A Soldiers Load Essay

Submitted By dubbz891
Words: 585
Pages: 3
Open Document
Marshall identified an over exaggerating limitation, somewhat a universal factor, on logistics and combat mobility – the amount of equipment and supplies an average man might carry into combat. Obvious points came out early in the writing. There is no dispute that a less weighed down soldier moves quicker on the battlefield. However Marshall stepped up another point, which is much less obvious. “Overloading has never steadied any man or made him more courageous.” (page 8) Perhaps more to the point, “Tired men take fright more easily. Frightened men swiftly tire.” (page 46) In Marshall’s view, there was a clear link between fear and fatigue. Or perhaps with our present day vocabulary applied, physical and mental stress have a massive effect. Marshall proposed practical limitations on what soldiers should carry into combat.

Ammunition? Well, drawing on accounts from the World Wars, Marshall contended the average foot soldier arrived on the battle line with up to ten times the number of rounds needed in action. Field Marshall Helmuth von Moktke (the younger) determined pre-World War I German soldiers required a load of 200 rounds. In World War I, U.S. soldiers assaulted beaches with 80 rounds plus eight hand grenades. All too much, said Marshall. Based on expenditures within the first day of combat, Marshall indicated the load could be cut in half. And note for effect, Marshall’s ammunition consumption rates match to those mentioned by Whittaker for mounted operation during the Civil War. However, Marshall would certainly argue against the eighty rounds Whittaker suggested as a trooper’s load. Then again, Whittaker wrote at a time when horseflesh, not internal combustion engines, carried resupply.Food and Water? In a statement that runs against every “take care of your troops” leadership lesson, Marshall contends that troops should carry less than a day’s ration into combat… we learned by actual survey on the battlefield that only some three per cent of the men along the combat line touched any food at all in the first day’s fighting. And that water consumption was only a fifth what it became on the second day and thereafter. Such is the economy that can be achieved by virtue of a churning stomach. (page 10) Ouch! And personally I would contend that hunger factors into physical and to a degree mental fatigue. Yet on the other hand, did not the Texas
Show More

Related Documents: A Soldiers Load Essay

Essay The Boston Masacre

Hey at Least it Wasn’t During a Marathon On March 5 1770 in Boston, hostilities that had been brewing for nearly a decade boiled over in a confrontation between a riotous crowd of colonists and a handful of British soldiers, that has become known as the Boston Massacre. Leading the ordinance of soldiers that fired on the colonials was a man named Thomas Preston, Captain. Whether or not Captain Preston was guilty of murder is a question that has plagued historians for centuries. Using several documen…

Words 1241 - Pages 5

Essay about Tim O'Brien 2009 English Mr Phelt Jones

greatly. At that time war also covered the hall nation with negativity as of media lies and political views with bad views. The new Americans were talking about Vietnam War that had taken a lot of American soldiers into both a dangerous war against a faraway world country. Also an American soldier, the veteran, Tim O’Brien created much of his experience in the Vietnam War through his short stories. Mr. O’Brien demonstrated ought through a war he always disliked. Many great experiences from Tim…

Words 1239 - Pages 5

How Does Tim O Brien Use Repetition In The Things They Carried

Vietnam war. the setting of the story is in the jungle. Tim O'Brien not only repeats scenes, and list of items carried by the soldiers throughout the story, but the word “carry and “weight” are repeated over 150 times. Because he wants to show that war is filled with physical and mental loads. One technique used by Tim O’Brien is the use of repetition. O’Brien in his story mostly retells certain events. For example, O’Brien repeats…

Words 412 - Pages 2

Boston Massacre Research Paper

handful of soldiers. Due to the crowds' behavior and their blaring noises, one of the soldiers mistook one of their voices as a command to fire their weapon. One of the first victims of this shooting was Crispus Attucks. At the trial, both Kilroy and Montgomery were charged with murder. The fault of the Boston Massacre was caused by the soldiers on duty. One of the main arguments in this event was the false command to fire their guns. No orders were given once or ever for the soldiers to fire their…

Words 530 - Pages 3

Ted Lavender Character Analysis

O’Brien always reiterates the story of Ted Lavender’s death. He mentions it multiple times, especially at odd places. For example, when the soldiers are relaxed and cracking up jokes, Ted states “They were waiting for Lavender's chopper, smoking the dead man's dope” (O’Brien 8). The death of Lavender significantly affected Tim especially since he was still a young man with his life ahead of him. Actually according to Tim, Lavender was afraid and never cut out for war “Ted Lavender, who was scared…

Words 177 - Pages 1

Soldiers In The Things They Carried Essay

In the short story, “The Things They Carried”, the soldiers portrayed in the story carry a colossal amount of tangible and intangible weight on their mission. They carry the basic essentials and the least amount of stuff possible to live, it all depends on the soldier. As well as the physical weight, the men also carry things like fear, grief, love and thought, which is the main focal point of the story. Although these men are soldiers in battle, everyone carries a similar emotional weight along…

Words 602 - Pages 3

Weapons In The Civil War

many weapons including canons, guns, knives, swords, etc. With the knives and swords, obviously, they were manufactured differently than the cannons and guns with actual ammunition. With the swords and knives, the soldiers had them safely secure in their pouches and cases. The soldiers used these weapons to stab, wound, and kill their enemies and to come…

Words 254 - Pages 2

Weapons In The Civil War Essay

“to catch them on blankets and throw them back at the northern troops” (Andrews). Landmines, known as torpedoes during this era, were used by the southern soldiers. The “northern troops considered these weapons as barbaric” and not a true form of combat (Andrews). Therefore, the northern troops retaliated by using captured southern soldiers to march in front of them to detonate any possible landmines in their path. Hot air balloons were used during the Civil War as a “weapon of reconnaissance”…

Words 975 - Pages 4

American Revolution Dbq

colonists, who decided to fight back or the patriots, started a movement that lead to the American Revolution. The American Revolution began on April 19, 1775, and ended on September 3, 1783 . There were many battles in which both patriots, and British soldiers put their lives out on the line for their country. The battle locations ranged from way up north in Quebec, Canada, to way down south in Savannah, Georgia . Of the many battles, all but two or three of them were fought using traditional linear tactics…

Words 2063 - Pages 9

Essay about Right-wing Politics and Click

http://1759.ccbn-nbc.gc.ca/ click on ‘From the Warpath to the Plains of Abraham’. Follow the instructions on your Webquest assignment sheet and answer the questions in point form. Be patient, some of the pages/activities may take a minute to load. Group 2: The British 1. Click on the section of the circle titled ‘Impasse in the British Court’ and follow the instructions provided. 2. Click on man in the portrait in the top right corner of your screen. What is…

Words 607 - Pages 3