Virginia Reels Essay

Submitted By Amanuel-Zewdie
Words: 1095
Pages: 5
Open Document
Virginia Reels

These are trying times for the FFV's (Founding Fathers from Virginia). During the 1960s Bernard Bailyn, Gordon Wood, and Jack P. Greene pointed out that, far from composed, confident constitutionalists calmly orchestrating a reasoned rebellion against British tyranny, Virginia leaders were an anxious, uncertain, tentative lot. In the 1980s Rhys Isaac found these same Virginians besieged by an evangelical counterculture, while T. H. Breen pointed out that George Washington and his friends were failed tobacco planters deeply, even desperately, in debt to British merchants. Thus well before DNA testing linked Thomas Jefferson to his slave, Sally Hemings, it looked like Jefferson and his fellow Virginia leaders, far from men fit for marble monuments, in fact had feet of clay.

Woody Holton joins this revisionist chorus in his fine new book, Forced Founders. Like his predecessors, Holton portrays Virginia's leaders as desperate men who became convinced that they had to do a desperate deed: declare independence. Where Holton moves beyond his predecessors is the large and colorful cast of characters he includes in this story. Jefferson and Washington are indeed here, as are Isaac's evangelicals and Breen's British merchants, but so, too, are Shawnees and Privy Councilors, Cherokees and common folk, slaves and colonial governors. All of them, in one way or another, played a crucial role in pushing Virginia down the road to 1776.

The structure of Holton's deeply-researched work is both topical and chronological. An opening section, "Grievances, 1763-1774," traces how natives resisting colonial expansion combined with British officials bent on avoiding another expensive Indian war to frustrate Virginia's many land speculators while those same Virginians, as tobacco planters and slaveowners, were also deeply upset by imperial trade policy. A second part looks closely at the colony's trade boycotts of 1769 and 1774. Next Holton chronicles how slaves and common farmers, in different ways, so frightened the Virginia gentry in the mid-1770s that they had, it seemed, no choice but to declare independence in hopes of regaining control of the situation. A final section considers the fractious "Spirit of the People" in 1776 and ponders the consequences Virginia's independence had for all of the peoples involved. If the topical arrangement is sometimes repetitious, it nonetheless serves to connect this gloriously motley crew to the book's central argument.

Holton is refreshingly, even disarmingly, modest in his claims for that argument. He does not insist that Virginia's story can be applied to other colonies (though he occasionally suggests parallels). He does not assert that Indians, or small farmers, or slaves, or any one group caused the Revolution; rather, a "web of influence" "indirectly," often "inadvertently," "helped" or "powerfully influenced" the course of events (pp. xvii, xviii, 205, 206). Nor can he claim complete originality in his treatment of Indians or slaves. Readers of Colin Calloway, Gregory Evans Dowd, Richard White, and others will find some that is familiar here, as will those acquainted with work on slave resistance by Ira Berlin, Sylvia Frey, Philip Morgan, and Peter Wood.

What Holton does accomplish, however, is to weave these various strands into a single interpretative fabric of considerable persuasive power. Who would have thought to link the Virginia assembly's 1769 petition to British authorities for a land grant in Kentucky with that same body's 1772 petition for an end to the slave trade? Yet Holton shows how both initiatives aimed at "more control over a group of nonwhite Americans, . . . sought to change government policies that had harmed free Virginians economically . . . [and] tried to prevent smallholders from obtaining crucial elements in tobacco production -- Indian land and African slaves --without paying a member of the gentry for them." Finally, "[i]n both cases, the
Show More

Related Documents: Virginia Reels Essay

Dance In The 1700's

As stated on Encyclopedia Virginia “being a skilled dancer was an indication of good breeding” (Dance during the Colonial Period, n.p). People would fit in due to the fact that they knew how to dance, and knowing how to dance was a way to tell whether you had manners. Dance was a…

Words 1817 - Pages 8

Patrick Henry Speech

In almost every form of figurative language that was used, Henry would seem to portray the British as deceitful and misleading. He wanted to establish the British could no longer be trusted, and they were only feeding the colonies false hope. To reel in the audience even more, Henry uses more figurative language to refer to biblical verses and scriptures. Because the colonists were so devoted to their religion, they often used biblical references to come off as more relatable. With all this being…

Words 774 - Pages 4

Patrick Henry Rhetorical Analysis Essay

The Speech that Ignited the War Speeches usually persuade and motivate. They contain rhetorical devices that helps persuade the audience. In the “Speech to the Virginia Convention,” Patrick Henry persuaded colonists to go to war against Britain. He demonstrates this with his powerful diction, imagery, his credibility and allusions throughout his speech. As the speech commences Henry appeals to his audience with ethos. His credibility opens the audience's ears and he seizes the audience's attention…

Words 703 - Pages 3

In Search Of Our Mother's Garden By Virginia Woolf Analysis

In Alice Walker’s response essay, “In Search of our Mother’s Gardens” to Virginia Woolf's essay, “What if Shakespeare Had Had A Sister?” is a particularly obscure and an intriguing one. Alice Walker draws various instances where women of color encountered oppression and instances which her grandiloquent poetry shines. Walker appears to be displeased that Woolf did not include/focus the struggles that women faced who weren't white. This begs the question: What is the importance of including women…

Words 1083 - Pages 5

Ethal: Centuries and Chinese Ancient Inventions Essay

drilling boreholes. Deep drilling proved to be very profitable and useful as they drilled they reached and collected deposits of natural gas used for fuel purposes to produce salt. The first recorded deep drilling in the United States was in West Virginia the eighteen twenties. . Steven H. (April 18, 2009), 10 Great Chinese Ancient Inventions, Retrieved from http;//www.listverse.com/2009/04/ The principle of gunpowder was discovered by the Chinese in the first century AD. But it was not used for…

Words 817 - Pages 4

Atmosphere In Wharton's Ethan Frome

stopped, and the attendees begin leaving. But wait…. A dark haired man hops and skips onto the dance floor, and claps his hands. The music begins anew. The man takes the hand of pretty, young lass. She and the man begin to dance while the band plays a "Virginia…

Words 966 - Pages 4

To Bear Arms

powers national government and gives Americans the right to carry arms for the sake of their own protection (Nicholas). The U.S., claims that every citizen free, and to an extent, that freedom includes the right to bear arms. Richard Henry Lee, Virginia delegate to the Continental Congress and Initiator of the Declaration of Independence, said that it is essential that the people always have the right to carry arms and should be taught at a young age how to use them in order to preserve liberty…

Words 1706 - Pages 7

The Life of Mark Twain Essay

Samuel Langhorne Clemens was born in Florida, Missouri, on November 30, 1835. He was the son of Jane (née Lampton; 1803–1890), a native of Kentucky, and John Marshall Clemens (1798–1847), a Virginian by birth. His parents met when his father moved to Missouri and were married several years later, in 1823.[7][8] He was the sixth of seven children, but only three of his siblings survived childhood: his brother Orion (1825–1897), Henry, who died in a riverboat explosion (1838–1858), and Pamela (1827–1904)…

Words 2476 - Pages 10

Walt Disney Research Paper

It’s no doubt that creating a family oriented theme park based on popular, beloved cartoon characters and imagination was a good idea. From Cinderella’s castle to the famous Main Street, U.S.A, there’s something extraordinary lying around every corner. Walt Disney World, other wise known as “the happiest place on earth”, or the place “where dreams come true”, was founded by a man with a dream of creating a place where children and parents could spend time together while making amazing memories. However…

Words 2914 - Pages 12

Essay on Menstrual Cycle and Fanciful Isadora Wing

a heightened degree, Alice, the prototypical child, exhibits this same sense of confusion in wonderland. Within the framework of her adventures, reality and fantasy, sense and nonsense, sanity and insanity are juxtaposed to create a dream-like world. Erica Jong's repeated references to Carroll's work clearly link Alice to Isadora. Because of their repetitiousness, Isadora describes her conversations with Adrian “like quotes from Through the Looking-Glass.” In Wonderland, the Red Queen explains to…

Words 4678 - Pages 19