What Is The Death Penalty Ethical

Words: 922
Pages: 4
Open Document
The Death Penalty has been a rather controversial topic for decades. It is defined as “punishment by execution of someone officially judged to have committed a serious, or capital, crime” (Vaughn 250) It has set the ground for passionate debates all over America on whether it should be legal or not. Some Americans believe that capital punishment is unconstitutional because it violates fundamental right to life that all humans have. Others however, believe it is a fair action to be taken on these criminals. Why waste space and resources on criminals who have committed such unspeakable crimes? While opponents of the death penalty believe that it is unethical to end a human life or “play god”, defendants believe that it is completely ethical. …show more content…
Although all humans have the right to live, there are some cases that the right to live is not applicable. Murderers should not be given the chance to live if they have killed an innocent person. If a criminal robs an innocent person of their right to be alive, why should that criminal be allowed to live? It is completely acceptable to use the death penalty on such individuals because it is rather unfair that they get to be on this earth while the innocent person does not. Kant’s “an eye for an eye” point of view is exactly what makes the death penalty the ethical approach when dealing with a criminal who committed murder. The death penalty should not come as a surprise to criminals that intentionally took the life of an innocent person. By committing the crime, criminals are in a way accepting the aftermath and repercussions of their actions. Capital punishment should not be implemented as a tool for vengeance but rather in a fair manner that allows law enforcement to make a wise decision about a particular …show more content…
In a utilitarian perspective, the death penalty would be saving the lives of innocent people so it would be for the greater good of society has a whole. Not only will the citizens feel safer that such terrible criminals got what they deserved, but it will also shift the attention from the criminals to the victims that lost their lives to these monsters. Too much effort and energy is spent trying to decide on whether criminals should be kept alive when the answer is simple; if they take an innocent life, they don’t have the right to live. According to John Stuart Mill, a very famous utilitarian, “If punishing an offender would most likely produce the greatest balance of happiness over unhappiness compared with the other available options (not taking any action, publicly denouncing the offender, etc.), then the punishment is justified.” (Murtagh, part
Show More

Related Documents: What Is The Death Penalty Ethical

Proposition 34 Proposition 34

For rather long period of time there were arguments in favor or against death penalty as a measure of punishment. Proposition 34 displays another attempt to solve the situation. Arguments about death penalty have rather long history and as a result all possible aspects are taken into consideration. Despite that such approach does not make the decision easier but turns it into even more complicated. That is why it is important to focus on the Proposition itself rather than on the general aspects of…

Words 1096 - Pages 5

Van Dee Haag's Argument On The Death Penalty

The death penalty has been a hotly debated topic for as long as it has existed. It has survived many generations, all seemingly struggling with the moral complexity of justice. Some people support it because they believe it’s a fair punishment, while others — including myself – believe that it’s an excuse for revenge and question its effectiveness and morality. I strongly disagree with Van Dee Haag's position on the death penalty, which holds that it is an essential tool in the fight against horrible…

Words 843 - Pages 4

The Death Penalty Essay

The Death Penalty: Two Wrongs Don’t Make A Right Informal Logic: PHI103 instructor April, 2013 The Death Penalty: Two Wrongs Don’t Make A Right Some crimes that a person may experience in their lifetime are too horrible to put into words. How can one be punished for a crime so unthinkable? Capital punishment could be one way, but how ethical is it really? The first capital punishment recorded on our land was in 1608. The hanging of George Kendall in Virginia’s Jamestown colony was…

Words 1980 - Pages 8

Utilitarianism: The Consequences Of The Death Penalty

people must think what will be the consequences of their actions in a particular situation. If the consequences of their actions bring total good and happiness to everyone, then this is the right action and the one it should do (Shaw 2011). In this ethical issue, we should analyse the consequences of the death penalty for all the people, the positive and negative effect that it can bring to the society especially to the people who are involved. Positive consequences Death penalty will reduce the…

Words 504 - Pages 3

is the death penalty justice Essays

the death penalty justice? When I was I child and other kids hit me, I would retaliate because, it felt like the only way justice could be served was to do to them what he did to me. For this reason we have the death penalty. Is it really ethical to have a death penalty? Should it be up to the people to decide whether or not someone lives or dies, and is the death penalty even really effective at deterring crime? Over the years of all the people put on death row…

Words 838 - Pages 4

Death Penalty Essay

Death Penalty From ancient time death penalty is an issue that people want to solve. People allege that guilty people may realize their crime and become better people on this world. Despite of democracy in some countries, the government is able to punish with death penalty which is sometimes might be so violent. When one thinks about specific county execution numbers may be small but think about the world. I believe to kill someone for a robbery or trivial crimes are unfair and useless. However…

Words 500 - Pages 2

Punishment And Death Penalty Essay

Death Penalty Professor Shah April 8th 2015 Killing does not solve killing Capital punishment or the death penalty is a legal process whereby a person is put to death by the state as a punishment for a crime. The judicial ruling that someone be punished in this manner is a death sentence, while the actual enforcement is an execution. Crimes that can result in a death penalty are known as capital crimes or capital offences. 58 countries maintain the death penalty in both law and practice. It as…

Words 1639 - Pages 7

Cruel And Unusual Punishment Research Paper

Secondly, Death penalty is cruel and unusual punishment. There are alternative form of death penalty we can sentence them to their rest of the life at the prison which means life without parole. Not only that number of innocence had been convicted so there were nothing written sentence on the constitution to sentencing the innocence people. Nevertheless, it does not mean that they are free from their cases, every action there was equal and opposite reaction so if you committed some kind of crime…

Words 426 - Pages 2

Capital Punishment In Furman's Death Penalty Case

William Henry Furman, a case that would change the enforcement of and views on the death penalty for a long time to come. Furman was burglarizing a home in Georgia when suddenly he fell. His gun fired and killed the homeowner almost immediately. Shortly after this incident, Furman was sentenced to death by the state of Georgia because the court believed that since he was burglarizing the home at the time of the death, he was to be charged with murder, not manslaughter. Furman appealed this decision…

Words 1924 - Pages 8

Death Penalty Essays

Death Penalty Death penalty or Capital Punishment is a legal process where the person who had committed the heinous crime of murder is sentenced to death by the state, as a means of punishment for what they’ve done. In ancient times most countries uses this method not only for a means of punishment for murder, but as a general punishment for anyone who had committed any type of crime. At that time the people who use this method the most are those who practices religion, although it isn’t justified…

Words 3812 - Pages 16