, which ultimately lead to a negative outlook on the American Frontier. The two sources are similar in the fact that the assimilation of the Native Americans and Europeans lead to American Individualism. In the Turner Thesis the white men were viewed as strong, and in the Ghost Dance Ballad the army was viewed as in control. The Turner Thesis is more reliable due to the fact that Turner was most likely educated; whereas, the author of the Ghost Dance Ballad was probably not. In addition, the author of the Ghost Dance Ballad viewed the American Frontier negatively because he was apart of the violence. As mentioned above, the Turner Thesis could make the opposite argument that the American Frontier was beneficial due to the author’s

Frederick Jackson Turner Frontier Thesis

Topic 2 Assignment: Frontier Thesis The Frontier Thesis was an argument made by historian Frederick Jackson Turner during the 1890s. He claimed in this argument that the American people as a whole had been shaped by the frontier. During this time, the frontier was basically the unsettled land in the western part of America. As time passed, the frontier line was steadily expanded as small farmers moved to the west as a result of the Homestead Act. Because of its expansion, the frontier seemingly vanished…

Words 419 - Pages 2

Nat Turner: A Troublesome Property

Charles Burnette’s documentary Nat Turner: A Troublesome Property is insightful and thought provoking. The title itself speaks volume because Nat Turner was, in fact, troublesome property for his owners. Consequently, Nat Turner’s story remained problematic for writers, film producers, and historians. The documentary discusses how Turner’s account of the revolt has been retold since The Confessions of Nat Turner was written by Thomas R. Gray in 1831. It addresses the question of how lethal should…

Words 390 - Pages 2

Westward Expansion Analysis

Citing Turner’s thesis as a representation of the “old west view” that is preoccupied with focusing on the triumphs of the white male in this uncharted territory, forgetting to consider the impact of Women, Native Americans or the multicultural society of Mexican-Americans…

Words 945 - Pages 4

Frederick Jackson Turner's Westward Expansion Thesis

Frederick Jackson Turner’s thesis focuses on the importance of westward expansion in American History. The frontier lies on the edge of free land, and it is in human nature to continue expansion. Turner argues that expanding west equals to developing America. This parallels prior beliefs that it was the American people’s destiny to expand west, more commonly known as Manifest Destiny. The people had already begun to move, but traveled and established settlements so isolated the frontier was not…

Words 289 - Pages 2

Essay about Lena Concurs with Fredrick Jackson Turner's Argument

Lena Concurs with FJT’s Argument In Frederick Jackson Turner’s essay on the frontier thesis, he states that all who enter the frontier shall embrace the new American intellect it is molding. Turner believes that all who enter it will transform into hardy, creative, hardworking individuals. He asserts that it will transform the colonists into individualistic, functional characters who excel in the area of practicality. Lena Lingard’s life supports with Frederick Jackson Turner’s argument that all…

Words 761 - Pages 4

Was Frederick Turner Jackson's Frontier Correct?

I think Frederick Turner Jackson's Frontier Thesis is correct. I believe that our frontier has played a huge role in differing Americans from their European origins, and that America should expand more. However, on page 584 it states, "...the thesis underscores the pervasive racism and disregard for the indigenous communities, cultures, and individuals in the American borderlands and beyond." Though I agree with his thesis, I do want to acknowledge its downfalls, like how it ignores the atrocities…

Words 266 - Pages 2

Essay about Frontier Thesis

Although some suggest Frederick Jackson Turner’s “frontier thesis” holds truth in the fact that the frontiers moved westward steadily, others disagree that the actual settlement of the west was not steady. There are certain events that prove Turner’s thesis unstable such as the homestead act and individualism. In his thesis Turner chooses to ignore the Native Americans that were living on the land saying it was “free land”. The Native Americans were forced out of their homes as the settlers and…

Words 373 - Pages 2

Turner's Thesis On The American Frontier Thesis

As turner said settlers did not care who they were running over the frontier land was free for the taking. They would take down every native tribe to gain that free land. Just like that the American democracy was born right out of the forest turner said "American democracy was born of no theorist's dream; it was not carried in the Susan Constant to Virginia, nor in the Mayflower to Plymouth. It came out of the American forest, and it gained new strength each time it touched a new frontier," Although…

Words 1065 - Pages 5

The American Frontier

Togetherness among the many individuals lead to discoveries just a few years after the American frontier was closed. More to say, the American were greatly in bondage during the frontier era as more reliance was on unoccupied land that according to Turner was of less benefit to the population occupying it (Sain,…

Words 1429 - Pages 6

Essay about Judt, Snyder, Turner

killing sites; it was the Red Army that liberated Auschwitz, Treblinka, Sorbibór, Belzec, Chelmno and Majdanek. What does Stalin’s prewar murders suggest to Judt’s thesis that war makes massacre possible? I would argue that Stalin’s prewar murders together with the laud and honour he received by the end of the Second World War support Judt’s thesis that the distortion of the wartime experience in continental Europe in public memory gave the postwar era an identity that was fundamentally false. Perhaps the…

Words 1031 - Pages 5