Thomas Nagel - How Is It Like to Be a Bat? Essays

Words: 870
Pages: 4
Open Document
Thomas Nagel (1981) – How is it like to be a bat?
Why does "consciousness" make the mind-body problem really intractable according to Thomas Nagel?
In his text “What is it like to be a bat?” of 1974 Thomas Nagel claims that consciousness is the barrier that makes the mind-body problem unique and so hard.
He states that consciousness is rarely addressed by reductionists. Because there is no really persuading reduction available, implausible accounts of the mental have been developed to help explain familiar kind of reductions. This has led to reductionists ignoring consciousness. But according to Nagel the mind-body problem is boring without consciousness.
Nagel now turns to conscious experience. He finds that some animals and …show more content…
You could describe everything that happens in the head of someone who feels anger, further pogress in the neurosciences included. But no description of the objective, physical facts would deal with the subjective character of the experience itself.
For Nagel, then, there are only few things concerning the mind-body problem to be stated safely.
One of them is coming to the rescue of physicalism: mental states are states of the body; mental events are physical events. But he then admits that the apparent clarity of terms like “are” are deceiving. They just claim a reference. Without a theoretical framework that makes those references understandable, they still are not well defined. What we hold in our hands is the evidence that mental events have some physical description. But what we lack is the theoretical framework.
Nagel closes with some proposals: First he asks whether the question is properly stated: is there something at all, something really objective, how it is like to have his experiences, or can we only ask for subjective appearances? Second, Nagel speculates about the development of an objective phenomenology. We could develop concepts that describe experiences for others – we could, for example, start with blind people. Maybe this would
Show More

Related Documents: Thomas Nagel - How Is It Like to Be a Bat? Essays

Nagel Mind Body Interaction

by simply reducing the mental to the physical. One American philosopher, Thomas Nagel, states in his paper “What is it like to be a bat?” that consciousness must be addressed in order to explain the interaction between the mind and the body. Consciousness is one of the main complications in current theorizing about the mind as there is a major lack of agreement revolving around the theory of consciousness. In his paper, Nagel does not explicitly say that physicalism is false, but he does emphasize…

Words 1780 - Pages 8

We Can Never Know What It Like To Be A Bat Analysis

We Can Never Know What it’s Like to be A Bat Many philosophers agree that consciousness provides a very difficult problem in understanding the mind-body concept; this is why from a materialist’s point of view, the problem is not sufficient enough for giving one’s attention. Thomas Negal on the other hand, finds the problem rather interesting. Negal’s “What Is It Like to Be a Bat?” proposes a number of arguments, one of them which states that the subjective approach to the mind-body problem…

Words 1733 - Pages 7

Philosophy 2500 Essays

we are having and how our body operates in our daily life. Therefore, many philosophers, psychologists, religionists or even mathematicians, and sciences have been actively trying to define the nature, attributes and affections of our brain/soul. There are many different views and perspectives on the soul and the mind-body problem, such as materialism, physicalism, dualism, mysterianism and so on… So, how exactly do we understand humankinds, and all living beings as a whole? How exactly do we understand…

Words 2464 - Pages 10

Explain The Arguments Against Naturalistic Dualism

A Defense of Naturalistic Dualism Naturalistic dualism states in the mind-body problem that 1) the body is physical, 2) the mind is nonphysical, and 3) the mind and body causally interact. Additionally, naturalistic dualists question the factuality of statement four, which says that the physical (body) and nonphysical (mind) cannot causally interact according to physics. Taking a stance on naturalistic dualism, I believe subjective experiences and consciousness exist. I will address arguments…

Words 1316 - Pages 6

Essay on Can Substance Dualism Be Defended

physical. There is a few articles and though experiment that supports this theory. As an example, Thomas Nagel (1974) characterizes the problem of qualia for physicalistic monism in his article "What is it like to be a bat?” Nagel argued that even if we knew everything there was to know from a third-person, scientific perspective about a bat's sonar system, we still wouldn't know what it is like to be a bat. A thought experiment proposed by David Chalmers is the Zombie Argument. The basic idea is that…

Words 1917 - Pages 8

Tom Regan Animal Rights

As a result Regan has come under the scrutiny of many other philosophers who declare his stance a contradiction of his own beliefs. Regan rebuts critics by explaining how a special circumstance justifies a change in decision without compromising his overall stance. Regan argues that animals have inherent value and rights, yet he believes that the dog should be cast from the lifeboat in the given situation. In order to…

Words 1398 - Pages 6