Arguments Against Drug Testing

Words: 903

Pages: 4

Open Document

Over a four month period, the state of Florida paid out $118,140 to drug test welfare recipients. That resulted in paying out $45,780 more in tax payer dollars than they would have paid to provide benefits to the 2.6% of beneficiaries that failed the drug test. America has been debating drug testing welfare recipients for years now, some Americans think that screening out drug users will save tax dollars in the long run, while others believe it will only be detrimental in a variety of ways. Drug testing our welfare beneficiaries is unconstitutional, costly, and detrimental to individuals and families. One of the main arguments for drug testing welfare beneficiaries is that it will save tax payer dollars. This would be true if states were able to remove substantial numbers of people from programs. By removing drug users from assistance programs, those dollars could be put to better use in other assistance programs or even into infastructure or healthcare. Removing a substantial number drug users would absolutely take a hefty burden off of our assistance programs. …show more content…
States are actually paying more to drug test recipients than they would be to continue paying their benefits. As stated above, Florida paid nearly $46,000 more to drug test than they would have to just continue fulfilling benefits over four months. Several other states had the same results. The idea that there is a large number of drug addicts using our assistance programs is proving to not be true. By drug testing recipients, we are only able to discover and remove very few people from the programs, and wasting money testing those who are clean. Besides that, it is wasting beneficiaries time that they could be using at school or work or looking for

Arguments Against Suspicionless Drug Testing

Drug testing is everywhere, there are many people who have their privacy invaded and civil rights violated due to suspicionless drug testing such as employees, students, and welfare recipients. Drug testing for no individualized reason for suspicion is unconstitutional and is also a violation of civil rights. There are strong arguments on both sides of the drug testing issue because on one hand some argue that drug tests should be allowed because drugs are illegal and that it gives people a reason…

Words 940 - Pages 4

Arguments Against Welfare Drug Testing

Controversies article “Welfare Drug Testing: Should the government require that welfare recipients take drug tests?” the two sides of the argument are given. Most people oppose to the recipients being drug tested. Issues & Controversies states, “Welfare drug-testing efforts have faced legal challenges from recipients who argue that such tests violate the Fourth Amendment to…

Words 572 - Pages 3

Research Report Essay

I. Should animal testing be permitted? A. In the past years, we have tested our research/etc. on animals. They use animals to ensure that products are safe and easy to use and not let anything hazardous happen. B. Most people believe that it’s ok to just use what apart of this earth and just use and get rid of it like its nothing… I personally think it’s a crazy thing to do! That’s why I’m arguing against it. C. People who are against animal testing base off their contentions on the fact…

Words 407 - Pages 2

Drug Testing In Schools

floating around: Should we drug test in schools or not? Does it affect the student's rights and is it appropriate for schools to do this? Drug testing in schools have been thought of as either a good or bad thing but hasn't really met in the middle. Throughout my research I have done, I have came up with a way to drug test students without affecting their rights, and privacy. Argument side A is going against drug testing in schools. Its argues that drug testing is completely against student rights. This…

Words 775 - Pages 4

The hazards of drug testing on welfare Essay

24 April 2013 The Hazards of Drug Testing for Welfare The establishment of welfare has proven to make a positive influence on thousands of Americans’ lives. The argument that is now surfacing is whether drug testing should or should not be required for welfare recipients. There is cause for pause because both sides to this argument have good view points. Today, each state is given a check by the federal government and is then in charge of distributing the money to each welfare recipient. This…

Words 736 - Pages 3

Should Animal Testing Be Banned Essay

Animal testing should be banned in the U.S. and all over the world. Everyday somewhere all over the world a innocent animal is abducted, abused, or abandoned. Animals are abducted from people's yards and taken to be sold to laboratories for experimenting. In these laboratories the animals are abused and neglected. Everyday somewhere in the world people capture abandoned animals on the streets that are just trying to survive to sell to laboratories. These helpless animals do not deserve to be treated…

Words 554 - Pages 3

Essay on Drugs: Anabolic Steroid and Athletes

Michael P. McGarry ENG 123 April ’15 Term Student ID: 2167022 Performance Enhancing Drugs Major League Baseballs Barry Bonds denies ever knowingly using steroids and has never tested positive for steroid use, however, many people believe that Bonds has been using steroids and other PEDs for years. Because of the suspicion of PED use, these fans discredit Bonds’ baseball accomplishments. In 1998, Mark McGuire broke Roger Maris’ record for most home runs hit in a single season. Despite his record-breaking…

Words 1777 - Pages 8

The Medical Secrets Essay

Saul Zendejas March 10, 2011 The Medical Secrets Many would say that great discoveries in medical science where made through testing with animals but the things that are never talked about are the things they did to the animals they tested with or how many countless animals died in the process. There are many other things that can be used to obtain answers on diseases, viruses, or other harmful organisms. The creatures that suffer in these are most likely to die or get killed after they are done…

Words 1107 - Pages 5

Drug Testing Argumentative Analysis

schools is drug testing. The argument whether or not to allow this action has been ongoing for quite a few years, but has become a more popular topic lately. The problem is trying to find a common ground for both sides. Some believe that mandatory drug testing is necessary in order to fix the issue of teens and drug use. Others believe that there shouldn’t be drug testing. Many believe that teens are capable of finding “loop holes” and still be able to consume drugs before the next drug testing date and…

Words 1221 - Pages 5

4th Amendment In School

the other? In both these cases drugs play a large role in the court case. Both the cases involve young students and they are both cases about invasions of privacy and fourth amendment rights. In the first case it was decided that student’s fourth amendment rights are different when enrolled in public schools this effected the decision the Veronica v. Action case. They are also both cases where the Supreme Court rules in favor of the school. 3. What are the main arguments for each side in the Vernonia…

Words 699 - Pages 3