A Few Good Men

Words: 1451
Pages: 6
Open Document
Disobedience and obedience is something commonly exhibited in humans, from teenagers constantly disagreeing with what parents think is best, to elementary children following directions to get some sort of reward that lays down the foundation for learning. Why is it that people obey and disobey, what is it that causes us to obey rather than disobey, or to disobey versus obey. What time is it that tunnel vision is developed and focused only on a higher authority; when is it alright to disobey the demands given by the authority? Several factors go into why people obey others, out of respect, position in a hierarchy, or love. In the article "Disobedience as a Psychological and Moral Problem" by Erich Fromm, He speaks about how obedience is established …show more content…
In the movie A Few Good Men, W. Dawson kept several of the other guys from giving T. Santiago a "Code Red" even when T. Santiago's behavior would deserve a "Code Red." What T. Santiago did was irrelevant and didn't matter, as Dawson would not stand for any of the other men performing a "Code Red" on Santiago. Dawson had recently been in trouble for firing his weapon, and this lead to where he was at risk of losing his job in Guantanamo Bay, when R. Jessup, someone of much higher power than Dawson, demanded orders that Santiago be given a "Code Red" Dawson did not have much choice in the matter, except give Santiago the "Code Red" as he was at fear of losing his job. (A Few Good …show more content…
This is not the case as there are several things that factor into people's choices, things such as whether the order is immoral or moral, or the order may be too dangerous to themselves or the people around as well. As the people in power want to believe that the power they have supreme power over them, and the ones that follow and grant the power to these hierarchy K9s want to be able to trust the ones in these positions; and that the actions and decision they make will be inadvisable interest for everyone else. In the publication "The Power Trip" Jonah Lehrer talks about a study presented by Adam Galinsky, who is a psychologist at Northwestern University. In the study, half a group was to play a dice rolling game, whatever number they rolled on the dice they got that amount of lottery tickets. It was shown that they got an average dice roll that was 20% more than what was to be expected on a random dice roll. The other group was asked to rate how bad lying on business travel expenses at work was, many agreed that it was against moral norms (Lehrer
Show More

Related Documents: A Few Good Men

A Few Good Men Monologue

A Few Good Men Journal: Colonel Jessup is responsible for the death of Private Santiago because he was the one the ordered the “Code Red.” It was his order that made Dawson and Downey commit the crime, because they were in a position where “they follow orders or people die.” I understand that Jessup was not the person that did the action of murdering Private Santiago, but it was his intentions that led to the death of Willie. While there might be a few people that see Jessup as innocent, because…

Words 275 - Pages 2

A Few Good Men Summary

The main character, Mike Arroyo, moved from Puerto Rico to New York City to play baseball. Everything was all fun and games until if he ever got found out that he and his brother were in foster care and cannot play baseball anymore… Michael moves from Puerto Rico to New York because his father died and they were forced to escape Cuba. Michael plays for an ALL-STAR team for New York and gets found out by other coaches that he should not be in the USA. Michael and his 17 year old brother get adopted…

Words 701 - Pages 3

A Few Good Men Rhetorical Analysis

Word of the day is handle. Defined as a part that is designed to be grasped or understood. The line that most of us remember from the movie "A Few Good Men" is "You can't handle the truth." I believe in speaking truth to people. Even when it is a hard conversation, you still need to speak truth, but also make sure that the person is in a position to receive what you are saying. If they are not willing or in a position to accept it, you are just talking and it could cause confusion versus helping…

Words 412 - Pages 2

Essay on A Few Good Men - Honor

that is earned through deeds and reputation. But, what is honor, and how does one receive it? Honor is like many things that are hard to put into words. Along with that, honor can be totally different, depending on your perspective. In the play, A Few Good Men, there is a central theme based around honor, who is doing right and who is doing wrong. The definitions of honor accepted by each person are so outstandingly conflicting that the play analyzes what honor is and at what cost is honor worth obtaining…

Words 898 - Pages 4

A Few Good Men Rhetorical Analysis

around us, lots of help above us. All we need to worry about is our one little piece, just the way we rehearsed it.” This passage takes place in the final chapter of the book, here Juan is talking to his platoon before making a drop. These final few words from Juan show that he now fully realizes that they are a part of a much larger team. His platoon is just one small moving piece of a much larger war machine. Shortly after this line, before deploying from the ship to combat, the ship’s captain…

Words 718 - Pages 3

Arrogance In A Few Good Men And Oedipus The King

There are hundreds of character traits that can used to describe a character. Some of these traits lead them to become heroes, but others can lead to a character’s undoing. In the plays A Few Good Men by Andrew Sorkin and Oedipus The King by Sophocles, both authors use the actions of two leaders, Oedipus and Jessup, to demonstrate that having arrogance and an inflated sense of self importance causes a person to think illogically, ultimately inciting their own downfall. To help support this idea…

Words 903 - Pages 4

Essay about TESTER BUTTY?

Why did the men of this era, 1600-1770, call the age the Enlightenment? During this age of the Enlightment because the men at this ear felt they were "Enlightned" group. They believed they were coming to grips with the age old problem of humans. THey had the beliefs that they had come closer to any other age to figure out how the universe and man worked and how to live more resonably and a good life. The Enlightenment era was a new intellectual movement that stressed reason and thought…

Words 4382 - Pages 18

Essay on Appearance Vs Reality

learn how to be able not to be good, and to use or not use this ability according to circumstances” (72). 2. “He should not concerned bad if he needs them to save his state. For there are cases in which people might think a certain path is valorous, but following it would be the prince’s ruin, while there are also cases in which a certain way might seem evil, but following it will be result in the prince’s safety and well-being” (73). 3. “I propose that it is good to be generous. And yet generosity…

Words 683 - Pages 3

The My Lai Massacre Sources Of Sadism Analysis

77). They would punish and humiliate their prisoners in cruel and odd ways, only because they didn’t realize the issues with what they were doing. This, inadvertently landed them in court as well on the same charges as the My Lai soldiers. In A Few Good Men, Dawson fulfilled the command from his officer without thinking of the consequences that could come with the code red. Dawson and Downey were told to carry out a code red and train the soldier to be more like a marine. They thought they were just…

Words 1253 - Pages 6

Ethos In King Henry

honor, and kinship. King Henry uses ethos to persuade his men to fight the French, although they are outnumbered of men in the battle. Henry’s speech is effective because he has strong ethos and pathos. Henry notes that his troops feel overwhelmed and unprepared for the battle against the French. He seizes the moment to inspire his men and prepare them. First, one should focus on the language and Henry’s ethos. Henry tries to show his men of what will become of them after the battle. This works on…

Words 846 - Pages 4