Arguments Against Preventative Force

Words: 2013
Pages: 9
Open Document
Britton Mehanna Mrs. Spencer Writing Seminar 10 21 February 2024 The Argument Against Preventative Force Rough Draft Every individual possesses limitless potential. It is up to individuals to determine whether this potential will lead to extraordinary achievements or catastrophic consequences based on how they channel and manifest this potential according to their beliefs and aspirations. The potential for future violent events within society is an equal threat and it is minimized by several preventative measures to preserve the state in the wake of violent events within society. As seen in post-9/11 society, Americans were traumatized by the threat of another terrorist attack, thusly stating that the Department of Justice's "single objective …show more content…
By continuously monitoring and surveying every aspect of individuals' lives, such a system undermines the very essence of autonomy and free will. The ability to autonomously make choices becomes threatened, limiting the range of our thoughts and actions. In essence, this approach not only adds constraints to personal freedom but also obstructs the development of society by imposing rigid constraints on individual liberties: "Freedom is not conceived negatively as the absence of external coercion or constraints. Rather, it is defined positively in terms of the exercise of self-influence" (Bandura 1182). Furthermore, implementing preventative justice would inevitably lead to violating numerous fundamental rights by placing restraints on personal freedom. As important as the state may be, it should primarily exist to safeguard the rights and interests of its citizens, rather than prioritizing its preservation at the expense of individual citizens. Fundamentally, the notion that a preventative justice system could safeguard society is flawed, as it places the state above the very individuals it should …show more content…
Unthinkingly invoking this duty could lead to abuses of power, where leaders exploit vague notions of "imminent danger" to give themselves more control (Kaufman 23). Furthermore, protection must be balanced against the principles of justice and fairness. A government's duty to protect its citizens should not override the rights of those citizens to freedom of expression, privacy, and due process. It is essential to realise that significant differences in interpreting what constitutes a threat can vary depending on those in power. This could lead to unjustified violations of fundamental human rights. Thus, it is imperative to establish clear and transparent criteria for determining when intervention is necessary. Decisions should be made with full respect for individual rights because every person has an intrinsic worth that others should recognize. Prioritizing the protection of citizens will result in authoritarian and communist styles of government where the very freedoms they seek to protect are removed (Fuster
Show More

Related Documents: Arguments Against Preventative Force

Holocaust Comparison

taught to feel a certain way about collective memories of trauma due to their dynamic nature, comparison can be instrumental in preventing future tragedies. Whigham’s argument has a much broader scope than Baum’s. He is arguing for comparison of all collective memories of trauma, rather than just Holocaust comparison. However, both arguments rely on the existence of obligatory emotions of empathy towards persecuted groups to produce a productive comparison. Whigham and Baum agree that historical comparison…

Words 1350 - Pages 6

Neoliberalism

Resurrecting Hope in Dark Times”, written by widely published cultural critic Henry Giroux, is an emotive yet one-sided argument on the dangers of neoliberalism in the early 21st century. While Giroux thoroughly interrogates the dangers of neoliberalism as a pervasive ideology, he falls short of resurrecting hope of combating it as, by failing to consider opposing views, his argument comes across more as radical democratic propaganda than as an articulated, balanced academic piece. Giroux begins with…

Words 722 - Pages 3

Drug Store Solution Essay examples

and the horrendous results of teenage pregnancy. They learn about the responsibilities of having a child, how hard it is, and all of the different easy ways having a child can be easily prevented. The problem is, how readily available are those preventative methods for a teenager? Birth control is the most effective way to prevent an unwanted pregnancy. Most sexually active teenagers think about and want to be on birth control, but are not able to attain this because most effective birth control…

Words 1048 - Pages 5

History Of Reproductive Health

Executive summary: As part of the Affordable Care Act (ACA), private insurance plans must cover contraceptive methods and preventative services for women including: counseling, well-woman testing, diabetes screening and prenatal care without a copay (some exclusions apply). This law positively influences women’s healthcare empowerment and is a milestone for women’s preventative health. History: Reproductive health has always been a concern ranging from: fertility, birth control, sexually transmitted…

Words 2787 - Pages 12

PHDHPE HSC Sports Medicine Essay

PDHPE – HSC – Sports Medicine How are sports injuries classified and managed? - Direct and Indirect Direct are caused by an external force to the body. Example collision, Area of contact will be injured; this could lead to fracture, dislocations or sprains. I Indirect caused by an intrinsic force (Within the body), Normally occur from extensive movements, fault in execution, ballistic movement. Result of extensive strain on mussels, ligaments or tendons. Example: muscle tear. -Soft and…

Words 2303 - Pages 10

Human Rights and Young People Essay

According to Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights Human rights inherent to all human beings, whatever our such as the rights to development and self determination” Although human rights is innate in all people the argument is, how can human rights be implement when we all born with a free will? According to Stanford Encyclopaedia of Philosophy “Free will relates to a particular sort of capacity of rational agents to choose a course of action nationality, place of…

Words 3050 - Pages 13

International Conflict Essay

The decision of going to war is not only made by a leader. For a president to declare war against other country there must be provocative reasons and an approval of public and other political figures (congress members). States’ Internal characteristics are another considered explanation to war. Poverty and the level of economic development is…

Words 2803 - Pages 12

Rpta 205 Final Study Guide Essay

disagreements with the use of specific conflict resolution skills. Conflict transformation- moments in the conflict process when parties reach new understandings- of self, others, goal. The Struggle Spectrum Mild difference Disagreement Argument Campaign Litigation Fight Escalation- raised voices, make self larger, personal space invaded, more people, past conflicts, feeling threatened, De-escalation- calm voices, define conflict as mutual problem, sit down… Sources of Conflict…

Words 1859 - Pages 8

Labour Relation Essay examples

Case Scenario Written by Charles Purchase, Seneca College Phil Stone has been a union organizer for 15 years. He recently targeted a firm in the garment industry. Up to this point he has had informal discussions with a few of the company’s four hundred employees so that he can get a better feel for the chances of succeeding in the organizing drive. Phil is aware that he does not face a ‘slam dunk’ in this situation and his prediction is that the certification vote could be very close. He is…

Words 3814 - Pages 16

Mandatory Vaccination Research

school settings is fueled by divergent beliefs about individual rights and public health mandates. Supporters of the law contend that it protects the rights of parents and safeguards religious and philosophical convictions. On the other hand, those against the bill argue that vaccination is the key to building public immunity and that the safety of the community should never be compromised. The best approach is to be able to reconcile the two antagonistic parts of the issue in a way that allows both…

Words 1601 - Pages 7