Essay Vietnam War and Story

Submitted By haydenholland
Words: 3731
Pages: 15
Open Document
Redefining Truth in Tim O’Brien’s The Things They Carried
By: Rose Monahan
May 2011
The Pennsylvania State University In an interview with Tobey C. Herzog, Tim O’Brien discussed the merits of truth by saying, “You have to understand about life itself. There is a truth as we live it; there is a truth as we tell it. Those two are not compatible all the time. There are times when the story truth can be truer, I think, than a happening truth” (120). Many literary scholars have struggled with the “truth” in one of O’Brien’s most famous works, The Things They Carried, a collection of twenty-two tales on the Vietnam War that stand alone just as strongly as they tie together. Although O’Brien is a Vietnam War veteran, unwillingly drafted in 1968 and serving until 1970, he purposively fictionalizes the war experience throughout The Things They Carried while simultaneously insisting that the essence of the work is true, a notion that many scholars question.
Teasing out which experiences O’Brien describes are true, which are folklore, and which are imagination would be a near impossible task because many of the tales mix. Rather, the importance of O’Brien’s work is his employment of metafiction narrative as a representative vehicle for the Vietnam War. Countless war stories have been published, particularly on the Vietnam War, and the impact or influence of these works greatly depends on the literary genre chosen to tell them. Although many critics1 have commented on O’Brien’s reinterpretation of “truth,” the necessity of metafiction to establish a reinterpretation has yet to be adequately explored. In this essay, I will discuss the use of metafiction and its ultimate accomplishment—redefining what is “true”—within O’Brien’s Vietnam War story, The Things They Carried. To begin, the definition of metafiction must be considered. Patricia Waugh, considered a leading expert on postmodernist literature, has written in her work Metafiction: the Theory and Practice of Self-Conscious Fiction, “Metafiction is a term given to fictional writing which self-consciously and systematically draws attention to its status as an artefact in order to pose questions about the relationship between fiction and reality” (2). Writers of metafiction, such as O’Brien, openly consider the relationship between fiction and memoir, often distrusting memory to accurately depict an event. While the author draws on many factual events or details, much of the work is also purely invented, and the author will frankly state that the work is not true. For example, The Things They Carried contains the warning, “This is a work of fiction. Except for a few details regarding the author’s own life, all the incidents, names, and characters are imaginary.” Yet, the true elements invoke the feeling of an autobiography, memoir, or other type of nonfiction. For instance, the central character and narrator of The Things They Carried is named Tim O’Brien (like the author), is a Vietnam War veteran in his late forties who is now a writer (like the author), and has published the book Going After Cacciato (also, like the author). These are clearly more than “a few details.” The distinction between Tim O’Brien, the person, and Tim O’Brien, the character, is difficult for the reader to balance, and ultimately, raises the question of what is fiction and what is reality. As the reader attempts to untangle the intertwined relationship between fiction and nonfiction, the author of a metafiction will comment on the writing of the piece. In the case of O’Brien, his comments remind the reader that his stories are invented. For example, before divulging into a gruesome story of a soldier slowly killing a baby water buffalo, O’Brien writes, “This one does it for me. I’ve told it before--many times, many versions--but here’s what actually happened” (78). By admitting that the story has been told in several ways, O’Brien is admitting the story has been fictionalized. Even
Show More

Related Documents: Essay Vietnam War and Story

Vietnam War and Story Essay

So by having a story that casts doubt on the novels veracity, he is obliging the reader to think about these questions. The book is 'about' the Vietnam war, at least it uses the war as a platform, and the war itself does raise huge questions about truth and fact, about the use of propaganda and misinformation and about the credibility of politicians and military leaders. 1. I think the story Rat tells is even more compelling because it has elements of fantasy in it. Fantasy is made to draw people…

Words 621 - Pages 3

The Role Of Story Telling In The Vietnam War

survive in and out of the war. However, telling stories to just themselves wasn’t always enough for some especially once they returned home. Not all those who returned could handle returning to life before war. Not all soldiers were like Norman, unable to cope with civilian life. That many were able to express their emotions through story telling made the transition back to home much easier. “Stories the narrator suggests, can heal the traumatized veteran of the Vietnam War and provoke an amnesiac…

Words 141 - Pages 1

Strength Of Feelings During The Vietnam War

Throughout the Vietnam War, the strength of feelings from the United States were portrayed thoroughly. This portrayal of emotion became so widespread that they were eventually translated into stories, movies, songs, and more. There are countless stories about the Vietnam War, whether they’re told from the account of real Vietnam War veterans or what the media saw the Vietnam War as. Although it may seem as if every story is told from the same account since it’s all about the same war, these stories begin…

Words 676 - Pages 3

Things They Carried Reflection

make the book a work of fiction. In addition, the novel presents many stories that are not known to be true. Therefore, The Things They Carried expresses true events but is transformed into a work of fiction. In the book The things they Carried by: Tim O’Brien, the author exaggerates about issues that impacted soldiers which makes the novel an inaccurate representation of history. The chapter “Enemies” , the author tells a story about a soldier who had beaten up and broke another soldier's nose…

Words 1311 - Pages 6

Historical Analysis Essay

Samuel Spence 4/20/2014 Professor Dunick EGL 1020 The short story “ The Things They Carried” by Tim O’Brien he wrote this story pertaining to the Vietnam War. The war actually changed to mindset of Tim O’Brien and it gave him even more of a reason to write about it. The Vietnam War drafted many 18 year olds to fight for their Country, being though most haven’t ever touched a gun. This story displayed from the young soldiers a physiological loss of innocence. Also the emotionally…

Words 1156 - Pages 5

Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

Tim O’Brien, Vietnam War veteran, perhaps more than any other author gives eloquent and contrary voice to American involvement in war. From his own experiences in Vietnam, O’ Brien wrote a series of anti-war theme novels, including his acclaimed 1987 short story “The Things They Carried,” considered one of the top 100 short stories of the twentieth century (e.g., John Updike and Katrina Kenison, eds., The Best American Short Stories of the Century, New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 1999). In his…

Words 770 - Pages 4

Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried

book called "The Things They Carried" which was about a Vietnam war. It was the longest battle in U.S history. Since the U.S. couldn't get control of a South Vietnam and eventually North Vietnam took control of South Vietnam. The Vietnam war occurred in the year 1959 and ceased in the year 1975. There was a conflict between the U.S and communist government. The main idea of this war was to prevent the expansion of communism in Asia and Vietnam. The combat was viewed by most Americans as the journalists…

Words 244 - Pages 1

Lieutenant Puller's A Fortunate Son

were on duty in Vietnam” (CITATION). One of these soldiers was Lieutenant Lewis B. Puller. Lieutenant Puller was the son of a highly decorated marine general. During Lieutenant Puller’s time in Vietnam he led his company on a search operation where he was injured. His injuries included loss of both legs, fingers on both hands, and he shell fragments covering his body. Lieutenant Puller wrote an autobiography titled A Fortunate Son that accounted his time in Vietnam. By reading this story the reader learns…

Words 422 - Pages 2

Muhammad Ali's Song 'Lyndon Johnson Told The Nation'

we’ve got no jobs to give you here, so we are sending you to Viet Nam”” . Which describes sending someone to war to war who didn't want to go to war. The story of Muhammad Ali's protest against going to war fits perfectly with the song in my opinion. He didn't want to go to the war because he probably wanted to focus more on his boxing career, instead of fighting an unjust war; declaring himself a “conscientious objector”. This earned him a prison sentence (which was later overturned…

Words 585 - Pages 3

Tim O Brien's The Things They Carried Essay

As we conclude the novel “The Things They Carried”, Tim is trying to write these stories as a way in which he remember these people during the Vietnam War and that these stories that the author was speaking were fictional. When the author, Tim O Brien defines “courage”, he was using it as a paradox in which he was a coward for leaving in which he didn’t want to go into the war in the first place. He was being a scaredy-cat by how he was running away. However, in “Speaking with Courage”, he was…

Words 467 - Pages 2