A COMPARISON OF Essay

Submitted By latenightcramsession
Words: 933
Pages: 4
Open Document
A COMPARISON OF
THE PRIMARY COLOURS LEADERSHIP MODEL AND THE SITUATIONAL LEADERSHIP MODEL

MNGT 5500.02 A New Approach to Leadership Spring I, 2013
Dr. David Pendleton and Dr. Benjamin Akande
Overview
While rational and logical, the Situational Leadership model presents as incomplete when compared with the Primary Colours Leadership model. The straightforward approach of Primary Colours means leaders and followers can more easily understand and apply the concepts. This leads to a much higher adoption rate. The plain language of the Primary Colours model lets leaders and followers concentrate on competencies and the core business purposes instead of learning a foreign language while mastering the tango.
Situational Leadership Theory is really the short form for "Hersey-Blanchard Situational Leadership Theory" and draws major views from contingency thinking. Situational leadership is a theory that says leaders should vary their style based on the changing needs of their followers. The key issues in when to vary the leadership style is follower maturity – the follower’s readiness to perform in work situations. Readiness is based on two factors – follower ability and follower confidence.

Pro's
• The theory has scales that a leader can use to give a "thumb in the wind" assessment of what leadership style to use
• Maturity and competence of the group are often overlooked factors in good leadership and it helps to focus on these
Con's
• The theory may not be applicable to managers as administrators or those with limited power but in structurally in a leadership position
• There are situations in which the theory may be less applicable such as those involving time constraints and task complexity
• Testing of the theory doesn't seem to bear out the predictions
• To have a successful outcome the leader must exhibit a high level of self-awareness and an acute ability to relate to the followers
• Testing of the Hersey-Blanchard Situational Leadership Theory so far has produced poor test results; more work is needed to show that the theory works
The Hersey-Blanchard situational leadership model identifies four leadership styles –
• S-1 telling – information flows from leader to followers only (do this)
• S-2 selling – leader attempts to convince followers by providing social and emotional support
• S-3 participating – leader shares decision making with followers
• S-4 delegating – leader assigns tasks to followers

Each style represents a different combination of task-oriented and relationship-oriented behaviors.
Four maturity levels of the group are posited by Hersey and Blanchard with letter designations:
• M-1: basic incompetence or unwillingness in doing the task
• M-2: inability to do the task but willing to do so
• M-3: competent to do the task but do not think they can
• M-4: the group is ready, willing, and able to do the task
In the situational leadership model, leadership effectiveness requires the correct match of style and follower maturity; the suggested match-ups are:
• telling style with low readiness
• selling style with moderate-high readiness
• participating style with low-moderate readiness
• delegating style with high readiness

In certain circumstances this theory may need to be thrown out the window. For example emergencies or wartime. In these circumstances there wouldn’t be time to assess followers maturity or willingness. If a group or team already has an agenda, the leaders actions may be less relevant the their ability to create change would be powerless. If followers willingness to do a task changes or the initial judgement of the leader is wrong quick adjustments by the leader are required.

Primary Colours leadership theory

Leadership proposition 1 builds on three overlapping pillars:
Strategic domain - Setting strategic direction
Interpersonal domain - Building and sustaining relationships
Operational domain - Delivering results
Leadership
Show More

Related Documents: A COMPARISON OF Essay

Holocaust Comparison

Comparison is an essential part of human thinking: something familiar serves as the standard by which we evaluate an unfamiliar topic. The Holocaust is seen as a paradigm of human-induced suffering and mass injustice. It is thus inevitable that in processing tragic events, the Holocaust is often used as a frame of reference. Despite the prevalence of Holocaust comparison, it remains a contentious issue. Those who disapprove raise concerns about Holocaust trivialization and the possibility of such…

Words 1350 - Pages 6

Frankenstein Comparison

Frankenstein, by Mary Shelley, is a dramatic horror story that takes place in 18th century Europe, in which Victor Frankenstein animates a monster who eventually seeks revenge against Frankenstein after witnessing the faults of mankind – specifically the faults of Frankenstein such as selfishness and abandonment out of fear. As the monster learns more about the world and begins to understand humans and human relationships with one another, he grows more and more depressed and angry. He realizes that…

Words 932 - Pages 4

Comparison Essay

Comparison Essay Amy Danek PHI/105 May 24, 2015 Eric Shark Comparison Essay Analytic philosophy is a broad category; it emphasized on clarity and argument. Some of topics that analytic philosophy targets are analyzing language, forming logical explanations, and supporting natural sciences (Mastin, Analytic Philosophy, 2008). An example would be analytical jurisprudence law; it focuses on the logical structure of law, tries to understand the real nature of law in the modern world, and rejects idealism…

Words 427 - Pages 2

Comparison Essay

Comparison Essay I have driven many different kinds of cars, from very slow cars like Jeep to very fast cars like B.M.W, since I got my driving license, but just two of them were very attractive for me. Kia Forte and B.M.W 235i are two well­known brands of cars in all over the world. Although both are very fast and suitable for an interesting driving, there is an ocean difference between their safety, quality of engine, and driving convenience. Although safety of both cars is better than old cars…

Words 430 - Pages 2

Comparison Essay

Daniel Bracho English 0307-4162 4/29/2013 Comparison and Contrast Essay Self-Employment is better than working for others In the current situation the country is going through, and especially in the current economy, jobs are increasily harder to find, and the ones available are bound to really rough competition, and poor hourly rates. Given this situation, self-employment has appeared as an attractive alternative for many people, as it is a valid way to bypass job position competitivity…

Words 545 - Pages 3

Comparison Essay

Flannery O’Connor’s “A Good Man is Hard to Find” and Alice Munro’s “Boys and Girls” both use symbols to highlight significant meanings in the characters’ lives. This essay will examine two differences and one similarity in the authors’ use of symbols: * O’Connor uses a gun to symbolize fear, whereas Munro uses a gun to characterize shame. * O’Connor uses a specific animal to signify death, while Munro uses a specific animal to represent freedom. * In both stories, the house symbolizes…

Words 1183 - Pages 5

Comparison Essay

all those equations, the outcome may not be what you are looking for. Here I am comparing whether or not to have the heat on in your household when living with your significant other. Yes, your preference is most likely going to overrule the comparison in fact but lets give it a whirl. What if I told you that having the heat on could change your every night and make it more or less desirable for your or their needs. Say you want to have your partner close to you, cuddling and snuggling you looking…

Words 521 - Pages 3

Comparison Essay

Comparison Essay ‘Disabled’ by Wilfred Owen and ‘Out Out’ by Robert Frost ‘Disabled’ by Wilfred Owen is about the topic of war and a young man joining the army, unaware of the consequences that would follow. Owen describes the gruesome realities of what war holds, using a range of graphic images which stick in the reader’s mind. ‘Out Out’ by Robert Frost is about a young boy who accidentally cuts his hand off with a saw while being distracted by his sister on a farm in America. Frost previously…

Words 2487 - Pages 10

Chinatown Comparison

Different places, different cities, and different people exist in our society. Our society is very diverse in the city of Los Angeles. One very interesting and specific ethnic neighborhood in the Los Angeles area is Chinatown. Chinatown is a well-known peaceful neighborhood that attracts many tourists, which I was able to visit for my project. I was fortunate to have met three special individuals who were very friendly and respectful. Exploring Chinatown was a great experience while doing some homework…

Words 1655 - Pages 7

Comparison Essay

Survival is a hard, but natural instinct for all humans. In the book, Night, by Elie Wiesel l, Night, the reader learns about the struggles Elie and his family faced during World War II. The struggles are also seen in the song “Red Sector A” by the band Rush. The novel and the song both express the importance of surviving during difficult times when one feels like giving up, as stated in the song, “All that we can do to help ourselves is to stay alive.” In Elie Wiesel’s novel Night, the beginnings…

Words 542 - Pages 3