Who Uses Quotations Anymore?

Submitted By mcgovern27
Words: 1129
Pages: 5
Open Document
Who Uses Quotations Anymore? Nowadays, literature has seemingly lost its popularity. According to the National Endowment for the Arts, nearly half of Americans do not read books at all, and those who do, average only six per year (Shriver). You would think that literary writers would be bending over backwards to attempt to win over readers and make their work straightforward and inviting, but they are not. Someone must have issued a memo stating that cool writers do not use quotations in dialogue anymore, and sent it to authors as different as James Frey, Evan S. Connell, Ward Just and others. Showing that the use of quotes in literature is faddish, vague, eventless, and effortful and proving that quotes themselves may not be as small as they appear on the page. By leaving it up to the reader to decide which lines are spoken and which are not, the quote-less fad fuels the widespread idea that popular fiction is fun while literature is challenging.
But, is the style always elegant? From Susan Minot's 1998 novel "Evening": “...But you see I've just been at dinner -- he glanced over his shoulder, then lurched forward -- in Boston with my great old friends -- the Beegins -- and I've only just heard of your mother's -- he pressed his chin into his chest -- misfortune and wanted to pay my respects. All those dashes simply replace one form of clutter with another.” (Shriver). What effect is this quote-free format supposed to have? Ideally, a minimalism that lends text a subtlety and sophistication. Cormac McCarthy could quite possibly be the most responsible for popularizing this custom. A passage from his 2005 novel “No Country for Old Men” illustrates this: “You could head south to the river. Yeah. You could Less open ground Less ain’t none He turned, still holding the handkerchief to his forehead. No cloud cover in sight.” (Shriver) To McCarthy’s credit, he has at least carved out his own style, which other writers have occasionally mocked. It is hard to imagine that his riveting, atmospheric novels would have any lower literary quality without the proper punctuation. It may be perceived like this: “we don’t hear any shouting; no one screams. Reading heated dialogue without the quotation marks is like watching chase scenes in “The Bourne Supremacy” with the sound off.” (Shriver) It just doesn’t quite have the same effect. McCarthy doesn’t mind insulting literary giants either. He spent most of his time with scientists rather than with literaries. Aside from writing, he separated himself from writers, and didn’t like to speak about his own work. He had this to say about Henry James and Marcel Proust: “I don’t understand them...To me, that’s not literature. A lot of writers that are considered good I consider strange.” (McMillan). James Frey is another author whose writing style is similar to that of McCarthy in that he uses a lack of punctuation in his literature. A big part of his literature titled “Pieces” is the fact that he does not use quotation marks to indicate conversation. Instead, he starts a new line each time. This gave his book somewhat of a confusing writing style that allowed the reader to better understand his version of the events. Frey’s writing style also includes capitalizing nouns randomly and repeating words throughout his text. “The Young Man came to the Old Man seeking counsel. I broke something, Old Man. How badly is it broken? It's in a million little pieces. I'm afraid I can't help you. Why? There's nothing you can do. Why? It can't be fixed. Why? It's broken beyond repair. It's in a million little pieces.” (Good Reads). Michelle Huneven omits quotations in her writing in an effort to separate herself from other novelists that maybe in her eyes aren’t as good. Skipping the quotation marks is a way for Huneven to show that her novels are not too accessible to just the ordinary reader. The readers must be willing to try to
Show More

Related Documents: Who Uses Quotations Anymore?

English 101 Paper 4

of what is good writing and what is bad writing threw me off guard. This question could be answered in many different ways, some simpler than others. Writing has little to do with skill, but more with perseverance and the person that it comes from. Simply put, good writers keep going while bad writers seem to quit at the sign of a road block. There is no real definition of what good writing can be. It can be seen differently through many eyes, but one thing I know that good writing comes from a person…

Words 824 - Pages 4

Personal Narrative Analysis

misconception that a fiction writer is allowed to block out all aspects of reality while writing. When most people picture a writer, they most likely imagine the stereotypical image of someone sitting alone at a desk typing away at the computer or writing in a notebook without any distractions. In this setting, the writer is alone and everything is silent except for the clicks of a keyboard. Although there may be some truth to this image, the popular belief that writing is a “completely solitary action”…

Words 1581 - Pages 7

Essay on Writing and Card Writers

Training/Educational Requirements: Writing experience preferred Median Salary: $35 to $200 per submission Job Prospects: Good Job Description Greeting card writers work to provide written copy for birthday, anniversary, sympathy, and other wishes. Though writing text for such cards is usually a freelance or contract position, for which the writer is hired only as needed, there are some experienced greeting card writers who may find a full-time job. It is important for greeting card writers not only to have the…

Words 1275 - Pages 6

Kurt Vonnegut Writing Style Analysis

Writing is an art, and like art people create it in different ways with different opinions on each piece made. These two authors, Neil Gaiman and Kurt Vonnegut, have two different views on the “rules of writing”. Although each authors set of eight rules could be said to have the same ideas, they are reaching two different kinds of audiences. Gaiman’s set of rules are about writing to please yourself as the writer, and to finish to find pride in it. On the other hand, Vonnegut’s set of rules are about…

Words 1015 - Pages 5

My Writing Assignment

to come to a realization that writing isn’t just required for english classes, but also for the outside world; college applications, resumes, scholorships. College requires you to critically analyze and think about not only yourself but also the external factors that surround us.Wether students realize it or not the external factors effect create certain mental inputs that create who they are as a writer and how they characterers as writers forms. The students writing identity and process goes furtherback…

Words 1900 - Pages 8

Travel Writing and Screenwriting Career Research Essays

Travel Writing and Screenwriting Career Research Report OUTLINE:  Introduction  Nature of the work  Working Conditions  Job Outlook  Education, Other Qualifications, and Advancement  Earnings  Benefits/Challenges  Personal Input/Conclusion  Sources of Additional Information Introduction Writing as a career can be divided into a numerous amount of fields pertaining to the profession. This report is assembled with respect to the two career choices, travel writing and screenwriting…

Words 1845 - Pages 8

MLA Bibliography: How To Read Like A Writer

Bunn, Mike. "How to Read Like a Writer." Writing Spaces: Readings on Writing. Volume 2. (2011): 71-78. MLA Bibliography In Mike's essay, he explains how to properly read educational pieces of literature. He becomes very detailed when explaining his process of analyzing literature, including its purpose, genre, type, context, and language. Throughout the essay, he describes how someone analyze an essay. In the last couple of sections, he gave good solid examples of analyzing his own work. He…

Words 293 - Pages 2

Becoming A Writer

believe I cannot honestly answer If I am a wonderful writer or if I am a terrible writer. I may think I did a really good job when I’m writing something when in reality it could be horrible. The reader is the one who can tell if they believe the quality of my writing is good or bad. Writing is not naturally given to me, therefore I find it really challenging. When I write I try my best I can and be happy with the final outcome. It takes a while to do my best and it may be still having quite a few…

Words 1078 - Pages 5

Technology's Impact On Writing: The Final Frontier?

Technology's Impact on Writing: The Final Frontier? Will my growth as a writer ever stop? Is technology’s impact on my growth as a writer the final frontier? Or will it just continue to be an old friend who continues to help me develop into a better writer? Honestly, I was never a great writer when it came to writing any essay. The prompts that I had to write about usually daunted and frustrated me because of their increasing difficulty and my deteriorating skills as a writer. I remembered that I…

Words 927 - Pages 4

Essay about dear america

ON WRITING: A MEMOIR of the CRAFT By Steven King Task#1: C.V. Steven King begins this book by revisiting his childhood to describe how he became what he is today. In the beginning section, he uses lots of literary elements to create clear and vivid pictures of his childhood. For example he writes, “The pain was brilliant, like a poisonous inspiration.” (19) He uses this simile to vividly describe being stung in the ear. One can almost feel pain in his or her ear from this description. Another…

Words 1122 - Pages 5