Abortion and Human Life Essay

Submitted By NkosilathiS1
Words: 3189
Pages: 13
Open Document
Nkosilathi Shangwa
David Hershinow
WRI 169: Taboos and Transgressions
02-12-14
The personhood of a bunch of cells.
Busi was missing for a week and four days before they found her propped against a tree in the woods. She had died after attempting to abort an unwanted pregnancy that she had managed to hide from everybody who knew her by sticking a wire coat hanger into her uterus. Busi was my cousin and she was one of the many women around the world who have died after attempting to perform abortions that are not legal in their places of residence for a variety of reasons.
There are many reasons why abortion is frowned upon by many societies in the world including religious objections, ethical considerations and legal constraints. There has been a raging debate about abortion in the United States ever since the Supreme Court decided Roe vs Wade in 1973 and many facets of the debate have been exposed. Abortion has been decried as an extension of the patriarchy’s continued denial of women’s freedoms as feminists have argued that it is up to a woman to decide whether or not to be a mother. Moralistic arguments against abortion have been made by many a religious organisation including particularly graphic campaigns by Priests for Life, a Catholic pro-life group and Advocates of life. There is a raging debate among scholars about when exactly the fetus becomes a person that can, and has to be afforded full legal protections. In a world where one woman dies every seven minute because of an unsafe and illegal abortion procedure, the debate around legalization of abortion seems almost unnecessary. In essence, making abortion more accessible would save thousands of lives of productive members of society. Feminists such as Katha Pollitt argue that abortion is an extension of the reproductive freedoms that have long being denied to women by patriarchal society, and it would certainly seem to benefit the women at risk of complications from unsanctioned abortion procedures if abortion were legalised. Therefore it becomes the debate comes down to a battle between the rights of a woman, and those of a foetus she is carrying, which antiabortion scholars would rather refer to as a baby. On one side, there are antiabortion activists who say that the right to life of the foetus supersedes any discomfort a woman might have about carrying a child to term. On the other hand, there are prochoice activists who insist that pregnancy and birth should be a woman’s decision, as it is her body that will be the vehicle of this child that antiabortion activists attach so much importance to. I am of the opinion that limiting the choices a woman a woman makes about her own life and body from the perspective of a moralistic viewpoint that is not infallible is a crime against the rights of women and hence abortion should be legalised.
To fully understand the viewpoint of both sides of the argument, we need to consider one issue that is used by both camps to justify their position; the personhood of the foetus. From the perspective of one pro-life proponent, Randy Alcorn, the debate around the personhood of fetuses necessitates efforts to protect the fetus because of the “possibility” that it may be a person. On the other hand various scholars such as Jason T. Eberl argue that the personhood of fetuses is not at all dependent on the foetus itself being alive but rather depends on when the foetus becomes an individual. The argument is then extended to when exactly the fetus ceases to be a cluster of biological cells and exists as an entity that might be considered human. To answer this question, arguments have been made by both pro-life proponents and pro-choice activists that draw from theology, philosophy, law and science. In this paper I shall lay out the arguments that are made by both sides and seek to show that while both sides have invaluable opinions on the matter, the facts, when viewed from a utilitarian perspective show that the questionability
Show More

Related Documents: Abortion and Human Life Essay

Abortion: Pregnancy and Human Life Essay

Abortion is a very controversial issue in the sense that it unmoral and should be illegal. The Catholic Church believes and teaches that the killing of an unborn child is the same as the killing of a full grown human, which is immoral. One question that many have is “When does life begin and is it considered a human being or just an embryo?” By looking at the views on the topic of abortion we can better understand why abortion is not right and is unmoral. An abortion is a big decision that many…

Words 1355 - Pages 6

Abortion: Pro-choice and Human Life Essay

Abortion Right or Wrong? Abortion is defined as: "the termination of pregnancy and expulsion of an embryo or of a fetus that is incapable of survival." However, if only the debate over the abortion issue was as simple as the definition provided above. Much like every aspect of human life, a statement is neither right nor wrong, but simply left open for someone to interpret it. There is no black and white in life, only gray areas that are hard to figure out. Some issues tend to provide us more gray…

Words 913 - Pages 4

Essay on Abortion: Pregnancy and Value Human Life

One of the best ways to tackle pro-life arguments against abortion is by having the mother-to-be put herself in the place of the child. If her mother had made the same decision that she does, she would not be here today. Also, females who are having a difficult time with an unwanted pregnancy need to understand that they are not alone. Counseling must be proactive in trying to provide options that value human life. Options are available to those who need and want them. Information on the Internet…

Words 386 - Pages 2

Persuasive Essay Against Abortion

What is abortion? Abortion is ending of pregnancy by medicine or surgical procedure. Abortion is legal in the United States from 1973. Abortion is one of the most questionable and arguable issues for more than three decades. The reason of that, there are some people fully against it and the others think that women have the right to choose and to do whatever they want with their selves. When it comes to abortion, there are two sides (groups) of people, people who are opposite it or against it and…

Words 1362 - Pages 6

Abortion 2 Essay

Pro-Life Cassidy Fultz Do you think killing an innocent human being is ok? Is it ok to deliberately destroy a life? Abortion is a controversial topic thrown around whether it should be illegal or legal. There are two categories abortion breaks up into: Pro-life or Pro-choice. Pro-life supporters believe abortion should be illegal and is unjust. Pro-choice supporters believe that abortions should be legal and it is an individual right. Every individual is genetically unique at fertilization…

Words 2667 - Pages 11

Santo wk5 Abortion Arguement Essay

An Abortion Argument Monica Santo PHI 103 Instructor Cornell Horn September 30, 2013 An Abortion Argument Abortion is a hot issue in the United States today. Abortion is currently legal in all 50 states however; some states have a 20-week ban law. This law bans all abortions after 20 weeks of a woman’s last menstrual period and only allows for exceptions in cases where a woman’s life is threatened. Folks on both sides of the isle on the abortion issue are extremely passionate about their views…

Words 1554 - Pages 7

Moral Concerns On Abortion During The Development Of The Foetus (Unborn)

ABORTION IS A HARROWING ACT! In this assignment I am going to look at the moral aspect concerns on abortion during the development of the foetus (unborn), and how this has been perceived and criticized by individuals and philosophers. Abortion has been defined as the act that a woman performs in voluntarily terminating, or allowing another person to terminate her pregnancy and the legal status that is appropriate for this act (English 1975). Warren’s (1973) understanding of abortion however…

Words 833 - Pages 4

Pro-Life Vs. Pro Life Induced Abortion

Induced abortion is the deliberate termination of baby before it’s birth. Spontaneous abortions are called miscarriages. It is a controversial topic with different cultural, religious and individual perspectives, those who are against the idea and wish for it to be illegal, those who believe it should be resisted and those who feel it should be legal and freely accessible. It is an ongoing debate whether it should be legal, the rights of the foetus and the woman’s rights over her own body. People…

Words 741 - Pages 3

Essay on Abortion Is a Form of Murder

hundred women aged fifteen to forty-four have an abortion, 48 % of them have had at least one previous abortion and 61% percent have had a previous birth. This means that these women understand the joy of a baby being born, and still choose to take away their privilege to live. They’ve carried these children before and know the happiness of seeing their own healthy child in their arms for the first time. Why then, when they know they are creating a new life inside of them, do they choose to deprive their…

Words 1775 - Pages 8

Fight Over Abortion Essay

One of the most heated debates that have lasted for a few decades now, is whether abortion should be allowed or not. Whether legally it is a woman’s choice or not; is it her right as a human being or blasphemy, of such magnitude that no amount of Hail Mary’s would be enough for the absolution. Typically, this debate, or rather fight, has been fought between the so called “science” and so called “religion”. The fight between religion and science is not a new one. It has been there since the birth…

Words 1655 - Pages 7