Transplant Discrimination Essay

Submitted By Alexana23
Words: 858
Pages: 4
Open Document
The case that I decided to do further research on is the case about discrimination in transplant patients. In my previous documentation in regards to the case of African Americans and kidney transplants many points regarding ethical and legal issues were mentioned. There are different points of views in regards to this topic and in some cases they may just be an opinion but what happens when we really do start to see a pattern of possible discrimination. Has discrimination gone as far as impacting the healthcare organization and how transplant patients are selected? As I investigated more and more the issue, I found that discrimination in transplant patients is not only based on ethnicity.
In an article about organ transplant and discrimination by Peter Byme, consultant psychiatrist, he points out how treatment should be available to everyone. During the first 11 years of a heart transplant program in Montreal, 226 transplants were completed and 28 people were denied the procedure on the basis of psychiatric diagnosis. Basically many patients were being denied full transplant treatment because they had mental retardation. Denial of transplant on the basis of schizophrenia or non-compliance violates the Americans with Disabilities Act. A New Jersey Assembly committee has advanced a measure to end organ transplant discrimination based on mental or physical disabilities. The legislation stems from an incident involving a three year old Stratford, New Jersey girl. She reportedly was refused candidacy for a kidney transplant by a doctor at a Philadelphia hospital because she suffers from the developmental disability, Wolf-Hirschorn syndrome. Tom Baffuto is executive director of The Arc of New Jersey. He says being turned down for an organ transplant because of disability is appalling. "We are well aware that the number of those in need of transplant far outweighs the number of organs available. However, distribution must be fair and non-discriminatory.
To make matters worse the discrimination in transplant patients does not stop here. There has also been discrimination against elderly patients who may be on a transplant waiting list. The UNOS (United Network for Organ Sharing ) wants to dictate whether a name stays on the transplant list or gets dropped. FOX News and the Washington Post are reporting that the healthier, younger patients will be getting the good kidneys for transplant first. If this passes, people who have been on the list for several years and are now over 50 will be hard pressed to get a donor kidney. Is this fair? Some bioethicists and transplant surgeons say yes. Others worry that people will stop donating the kidneys. If people who need kidneys age 50 and over are going to be dropped, will they still want healthy kidneys donated from 50 year olds? Others like Lainie Friedman Ross, a University of Chicago bioethicist and physician, say that people age 50 and older will never see the good kidneys from donors aged 35 and under if this goes into effect. Ross says that people in their 50s and 60s can live another 20 years with a good donor kidney (Tomfeld). Then there is the case of discrimination based on race. African Americans have a higher prevalence of hypertensive renal disease and represent a high percentage of patients on the transplant waiting list, yet the percentage of those that receive transplant organs is much lower compared to white transplant patients which receive organs.
However information produced by the Institute of Human Values in Health Care points out some facts that may give valid reasons to why African Americans are receiving
Show More

Related Documents: Transplant Discrimination Essay

Vulnerable Population Paper

not exist for certain vulnerable populations, such as slaves, women and blacks/colored people, until specific legislation was passed to protect these populations, i.e., emancipating the slaves, granting women the right to vote, and prohibiting discrimination based on race, color, religion, and national origin (Stone, 2012). Equality is still far from the reality in the U.S. today, let alone equity. When people are making decisions regarding health interventions and health policies, they can be influenced…

Words 1201 - Pages 5

Kidney Transplantation In Ethnic Groups Essay

Abstract Renal transplants are successful alternative to dialysis, however ethnical minorities have less access to renal transplantations and higher graft rejections. There are many factors that contribute to this health disparities in ethnic minorities. Lifestyle, immunologic factors, and geographic have an effect on the post-transplantation graft rejection within ethnic group. Ethnical minorities in the United States (US) have less access to kidney transplants; the national waiting…

Words 615 - Pages 3

Healthcare Law Unit I Essay

that is shown to be harmful, or refusing to provide a treatment that has not been shown to be effective. The principle of justice means that all patients are treated equally regardless of their ability to pay for treatment or not, and without discrimination of any kind. For example, a long term care (LTC) facility was concerned that some of its residents were at increased risk for advancing illness by continuing to smoke cigarettes. The facility enacted a policy that prevented all facility residents…

Words 2035 - Pages 9

The Death of Cloning Essay

Derrick Alba - May 18, 2004 Human Cloning: Speech #3 Part 1 (Pro) Thesis: The subject of Human Cloning is a controversial issue. Introduction: On one hand there are benefits in terms of scientific and medical research and applications. On the other hand there are ethical, legal and moral implications attached to human cloning. Preview: In the first part I will go over some of the types of human cloning and their benefits in terms of science and medicine while in the second part, Brian…

Words 994 - Pages 4

RIP System Ethical Dilemmas

The RIP system is a tremendous help in the emergency room. When there are numerous patients in need, the RIP system comes in handy by giving dire information to the doctors. Some think that the RIP system is unethical because it prompts doctors to not try to save a patient that is close to death. The RIP system is a necessity in the emergency room because of just that. William E. Thompson and Joseph V. Hickey wrote an incredibly informational essay about the RIP system in the article “Medical Technology…

Words 693 - Pages 3

Martin Luther King Jr Greed Quotes

they are a shell full of selfish desires and suffering. For some it is inevitable. But for some it is a reason to stand up and fight. Unfortunately the society in the middle of the 20th century was unfair and corrupt. Many people were victims of discrimination,fortunately there was one man that made a large impact on the United States point of view on other people's. “Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate;only love can do that”. The quote and the accomplishments…

Words 417 - Pages 2

Genetic And Reproductive Sciences

of stems cells. Stem cells are utilized to cure various types of diseases, which will result in massive amounts of live saved. Society will gain a well of knowledge regarding stem cells, stem cell transplants can offer benefits for those suffering from Parkinson’s disease and a stem cell transplant may help society discover a…

Words 1433 - Pages 6

Final Exam Essay

proper manager to manage the dinner. So these are the possible reasons which could make the dinner menu costlier than lunch menu. 4. A prominent hospital in New England decided in 1980 to turn down a request by staff surgeons to perform heart transplants. The general director of the hospital objected to the statement that this decision was "based largely on cost considerations." On the contrary, he insisted, "the decision was based largely on the limited physical resources and highly trained personnel…

Words 1437 - Pages 6

HRM 423 Essay

CHAPTER 1: First the Forest, then the Trees: An Overview of Employment and Labor Law INTRODUCTION Chapter one introduces the student to foundations of labor and employment laws and how political, social, and economic conditions have contributed to the rise and fall of 1) government intervention in the employer/employee relationship, and 2) the influence of organized labor. Historical examples date back to the New Testament of the Bible and should enlighten the student to the fact that the…

Words 4218 - Pages 17

Essay on A Day In the Life

should fire Ms. Smith, is that cancer is covered under the American’s with Disability Act. She is a female which makes her fall under the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act and the fact that she is 58 years of age so she is covered under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act. (Popejoy, 2006) Emily Lessiker was one of three final candidates for an Auditor 1 position and just informed Rob Peterson that if she is chosen for…

Words 2083 - Pages 9