What Is The Lost Art Of Discipline

Submitted By kerryharris1985
Words: 1244
Pages: 5
Open Document
Media Analysis
‘The lost art of discipline’ By Kevin Donnelly

This paper investigates the messages about education to be found in the media article ‘The lost art of discipline’ by Kevin Donnelly. The article concentrates on how to overcome student disadvantage by suggesting the resolution can be found in a rigorous discipline based approach. Donnelly argues, “the students suffering in terms of result”, the low retention rate of teachers as well as the declining rank of the Australian education system on the world stage is due to the lack of discipline in school and family environments (2014, para.9).

Donnelly’s ideological understanding of the failing system is due to the loss of discipline and values. In Donnelly’s (2014) view, schools and families are identified as being the source of dissatisfaction and “the real problem” with the education system (para. 2). He believes the main issue for disadvantage students is disruptive classrooms. Thus, regardless of socio-economic background, school funding or marketization of schools, Donnelly specifies that “badly behaved students and poorly managed classroom” as the main determinant for failing student outcomes (2014, para. 7).

The articles preferred discourse is summarized in the headline, ‘The lost art of discipline’ (Donnelly, 2014). Here discipline is defined as being lost and with the inclusion of ‘art’ insinuating it is something of high value and skill. Thus, this line of questioning is preferred throughout the article as the author’s preoccupation with correlating badly behaved students with academic results is reinforced with research statistics and statements.

His claim that ‘the problem with badly behaved students and disruptive classrooms across Australian schools is not new’ (Donnelly, 2013) is supported through the use of OECD statements and other studies. The results are used to provide substance to his argument, as it compares Australia to international high-achieving schools such as Finland, South Korea, Singapore, Japan and China. The inclusion of OECD statements positions it as an authoritative voice that speaks for education therefore provides an air of objectivity to Donnelly’s criticism. In the initial part of the article, the author uses concrete statistics that unfavorably rank Australia in order to emphasise his point. This is evident in the following extract:

“Australian classrooms were ranked 34th out of 65 countries in a recent OECD survey that asked 15 year old students to describe the levels of noise and disorder, the time it takes them to start working, whether they are able to work uninterrupted and whether they listen to the teacher” (Donnelly, 2013, para. 3).

This statement works to exaggerate school factors, which is established further with the inclusion of additional research. Again, the next study compares Australia to other countries however Donnelly has favored statements instead of statistics to establish his discourse. The statement uses vague and sensationalist language, which fails to clarify the exact predictions of the research. In addition, he attempts to show he didn’t come to this conclusion himself, however ultimately he did, as he paraphrased the remaining part of the statement in his own words. The is witnessed in the following statement:

“A 1997 study carried out by the Australian Council for Educational Research, involving 45 countries concluded ‘Australian ranks among the top handful of countries’ in terms of badly behaved students and poorly managed classrooms” (Donnelly, 2014, para. 7).

Together, these two studies construct a discourse on Australian schools and parents, which establishes them as opposition groups to the Australian education system. Initially the discourse represents teachers as a victim, due to the issue being presented as the core contention why teachers were leaving the profession. Whereas, the latter position undermines teachers’ professional practice and questions their
Show More

Related Documents: What Is The Lost Art Of Discipline

Media Analysis In Malaysia

Essay: MEDIA ANALYSIS IN MALAYSIA (NEWSPAPERS) INTRODUCTION Newspapers are essential in everyone’s daily life as it is the main source of news since the olden days before the television was invented. Without the newspapers, where does the news come from? Particularly in Malaysia, there are several languages used in the country. The main languages used however are English, Bahasa and Mandarin. Each of these different languages have specially dedicated newspapers to the particular language.…

Words 4104 - Pages 17

In The Defense Of Media Analysis

Media does help in times of struggle for America. In order for America to successfully win a war it is important that media plays a big part. In the past, wars and struggles may have not been won if it had not been for media. This is why it is so important. To start off with, in "In the Defense of Media" the author explains why media played a big part in the Civil Rights Movement. The text specifically talks about how media showed people what was actually going on in their country rather than what…

Words 534 - Pages 3

Analysis Of Disability In The Media

In the media today, people with a disability are recognized as tragic heroes or as medical miracles. They are not often noticed for their intelligence or for their accomplishments. Charles A. Riley II, professor of journalism at Baruch College, wrote “Disability and the Media: Prescriptions for Change” in 2002. He describes how the media is portraying people with a disability as saints, rather than showing their human traits. He points out those celebrities that sustain a disability are seen as an…

Words 412 - Pages 2

Women'slut In Media Analysis

Media representations are the ways in which the media portrays certain groups, experiences, ideas, or topics from a particular ideological or value perspective. Media is a big effect on women and the way they portray themselves. In this article, “Should ‘Slut’ Be Retired?”, it talks about the word “slut” and how it is such a common word used nowadays to describe a woman who is or portrays herself as too sexual. The “correct” way women should be is that they must “Police themselves and remain minimally…

Words 1175 - Pages 5

Social Media Analysis

. The use of social media increases the level of empathy in individuals and thus, they become more supportive than they were initially. Therefore, this kind of connotes that those who are more social in real life are those who use social media networks more. Also, there is the advantage of increased social connectedness which is enjoyed as a result of the speed in which information is shared and the extent to which it is spread. However, the problem in this is that the information that becomes shared…

Words 1305 - Pages 6

Gun Violence And Media Analysis

control has had steady media coverage over the last years, but what has changed is the amount of media attention dedicated to this issue and how that framing has respectably changed with time. Although more than 30,000 people die from firearm homicide and suicide each year while another 80,000+ are wounded, gun violence is rarely at the top of the US public political agenda (McGinty). When a horrific act of violence occurs such as a mass shootings occur, that is when news media coverage is at an all-time…

Words 1772 - Pages 8

Essay Media Comparison Analysis

Media Comparison Analysis The immigration reform is one of the most controversial issues in the media today. After many decades of dispute, both Democrats and Republicans believe an immigration reform shall finally pass through this year. Since the midway elections are coming up, Republicans from the House are willing to comply with President Obama to make an immigration policy reform because Republicans want to gain more votes. In the 2012 election, candidate Mitt Romney only received 20% of…

Words 1191 - Pages 5

Social Media Analysis

monitoring social media for insight into political processes and as an instant indication of "public sentiment" rather than waiting for press releases (Thorsen 2013). The primary purpose of news has not changed, however, social media has impacted the way people interpret news and act upon it. The increasingly active role of audiences in news creation is changing the traditional roles between media and journalists and their readers (Stanoevska-Slabeva 2012). Before the phenomenon of social media and Web 2…

Words 1477 - Pages 6

Crime And Media Analysis

How the media constructs the crime, the words they use, the information they include and the statements they comprise all control the impact of the crime. Both these crimes I decided to explore were constructed differently within the media. They are different in the simplest sense of the extremeness of them. The gang robbery was focused on much more heavily than the tenant fraud crime within the media. The gang robbery was explored in a variety of newspapers…

Words 1447 - Pages 6

Media report analysis Essay

ASSIGNMENT ONE MEDIA REPORT ANALYSIS (20%) Students are required to select one of media report from the three reports provided on Blackboard under the assessment folder. Students are required to identify and analyse the legal issues arising in their chosen report through answering a series of questions. Students need to apply a similar approach to that used in the Topic 1 case study, ‘The Coffee Shop’, to their chosen media report. Format of assignments Assignments cannot be handwritten…

Words 1176 - Pages 5