Arguments Against Research On Non Competent People Essays

Submitted By pa99
Words: 426
Pages: 2
Open Document
Arguments against research on non-competent people

The topic of research amongst individuals who are deemed non-competent is ethically controversial. According to Wolbring (1999) allowing for high-risk and non-beneficial research on non-competent people can result in serious abuse. From the 1930’s up until the 1970’s researchers had been recruiting black males to participate in the study of syphilis. The researchers had told these men that they were receiving treatment when in fact at the time syphilis was untreatable. The purpose of this study was to see the effects of syphilis on the human body over time (Emanual, Abdoler, & Stunkel, 2006). The example demonstrates how researchers have the ability to act unethically and exploit their human subjects to serious abuse and long term disability simply for the sake of research. In the case of teenagers, due to their non-competence parents will often assume the role of decision maker for that child. The ethical dilemma with non-competent youth is that parents may bribe their child in order to participate in certain research studies (A handbook for Human Research Ethics, 2010). As well as the issue of bribery from parents, youth who have substance abuse issues or are homeless may be compelled to participate in dangerous studies for the sake of financial compensation. According to the handbook for Human Research Ethics (2010) Youth with addiction may use the money they receive to further support their habit as well as the substance abuse may interfere with their ability to make appropriate decisions. Individuals who are non-competent are an extremely vulnerable group because they can be easily taken advantage of and mislead. When conducting research on this cohort of
Show More

Related Documents: Arguments Against Research On Non Competent People Essays

Philosophy 241 Lecture Note Essay

Lecture agenda Sept. 5, 2013 Announcements: 1. I've been asked to alert you that there's an emergency exit alarm at the door in the far southeast corner of the room. If you activate it, or even open the door, there's an ear-splitting alarm that won't stop until the door is closed again. (Some students thought it was fake and tested it; others just didn't see the exist alarm and opened the door). 2. Reminder: The Socratic Society (undergrad philosophy club) meets every Friday at 7 pm in Memorial…

Words 7807 - Pages 32

The Role Of Autonomy In Medical Decision-Making

Currently many people die waiting for an organ transplant, and there is much evidence that people are generally in favour of donating their organs upon their death yet do not have their organs procured. (1) More specifically, potential donors who are in favour of organ donation either do not take the necessary…

Words 1554 - Pages 7

Institutional Racism In School

San Diego, a white fraternity had a party that was themed “Black People” meaning that members at the party must dress in stereotypical black outfits and act as a stereotypical black person would act. The party was not taken lightly and was seen all over the news and made all the students at UCSD be perceived as racist. Not only was this a cruel joke to African Americans, but it impacted all the minorities on campus. It made all the non-white students feel uncomfortable since half of the population…

Words 1947 - Pages 8

Essay on teleological argument

The Teleological/Design Argument for the Existence of God Key introductory points The teleological/design argument suggests that the world in which man lives is so complex and ordered (among other characteristics) that it could not have come about by chance. In order for it to be as we currently see the world, it must have been designed, ultimately by a designer whom some call ‘God’. It is an old argument, even predating Christianity. Kant commented that:…

Words 2828 - Pages 12

A Brief Note On Diversity And Cultural Proficiency

13-20) she interviewed in Yonkers, New York believed education was the key to success, jobs and mobility. What these young people resisted, however, was the assumption that to succeed in school one must assimilate into mainstream society to the exclusion of one's own culture. Not wanting to adopt the linguistic and clothing styles of the majority, Carter reported, these young people "struggled with how to maintain culturally authentic selves, while, at the same time, achieve." They responded to this…

Words 2595 - Pages 11

Essay on Ethics in International Business

international business ethics discussions on the question of how to act in the home country as opposed to the host country is at the central point of most international corporations. The argument in question is how companies should practice their business according…

Words 1663 - Pages 7

Essay Structure

Research Essay 2,000 words: Satisfactory 1 The High Court of Australia has ultimate responsibility for interpreting the Constitution in an independent manner. Given this responsibility, how adequate are the current processes and principles of appointment of High Court judges? It’s good to give your paper a title, one that indicates your position Introduction The Governor-General is given the power to appoint judges to the Australian High Court and other courts by the Australian Constitution.1…

Words 4128 - Pages 17

The Criminal Justice System: A Kinesics Study

This essay focus on the study Kinesics in relation to the Criminal Justice system. Throughout the essay there will be in-depth research on history of Kinesics, issues affiliated with Kinesics, the future of Kinesics in the Criminal Justice System. In conclusion, Kinesiology is intricate art of the Criminal Justice System and requires Criminal Justice personnel to have a firm grasp of is concepts in order to work effectively. Introduction The study…

Words 1971 - Pages 8

Research Outline Gay Marriage Essay

benefits are guaranteed or required out of state” (Johnson). “Immigration Rights. Marriage: U.S. citizens and legal residents can sponsor their spouses and family members for immigration. Civil Unions: U.S. citizens and legal residents cannot sponsor non-legal spouses or family members” (Johnson). Public and Political Opinions “According to…

Words 2785 - Pages 12

Essay about Hrm Policies

Q1 “HRM POLICIES AND PRINCIPLES DO NOT CONTRIBUTE TO THE EEFFECTIVENSS, CONTINUITY AND STABILITY OF THE ORGANIZATION” THIS STATMENT IS WORNG Human Resource Management (HRM) is the term used to describe formal systems devised for the management of people within an organization. These human resources responsibilities are generally divided into three major areas of management: staffing, employee compensation, and defining/designing work. Essentially, the purpose of HRM is to maximize the productivity…

Words 10727 - Pages 43