Theory of War Essay

Submitted By cablair4
Words: 1321
Pages: 6
Open Document
Comment I
Question I
Politics of War Cody Blair
A. The first known war dates back nearly 5,500 years ago to the ruins of Hamoukar, which is the oldest known site of a large-scaled organized discovered in north-eastern Syria. Since this time there have been countless documented wars ranging over thousands of years, and still continues today. There have been many theories casted and debated as to why we fight wars, if it is biologically ingrained in human nature to do so, and whether it can be controlled if it is found to be true that it is.
Indications have been made that aggression is one reason that we fight. It was said that aggression became inherited from ancestors by the means of survival and evolutionary adaption. Since anthropological findings claimed that hunters and food gatherers who represented the early stage of cultural evolution were peaceful. This leads them to legitimize that prehistoric man lived in peace. (2) There are many motives to aggression such as hate, revenge, protection of self-esteem, etc. Many of those traits could stem from experiences during childhood, which could resort to violence later in life.(3) Though aggression can be one of the factors behind why humans fight, it has also been proclaimed that it is biologically imbedded in our nature to do so.
According to the Hobesian thesis “was is part of human nature and serves both the internal function of solidarity and the external function of maintaining the balance of power.”(1) Thomas Hobbes believed that men acted upon competitiveness, diffidence, and glory, these were his reasons behind why war was a state of nature for man.(1) His theory has been argued, Margret Mead writes:
“The Eskimo are not mild and meek people; many of them are turbulent and troublesome….here are men faced with hunger, men faced with loss of their wives, men threatened with extermination by other men….The personality necessary for war, the circumstances necessary to goad men to desperation are present, but there is no war.”(4)
Mead has her own theory that war is actually an invention. She uses different example of Indian tribes to give reasoning behind her theory. Tribes like the Pueblo Indians use “defensive warfare” to defend its village but never being the aggressor, or the Lepchas who have no knowledge of warfare, and would simply submit defeat. Depending on the civilization and their motive, “they will all go to war if they have the invention, just as those people who have the custom of dueling will have duels.”(4) Assuming that war is inside us the question becomes can we control the urge? According to the Seville statement, humans have a “violent brain”, but isn’t automatically activated. It needs to be triggered before a human acts on the urge to be violent.(7) The way that we act is shaped by the way we have been “conditioned and socialized”. There is nothing in our brains that makes us act in violently. The Seville statement goes on the say that there is nothing genetically programed in us to act violently as well. We are not born with the genes that make us want to act out in violence, but “while genes are involved in all levels of the nervous system functions, they provide a development potential that can be actualized only in conjunction with ecological and social environment.”(7) Meaning the genes do not cause us to be violent, it is the environment that one is raised in or the society around us that could determine why a certain person acts the way he or she does. Summarizing the Seville statement, we are not genetically programed to fight, but we are triggered by certain actions or events that make us this way basically causing a switch to flip on and off.
B. Men are commonly associated with aggression and competitiveness, these traits may help them be great leaders for politics or armies. Women on the other hand are seen to be less aggressive and be more conservative in nature. So the question is asked, “Would there be
Show More

Related Documents: Theory of War Essay

Just War Theory

The just war theory is a christian philosophy that was created to prevent warfare between nations by setting certain rules and conditions on when a war should be fought and how it should be fought . The most important part of the just war theory is that war should be avoided and should only be used as a last resort because taking human life is wrong, however, sometimes it is necessary to use war to protect innocent people and morals (Just War - Introduction). The American Revolutionary war should be…

Words 1316 - Pages 6

The Just War Theory

Iraq does not satisfy the six crucial requirements of the just war theory. More specifically, this paper contends (although subjectively) that the invasion does not meet the conditions of the cause being just, the right intention in embarking upon war, or war being undertaken only as a last resort. Yet, despite such reasoning, the mainstream news media from the invading countries represented the decision to invade as ‘just’. It is purported that such perpetuations occurred as a result of a relationship…

Words 275 - Pages 2

Just War Theory

The use of force in war is acceptable only when the benefits outway the potential suffering and damage of the force. This is governed by the fact that war without a beneficial result is simply unnecessary violence. The just war theory contains standards for causing war (jus ad bellum), and appropriate conduct during a war (jus in bello). Jus ad bellum includes standards that should be met before starting a war to ensure morality. This includes the fact that the war must be fought to bring about peace…

Words 719 - Pages 3

Just War Theory Analysis

Purpose of Just War The purpose of the Just War Theory is to establish a guide to the correct way for countries to act in situations of potential conflicts. Just War only applies to the states but not people even though the individuals can always use the theory of Just War in deciding whether it is right to take part in a particular war. Just War offers individuals and political groups with a useful framework to use in their discussions for possibilities of wars. The aim of the Just War theory is not to…

Words 1101 - Pages 5

Just War Theory Essay

Civil War was brutal and hard fought. Two conflicting beliefs clashed and almost resulted in the separation of a young nation just getting its foothold in the world. The war resulted in an estimated 620,000 casualties for both sides. Each side, the Union and the Confederacy, proved determined and stood by their ideals no matter how misguided they seemed to be. Though people today might think the war was justified, does it fit “Just War” Theory? This will take a look at the Just War Theory and whether…

Words 1102 - Pages 5

Just War Theory Essay examples

Religion (Just War) Christianity preaches peace and loving your neighbor but for the history of christianity, there has been violence and war in its name. For Many years people have been killing other human beings in the name of christ or justifying their killings by saying that the war is in the name of god. The belief that violence and war can be justified is called the “Just War Theory.” Just war is a war that is justified because it is necessary for peace to happen. Just war theory has its…

Words 2510 - Pages 11

Michael Walzer's Just War Theory

Michael Walzer, theory from Augustine to Aquinas to modern times. “Just War” has been used to justify and sometimes rationalize wars throughout history, by invoking its test of morality. Today, “Just War” theory is useful to scrutinize and critique wars in our time. Walzer states the reason for having a theory of “Just War” in a way that is hard to argue with is one, the moral reality of war is not fixed by the actual activities of the soldiers but by the opinions of humankind. Second, the truth…

Words 1464 - Pages 6

The US Invasion Of Iraq And Just War Theory

The U.S. Invasion of Iraq and Just War Theory Harris Sheikh Hum 102 Prof. Burke February 13, 2014 A corrupt nation can only win so many times before the lies begins to unravel and questions begins to rise. There haves been many incident throughout the history where the actions takenook by the government could be ruled unjust, yet people always tend to be blinded by the reality that stands in front of them. A war may have many reasons behind it, but for it…

Words 2196 - Pages 9

Just War Theory In St. Augustine's The City Of God

The basic principles of the “Just War Theory” start with the command leadership allowing for consideration the opinions of those officers below them. It has been proven that, “individuals and organizations invariably perform much more proficiently if they know what they are doing, why they are doing it, and most importantly believe in the mission to which they are assigned.”1 This is why the manner in which the leadership presents itself to the subordinates is so important and also why motivational…

Words 374 - Pages 2

Hegemonic, And Pluralistic Theories Of International Relations

Cyclical, Hegemonic, and Pluralistic Theories of International Relations: Some Comparative Reflections on War Causation Author(s): Franz Kohout Source: International Political Science Review / Revue internationale de science politique, Vol. 24, No. 1, Power Cycle Theory and Global Politics. Cycle de pouvoir et politique mondiale (Jan., 2003), pp. 51-66 Published by: Sage Publications, Ltd. Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/1601329 . Accessed: 12/03/2014 22:13 Your use of the JSTOR…

Words 8608 - Pages 35