The Ultimate Taboo Essay

Submitted By Janie-Ervine
Words: 694
Pages: 3
Open Document
The Ultimate Taboo: ‘Survival Cannibalism’
Reflective Assignment—Grade 12 Law Course

Cannibalism is often regarded as one of the most deeply repugnant acts to be committed in a civilized society--one that is fraught with obsessive fears and fascination. However in such extreme circumstances as that of R v. Dudley and Stephens (1884), State v. Holmes (1841), or the case of the Donner Party (1846-47); these extremist of situations had about them a kind of normality found only in our innate human nature and the instinct to essentially survive. Such taboo subjects often become the subject of jokes, and comically macabre poetry responded to by well-known writers, including Bryon, W.S. Gilbert and W. Thackeray. This is a nervous humour that unfolds in our society when faced with the unspeakable ways that we as ‘civilized human beings’ assimilate these great horrors into our culture. To look extensively at one case in particular, it must first be addressed that among the scientific and anthological community, anthropologists have divided anthropophagy (cannibalism) into two broad categories. The first is ‘learned cannibalism’ also referred to as customary anthropophagy and the second, is classified as ‘survival cannibalism’ as found in the multiple cases that have been listed above. Anthropologists agree ‘survival cannibalism’ is innate and cannot be learned, perhaps in that regard, it is more easily forgiven in the minds of civilized societies and Westerners. It is under terrible circumstances that perhaps murder for self preservation or survival can be excused as a basic act of instinct and that prior to turning to human flesh for sustenance: dogs, candles, leather, shoes, and blankets are all consumed before cannibalism becomes the ‘only recourse’ for human survival. The concept of justifiable homicide in criminal law ‘stands on the dividing line between an excuse, justification and exculpation’. It differs from other forms of homicide in that, due to certain circumstances, the homicide is justified as ‘preventing greater harm to innocents’ (Martin, 1980).
In the case of R v. Dudley and Stephen, State v. Holmes, and the case of the Donner Party; there is only (one) viable recourse for survival and that is to either ‘kill or be killed’ or die from dehydration and starvation. As Professor Sandel addressed in his lecture, there is common question that always comes into play when exploring the philosophical, moral and ethical boundaries of extenuating circumstances: why should the lives of the few be saved over the lives of the many? Why save one, when you can save five? Either way, you are making a conscious decision—a decision that is premised on either the utilitarian prospective (a measure) or an act of moral consequentialism. The story of the Mignonette was an exception. For one thing, the ritual was not observed,
Show More

Related Documents: The Ultimate Taboo Essay

Principles Ayers Theme Essay

Hileri Keizer 11/24/14 EDUC – 479 What’s all the Taboo about? The art of teaching has become a profession where others who are outsiders to what actually go on as a teacher. Day to day teachers are now battling what needs to be taught for the students to pass standardized tests and Common Core curriculum and their hidden curriculum that teachers want to teacher to their students. It is the struggle teachers have to be able to be balance…

Words 342 - Pages 2

Death In Catcher In The Rye

Human fear the inescapable, that all living beings will die in the end. The topic of death is perceived as a societal taboo in any given discussion. It is difficult to find a community in which death is spoken openly and freely. Eventually, this coldness towards death leads to ignorance towards it. This is seen in the novel, The Catcher in the Rye by J.D Salinger which depicts a teenage protagonist and his failed interaction with adults. Through this the protagonist views adulthood as a cynical…

Words 212 - Pages 1

Marbury V. Madison 1803: A Case Study

The historic case of Marbury V. Madison 1803 gave the ultimate power to the Supreme Court to declare decision/act of Congress unconstitutional (Cornell Law, Marbury v. Madison). Entrusting one branch of government with all power may lead to dictatorship; hence to avoid such power Judicial Review was introduced to the American Court System. Judicial Review creates check and balance with other branch (Executive and Legislative) of government giving right to Judicial with power to veto the decisions…

Words 299 - Pages 2

Maggie Kilgour's Cannibalism

Whether it be considered deviant and appalling in American society, the cannibalistic process does not impede a human being’s natural desire to comprehend the different. It is through individuals’ innate inquisitiveness and tendencies to understand taboos that have created a mass interest in the abnormal practice of anthropophagy, Lindenbaum adds to this with the statement “The current surge of interest in cannibalism has also fed salacious newspaper and television reports of cannibalism as psychopathology…

Words 2280 - Pages 10

An Analysis of Lord of the Flies by William Golding Essay

broke the rules and went into savagery; Jack is the leader of the hunting tribe where they would hunt pigs. He is initially excited to play at democracy, increasing frustration he then doesn’t want to play anymore with the rules. He breaks ultimate social taboo which is cannibalism (well tries to anyways). This made me understand how Jack is not true to his word. Savagery has taken over him and the savagery shows how he has…

Words 593 - Pages 3

Menstrual Cycle and Dominique Christina Essay

mighty...something un-language-able...something in hieroglyphs...something that sounds like the end of the world! Name it for the roar between your legs, and for the women who will not be nameless here. Lucille Clifton and Dominique Christina take a taboo topic and haul it out into the open. Clifton launches menstruation into her writing in search of empathy and understanding from men, while Christina pushes it into the open as an example to her daughter that menstruation can be normal, named, and noble…

Words 1041 - Pages 5

Essay on Romanticism: Romanticism and Romanticism Alejandro Figueroa

expression. Romanticism emerged as a reaction against the over bearing rationalism in the arts during the 18th century. Thus emphasis in Romanticism was put on individualism, imagination, and free thinking. Also Romantic artist were thought to have the ultimate insight into the fundamentals of reality. All of the art in this era showed great creativity and the ability to break from social molds. Painting was no exception from this. During the Romantic era painters showed how they longed to break the…

Words 692 - Pages 3

Gender: Transgender and Twentieth Centuries Essay

Troubling Conceptions of Gender and Sexuality As children many of us are socialized to believe that we are ‘normal’ and that to be ‘normal’ is the ultimate goal. We are taught by our parents, teachers and the media how to act in ways that are socially appropriate for our class, race, nationality and gender. It is assumed that we are cisgender, heterosexual, patriotic beings that will maintain that identity throughout our whole life. However, as we grow up some of us realize that perhaps there…

Words 1968 - Pages 8

Star Wars Fans: The People Vs. George Lucas

laws of nature, there is no divine guidance, purpose, or providence in the universe” (Guignon 42). With just that being said, the Star Wars fans should know that George Lucas never really got rid of the original edits of his films. That's basically taboo in the film industry. Along with that, the originals will never die. So for the people saying that George Lucas destroyed their lives, killed their childhoods, ruined their families, that is not true! George Lucas did make a selfish move by editing…

Words 761 - Pages 4

Definition Essay-Why Should We Fantasize?

7). According to Block, these partners can be absolutely anyone; ranging from your own partner, a stranger, your ideal partner to even a relative, or your best friends spouse, it can be very taboo. Dr. Block calls this type of sexual fantasy, “The Perfect Lover” fantasy. These fantasies, could involve, simple kissing to intense sexual acts, oral sex, anal, passionate, yet innocent sexual intercourse and rough sex. It all might depend on what…

Words 1337 - Pages 6