A Midwife's Tale Essay

Submitted By Michael-Slattery
Words: 831
Pages: 4
Open Document
Laurel Ulrich: An Arnold Historian Through and Through

Michael Slattery

Making History
Dr. Prevost
September 7, 2014
Midwife’s Tale is the story of a late eighteenth century midwife living on the frontier in Maine, retold by a historian named Laurel Thatcher Ulrich. She uses the diary of the midwife, Martha Ballard, to tell a story in a way that John Arnold would approve of. Ulrich investigates the diary and events of the period in which the writing was done to recreate Martha’s story. Ulrich is also part of a movement in her time to bring women’s history in the 1700’s to light. Her hard work brings about stories that were hardly even thought of or heard. Also, the stories she brings to life are put out in ways that non-historian people can see and understand. She is a historian in every way that Arnold says in his book History: A Short Introduction.
Arnold believes history is an investigation and the entire story of Martha Ballard is created through investigation. In order for as much historical information to be found as is possible, a historian cannot only look at whatever they have in front of them. They must dig deeper and find connecting facts and information to tell the whole story. This historian first has to translate the diary into modern English. To do this she has to decrypt the writing in the actual diary that is written in cursive and crammed to fill each page with as much information as possible. This is seen when the documentary shows Ulrich going through sheets of paper that have each line or part of the diary separated out in print so she may go back and find patterns in the writings and then investigate the meanings behind the pattern. One of these patterns was the Scarlett Fever epidemic. Martha writes over and over that she has been called and stays overnight to take care of many people who have similar rashes and symptoms. Previous historians who looked at the diary missed out on this because they did not take the time to investigate deep enough into the cramped writing before giving up. Another even where investigation sheds light on something written is when Martha writes that one of her daughters has turned 18. It is seemingly unimportant but the sentence is included right after she states that a mill belonging to her husband was on fire. Intrigued by this fact, Ulrich investigates and finds out that there had been an epidemic in 1769 that claimed the lives of five of Martha’s children. This type of investigation into history aligns with chapters four and five. Especially chapter five where Arnold talks about how wider questions can be asked about society from records.
The next way that Ulrich proves to be an Arnold historian is her choice to look at the Ballard diary. The involvement of women in history prior to the twentieth century is seen mostly as small and insignificant. When Ulrich first goes to look at the diary others scoff at her and tell her that nothing will come of her work. She is not disheartened by this and continues her work. This goes along with Arnold’s view that history changes alongside societal changes from when the
Show More

Related Documents: A Midwife's Tale Essay

A Midwife's Tale Analysis

Laurel Thatcher Ulrich. A Midwife’s Tale: The Life of MArtha Ballard, Based on Her Diary 1785-1812. New York: Vintage Books, 1990. Pp 444. Paper $16.95. A Professor at Harvard specializing in Early American and Women's history, Laurel Thatcher Ulrich, argues for the importance of Martha Ballard’s diary as a historical primary source and the impact it has to the historical community in A Midwife’s Tale. For years the diary was barely acknowledged and disregarded as mundane, but according to Ulrich…

Words 630 - Pages 3

A Midwife's Tale Summary

In A Midwife’s Tale, Ulrich sets up her chapters in chronological order to coincide with the diary. Each chapter focuses on particular events that have happened in Martha’s life. Ulrich begins each chapter with excerpts from the diary and then analyzes and discusses…

Words 1033 - Pages 5

A Midwife's Tale Summary

In her book, ‘A Midwife’s Tale’, Laurel Thatcher Ulrich explores the social position of women in society and the subsequent change in their roles in early American society by studying the life of Martha Ballard. This book questions the impact that the Revolutionary War and the independence of the United States of America had on the lives of American women like Martha Ballard. Due to the restriction on Martha’s participation in the public economy, her exclusion and apathy toward the Revolution and…

Words 825 - Pages 4

The Protagonist Martha Ballard In A Midwife's Tale

In A Midwife’s Tale, the protagonist Martha Ballard lives during Colonial America when most women have minimal rights and less power than men. Since then, society as whole has changed and there has been great progress towards equal rights for women. Many great women during this period went unrecognized for their achievements and contributions to their community. However, when Ballard’s diary is dug up it brings her heroine-like attributes into light.…

Words 71 - Pages 1

The Midwife's Apprentice Character Analysis

I think that when most kids think about life in this time period, they think of fairy tales, as well as, knights and castles and royalty. Of course, with all of those things comes wealth. Fairy tales do not usually talk about the poor and unfortunate. In The Midwife's Apprentice, the main character, eventually known as Alyce, is a homeless orphan who owns nothing more than the filthy clothes that she wears. The first chapter details how she finds food and shelter every night, eventually sleeping…

Words 329 - Pages 2

Historical Perspectives On Birth: Martha Ballard

opposed to Ballard’s emparist approach, which involved herbal remedies, the male physicians were noted to implement “dramatic therapies” which were directly related to their status and fees (Ulrich, 1991, p. 56). For example, in the documentary A Midwife’s Tale, the male physician was seen administering medications which eradicated pain but ultimately slowed labor while Ballard’s methods allowed nature to take its…

Words 525 - Pages 3

Essay History assignment 1

Angelica Garcia History 3/22/15 Writing Assignment #1 In the story A Midwife’s Tale: The Life of Martha Ballard, Based on Her diary, 1785-1812 by Laurel Thatcher Ulrich I learned of about a woman named Martha Ballard. Reading about what she did is impressive, especially for her time period. If it weren’t for her diary we would not know about her many achievements and struggles that she overcame. Martha Ballard was a woman born into the 1700s. A woman who claimed a few titles a healer, a midwife…

Words 1098 - Pages 5