You Are the Judge Essay

Submitted By chenz44

Words: 418

Pages: 2

Open Document

Legal Issue:
The ticket was purchased in the state of Washington with a clause in the contract stating that if a lawsuit arises from the purchase and/or cruise any lawsuits would be filed in the state of Florida.
Can the forum-selection clause in the Carnival Cruise Lines tickets be enforced?

Plaintiff’s Arguments:
Mrs. Shute purchased tickets to Puerto Vallarta, Mexico on Carnival Cruise Lines in the state of Washington through a travel agency. During the trip, Mrs. Shute slipped on a deck mat while on a guided tour of the ship’s galley and was injured as the ship was on its return voyage in international waters off the Mexican coast. Mrs. Shute filed a negligence lawsuit against Carnival Cruise Lines in the U.S district court in Washington, seeking damages. Mrs. Shute purchased the ticket in Washington, where she resides and filed the lawsuit in her home state.

Defendant’s Arguments:
Carnival Cruise Lines received payment from The Shute’s for the cruise to Puerto Vallarta, Mexico, prepared the tickets and mailed the tickets and a five page contract to the Shutes. In the five page contract the ticket contained a forum-selection clause designating the state of Florida as the forum for any lawsuits arising under or in connection with the ticket and/or cruise. Mrs. Shute was aware of the terms of the contract and filed a lawsuit in the state of Washington. Carnival Cruise Lines filed a motion for summary judgment, contending that the lawsuit could be brought only in a court located in the state of Florida, where the headquarters is located.

My Decision as the Judge:
Carnival Cruise Lines should prevail in

You Be The Judge Research Paper

You Be the Judge Read the following application essay. See if you can figure out this essay's strengths and weaknesses. Then keep reading to see our critique. The Essay From the time I was able to realize what a university was, all I heard from my mother's side of the family was about the University of Michigan and the great heritage it has. Many a Saturday afternoon my grandfather would devote to me, by sitting me down in front of the television and reminiscing about the University of Michigan…

Words 986 - Pages 4

You Be the Judge Essay examples

As we move into the twenty-first century we all know that healthcare is shifting. A vast majority of technology has taken over and a new healthcare reform is being put into place. Kaiser Permanente strives to keep up with the innovation and changes this world is bringing. There is an extreme amount of new realities, diversity, technologies, best practice, teamwork, and education Kaiser implements into every aspect of each individual job. The past couple of years Kaiser has experienced…

Words 322 - Pages 2

Can You Judge Characters By Their Names?

Can You Judge Characters by Their Names? While reading any type of literature, whether it is poetry, a short story, or a novel, one can make the connection that quite possibly the names of some characters are chosen specifically by the author to portray the character based on the meaning or gender of the name. I have always paid attention to names in a piece of literature just to see how certain characters’ names may portray what kind of character they are. Although not proven, it seems as if minor…

Words 1694 - Pages 7

The Minister's Black Veil: Do You Judge?

Do You Judge? People get judges every day. In the short story The Minister's Black Veil, by Nathaniel Hawthorne is about a man named Mr.Hooper wearing a veil and how that affects him with himself and the people around him. He was getting judged for something as simple a veil on his face. As we human we judge and get judged everyday.We are all guilty of doing it sometimes. Though we judge by the cover we should know what is going on. Mr.Hooper was a good man in the village, he was living in. He…

Words 704 - Pages 3

Essay about You Be The Judge Consumer Laws

Nick Prestigiacomo Prof. Brush Business Law You Be The Judge: Consumer Law In the bustling business world, daily use of misleading and unlawful actions are practiced in hopes of achieving success. From these practices, many negative repercussions are unfortunately the outcome. In this You Be The Judge case, Mr. Johnson is suing Mr. Dencell, the owner of a local cafe, for negligence that may have been responsible for the death of his grandfather, caused by Pulmonary Artery Disease. Prior to…

Words 724 - Pages 3

assess the view of the Marxists view of the family role Essay

injury claim and have seen you have occurred a serious back injury Mr Green whilst being in a car, you have claimed that Sally Brown caused the accident and that your loss of salary and expenses will roughly be around £50.000 pounds. As you have never had any involvement before in a legal case I will therefor go through the main stages and procedure’s that you will over go throughout the case. Firstly the solicitor will interview you about the incident and the claim you want to over go and follow…

Words 1026 - Pages 5

Sally Cade Prosecution

Prosecution: Your Honor, the Prosecution would like to call the witness: Sally Cade to the stand Judge: Bailiff please call the witness to the stand Bailiff: Witness, do you swear to tell the truth, only the truth and nothing but the truth. Sally Cade: I do Judge: The Prosecution may now begin its direct examination. Prosecution: Witness, please tell us what if Jhonny had displayed any aggressive behaviour to Mr. Sheldon before the crime? Sally Cade: Yes, I believe he had this growing aggression…

Words 611 - Pages 3

Questions On Criminal Law

SHOULD I APPEAL TO? You need to make sure that you should be appealing to the Court of Appeal and not to another court. Appealing against conviction You can only appeal against conviction to the Court of Appeal if you were convicted at the Crown Court. If you were convicted in the Magistrates’ Court, you need to appeal to the Crown Court (or possibly to the Administrative Court) and you should speak to the Magistrates’ Court for advice on how to appeal Appealing against sentence If you were sentenced…

Words 3830 - Pages 16

Reed Mcmarley Case Study

Bailiff Jake - Judge Steven - Prosecutor [The defendant Reed Mcmarley was immediately apprehended after giving his testimony to the responding officer at the scene of the crime. Mr. Mcmarly had chosen a bench trial and to be defending himself for murder of Mr. Rich in the second degree as an to attempt to show the type of person he is and furthermore to prove his innocence in the crimes to the Honorable Judge Barry Bee.] BAILIFF. The courtroom is now in session with the Honorable Judge Barry Bee…

Words 555 - Pages 3

Judge Stephen Walking Vs Harvey

Crimes committed: Breaking and entering, aggravated assault. Defendant gumshoe 40 yr old Was a detective for 20 years now a retired worker who helps around the neighborhood. Judge Stephen Walking was a top Harvard-educated lawyer recently elected to be a judge. There is no correlation to somebody named Stephen Hawking. Defense Attorney Phoenix Wright: A lawyer fresh out of law school ready to make his mark on the world with not much experience but very capable. Prosecuting attorney Harvey…

Words 629 - Pages 3