Why We Should Not Obey A Given Law

Words: 524

Pages: 3

Open Document

When is it justified, then, for the citizen to act as his own legislator, and to decide that he will or will not obey a given law?

In the first place, dramatic disobedience to the law by a minority may be the only effective way of catching the attention or winning the support of the majority Most classic cases of civil disobedience, from the early Christians to Gandhi and his supporters, exemplify this truth. Civil disobedience, like almost no other technique, can shame a majority and make it ask itself just how far it is willing to go, just how seriously it really is committed to defending the status quo.

SECOND, there is the simple but painful factor of time. If a man is holding you down on a bed of nails, it is all very well for a bystander to say that you live in a great country in which there are legal remedies for your condition, and that you ought, therefore, to be patient and wait for these remedies to take effect. But your willingness to listen to this counsel will depend, quite properly, on the nature of the injury you are suffering. …show more content…
A majority's complacent acquiescence in bad laws can undermine the faith of a minority in the power of democratic methods to rectify manifest evils; yet a vigorous democracy. Civil disobedience is not simply like other acts in which men stand up courageously for their principles. It involves violation of the law. And the law can make no provision for its violation except to hold the offender liable to punishment. This is why President Kennedy was in such a delicate position last spring at the time of the Negro demonstrations in

Real: Law and Sovereign Commands Essay

Austin This is very much a “law as fact” approach, intent on not confusing law with justice or morality. The pure description approach (just say what is out there) has a straightforward appeal: it seems logical to say what law is before asking whether it is good. Austin’s focus is on political relationships, because law rests on politics. It is true and often overlooked that law is a political arrangement and achievement. So, the way to understand law is to understand the politics. One might…

Words 1288 - Pages 6

Sample essay

citizens are subordinate to the state and its laws to such an extent that if a citizen ever disagrees with the state's laws or orders, he "must either persuade it or obey its orders," even if the latter amounts to suffering death. The implication for his own case is clear: Socrates had tried to persuade the court of his innocence and of the injustice of his execution (as detailed in the Apology), but he had failed; therefore, he argues, he must now obey the court and accept his death sentence--even…

Words 1578 - Pages 7

Plato and Socrates States Essay

easiest path, whereas one should choose the path a good and courageous man would choose, particularly when one claims throughout ones life to care for virtue” (45d, Crito,Plato). In response Socrates argues that it is not worth it to pay attention to the views of ignorant people but only listen to people with knowledge. To Socrates his concern is not what the people will think of him but whether or not escaping from prison is just or not. Socrates is a strong follower of the law and will never do anything…

Words 1368 - Pages 6

Should People Obey Seatbelt Laws

Should People Obey Seatbelt Laws? The debate on whether the United States should inforce seatbelt laws or not has been an ongoing topic. Do seatbelts honestly save people or are they just another way for the government to increase revenue? Although seatbelts are designed to prevent fatality, statistics show that they can also lead to injuries or even death. “On the promise of reducing highway fatalities and auto insurance rates, seat-belt laws began to pass in state legislatures throughout the…

Words 924 - Pages 4

Ethical Dilemmas In The Military

members of the service in order to avoid many problems. However,along with power, acts of abuse from the superior may potentially occur and ultimately instruct the subordinate to unfairly follow commands. With the ethical problem of following any order given, the importance of this dilemma is to comprehend that disrupting the superior and subordinate…

Words 2162 - Pages 9

Comparing Cannibalism And Theorized By Jean-Jacques Rousseau

someone should be eaten. One can assume that there is a chain of command within the group of space travelers or the use of a democratic vote to determine the path taken. Either way, the social fact in this situation would be starvation. The two debatable points are should we or shouldn’t we eat someone to survive. Under these constraints, the source theory would be true. Another jurisprudential justification of that would explain the events depicted in the fact pattern is whether the law of cannibalism…

Words 959 - Pages 4

Civil Disobedience Rhetorical Analysis Essay

gather large groups of people to do exactly what “civil disobedience” means to do. A civil and peaceful way of not following the laws that are in place. This idea of one honest man standing up to the government can change the government is one of Thoreau’s main ideas in his passage of “Civil Disobedience”. Thoreau shows this…

Words 1003 - Pages 5

Essay on If The Tape Of Your Life Could Be Rewound To The Exact Moment When You Made A Decision

to me free will is just an illusion. Why do I say that having free will is just an illusion? We are all human beings made up of molecules, we have to obey the laws of physics. Our brain is where we do our "thinking" and that to is made up of molecules. And the neurons and molecules in your brain are the product of both your genes and your environment. Everything that you think, say, or do, must come down to molecules and physics. If we truly had free will we would have to be able to get into our…

Words 561 - Pages 3

The Ethics And Consequences Of Following Military Orders

and to have that order carried out, however there are orders that are of such ethical dubiousness that they can and should be thoroughly questioned. In the following pages of this paper, the writer will attempt to show several ethical scenarios, encountered by a soldier, and how using various ethical theories, the soldier would handle them. Military members who fail to obey the lawful orders of their superiors risk serious consequences. Article 90 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice (UCMJ)…

Words 1676 - Pages 7

Essay on Ortance Of Following Orders And The Emphasis Of How It Applies To Unit Structure Including The Specialty Of A Soldier

The importance of following orders and the emphasis of how it applies to unit structure including the specialty of a soldier On Wednesday, 28 February 2015, I was given instructions and failed to do so by taking initiative and went to talk to my Platoon Sergeant SFC Taylor. I understand my mistakes and what they can cause that is why I am writing this essay about the importance of following order, with emphasis on how it applies to our unit and our specialty. Failing to follow instructions, no matter…

Words 2148 - Pages 9