A Right to Die Essay

Submitted By bll0011
Words: 2740
Pages: 11
Open Document
Assisted Suicide: Should it be legal? During a visit to see your mother, she suddenly falls to the ground with no warning. 911 is called, and she is rushed to the hospital with the outcome looking very bleak. After tests are performed, it is discovered that your mother has a tumor the size of a golf ball in her brain which has progressed so that removing it would be no help. Chemotherapy will add approximately a year to her life, but the treatment is so expensive, and the side effects are so bad, that your mother is now questioning whether she wants to continue on with her life. Does she have the right to die? Or is that morally wrong? Despite the emotional pull of stories like this, I believe evidence leads to the conclusion that we should not legalize euthanasia or physician assisted suicide. Instead, our society should embrace a life-giving health care system that includes compassionate care for the dying, and educating patients about the right to refuse troublesome medical care. Before delving into euthanasia or physician-assisted suicide, it is first necessary to define these terms. There are two variations of euthanasia. Passive euthanasia is the removal of a patient from life sustaining machinery at their request and with full, informed consent. Active euthanasia is intentionally administering medications to cause a patient’s death at their request and with full, informed consent. Physician assisted suicide is a physician providing a prescription to a patient with the understanding that the patient intends to use the medication to commit suicide (Manning 3). However, whether a physician provides a lethal prescription or personally administers the lethal drug, the intent is the same-- the premature death of a patient.
Euthanasia did not always have the negative connotation that it does in America today. The ancient Greeks and Romans called it “voluntary death over endless agony” (Manning 6). In Athens, the magistrates of the city kept a constant supply of poison for anyone who wished to die. The Stoics recommended euthanasia when the person’s life was no longer in accordance with their individual needs. However, all ancient philosophers did not agree with the practice of euthanasia. The Pythagoreans opposed it because they believed the gods valued each life, and euthanasia was disrespectful. Plato also opposed suicide. Though he did not support the idea that the gods had the right to take life, he did believe that that life could only be ended in cases of imminent death (Manning 7). What started out as a “calm” debate quickly turned to hysteria when Christianity was developed. The religion took the Roman practices and turned them into martyrdom and since then, the belief has stuck with humanity (Uhlmann 68). So where does that leave us today? There are different legal statuses for physician assisted suicide and active voluntary euthanasia around the world today. In England, due to the Suicide Act of 1961, neither suicide nor attempted suicide is a criminal matter. However, it is illegal to assist in or devise a plan towards the suicide of another individual. Similar to the English model, no state in the United States punishes someone who has committed or attempted suicide, nevertheless 32 states and 2 territories have made it illegal to assist, cause, or promote suicide (Celocruz 377). The world, as a whole, has not accepted euthanasia as a universal good, however, some place have legalized it, such as Oregon and Washington. The Hippocratic Oath is a main component of the argument of legalization of euthanasia for its opponents. The oath was believed to be written by Hippocrates in the 4th century (Uhlmann 258). It requires a new physician to swear upon a number of healing gods that he will uphold professional ethical standards. It also strongly binds the student to his teacher, and to the greater community of physicians, with responsibilities similar to that of a family member. The oath explicitly states
Show More

Related Documents: A Right to Die Essay

Right To Die: An Argument On The Right To Die

The argument on the rights to die is highly persuasive and effective to those debating the laws around the issue of PAS. A main argument against our rights to die is based around the idea that those vulnerable to the idea to PAS may be coerced into taking this option rather than exploring the options available. This opinion is correct to a certain extent, however the persuasiveness of the ‘right to die’ surpasses any argument given. A right to die is only something a person considers when faced with…

Words 176 - Pages 1

Right To Die

Should we have the right to end our lives? What if you are terminally ill or have a disease that cant be cured? Would you live like this? This is an issue that has been argued throughout the United States. While many believe it’s an act of suicide, others believe we have the right to decide what to do to with our body. Having the right to die should be legalized. In the medical field, doctors experience many sick patients that don’t want to live with pain. Patients that have a terminal sickness…

Words 391 - Pages 2

The Right To Die

The Right to Die Whether or not to legalize physician-assisted suicide is a controversial issue debated today. Many people believe that “it is inhumane, cruel and even barbaric to make a suffering person, whose death is inevitable, live longer than he or she wishes” (McCuen 101). The state of Florida should pass an initiative allowing physician-assisted suicide, but for reasons much more logical and rational than it simply being inhumane. One major reason why this initiative should be passed in…

Words 1245 - Pages 5

The Right to Die Essay

The Right To Die A couple of years ago my mom’s friend Patty was diagnosed with a deadly disease called multiple sclerosis which they had no treatment for and was slowly eating her insides away. She had always that she didn’t want to suffer to this horrible disease and wanted to be put out once it reached a certain point. The only problem is that in the state of Florida you aren’t allowed to have a physician aid you in giving medication to kill someone or also known as Euthanasia. So in order…

Words 1155 - Pages 5

Right to Die Essay

Garza 1 Valerie Garza Ms. E. Guevara English II T/Th 2nd 6 February, 2015 Right to Die About five years ago, my grandmother was diagnosed with Melanoma. She was given a year to live, and in that one year, it advanced aggressively. Her strength faded, the light in her eyes dimmed, and she was no longer the carefree, patient grandmother my siblings and I grew up with. Those last twelve months were spent in and out of the hospital and eventually hospice. She was in very noticeable pain,…

Words 1331 - Pages 6

The Right to Die Essay

The Right to Die As American citizens, we are guaranteed certain indisputable rights, defined in the Declaration of Independence: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.” Yet, thousands of terminally ill patients are being denied these essential democratic rights as they determine end of life care. Doctor assisted suicide is an…

Words 938 - Pages 4

The right to die Essay

The right to die It is your 189th day in hospital; 4536 hours looking at the same lemon-coloured walls, the same 30 uneven ceiling tiles, the same blinking florescent light. You are barely able to move, talk or even look at your family. Every second of your life is spent in unimaginable pain and there is nothing you can to do to stop it. From now on, every single day for the rest of your life you will be waiting for the release of death to finally take the agony away. You can see the stress and…

Words 955 - Pages 4

Persuasive Essay On The Right To Die

others feel that by ending a terminally ill patient’s suffering, they are helping that patient avoid a drawn out and painful death. In “The Right to Die” author Howard ball writes, “When a competent, terminally ill patient’s pain and suffering is intolerable, using PAD trumps the state’s interest in preserving that patient’s life” (21).…

Words 454 - Pages 2

Right To Die Movement Research Paper

The “right to die movement” has been a controversial topic worldwide. This movement has left many American with questions, and has been a difficult topic for people to decide if they are pro or con. Dr. Jack Kevorkian was a physician who assisted his terminal ill patients to committee suicide even though people did not agree with Kevorkian actions he strongly believed in euthanasia. Kastanbaum defines euthanasia as “good or happy death” (Kastenbaum, 270). Kastenbaum states that, “Many people in…

Words 1064 - Pages 5

The Medical Professionals Influence On The Right To Die Movement

The Medical Professionals Influence on the Right-to-Die Movement Michelle Rand (7805388) March 31st, 2015 Introduction As humans, we often question the amount of control that we have over our own lives; do we make all the decisions, or is our life in the hands of somebody else? The Right to Die Movement addresses this idea through the belief that individuals should ultimately control the time and circumstances of their own death. The movement fights for the opportunity of both…

Words 2667 - Pages 11